Thursday, November 19, 2026

Nana Patekar Obit


In the 1980s, I had not seen any Nana Patekar movies. He was not that big in Bollywood. But I used to see him in the pages of *Screen*, a film newspaper from the Indian Express Group, which my mother started subscribing to so that we would read English regularly. She knew that filmy gossip attracted young minds more than good literature. I was happy that I started my English reading with film news in *Screen* and *The Trial* by Kafka. Strange! I got that copy of *The Trial* from the attic of a friend's house, where I was browsing through old magazines to find some cartoon books, the predecessors of today's graphic novels.
Nana Patekar is no more, and he was seventy-five. From the pages of *Screen*, I understood that people in Maharashtra used to listen to his Marathi film dialogues repeatedly on recorded cassettes, which they felt roused their patriotism, anti-establishment attitude, and irreverent machismo. If Amitabh Bachchan was rendering his dialogues in a refined Hindi accent in a royal baritone voice, Nana Patekar's 'ranting' or 'rap-like' dialogues hit the local youth in the streets. They were impatient and irreverent.
Those were the heyday of the Shiv Sena, and Bal Thackeray was demanding Maharashtra for Marathis, as he thought the plum posts in the public and private sectors were reserved for educated South Indians. He ranted against the Southies and demanded justice and dignity for the generations of mill workers in the ailing textile industry. Though Nana Patekar later turned against bigotry and fundamentalism, his characters in the early movies were anti-establishment and demanding dignity for ordinary mortals.
The cassettes belted out the poetic rendering of Nana Patekar's long dialogues into the streets, where the nasal tone of his voice found resonance among the milling masses. They thought that Nana Patekar was talking for himself. Then he acted in a movie called *Prahar*, where he portrayed the role of an army soldier, for which he underwent rigorous army training for months. *Rambo* had made its mark on the world's screens in the previous decade. In *Prahar*, Major Chauhan, essayed by Nana Patekar, ruthlessly pulverised the enemies and came out as a true patriot.
Nana Patekar was not hero material in the conventional sense. From the Marathi ethos, he was just the counterweight to Amol Palekar, who always essayed a timid, soft-spoken and dignified middle-class youngster who was always in love. Nana Patekar was rough and street-smart. His big eyes did not show any other emotion than ruthless inquisitiveness. When they were not on fire, they were just cold pieces of suppressed rage, which could turn his deadpan acting style into that of a crazy maniac who could go to any extent to achieve his goals.
The package was just good enough for the streets. If one could compare Nana Patekar with any other international actor, I would put him alongside Denzel Washington, though the latter is in a divine league of actors. Nana Patekar was no less. He could turn his light smile into a smirk and absolute ruthlessness. Both of them have essayed cop parts very well. If Denzel had *Training Day*, Patekar had *Ab Tak Chhappan*. Nana Patekar could have been an international actor. People loved him when he spoke, 'Saala ek macchar aadmi ko hijda banata hai' ('A mosquito could turn a man into a trans-man').
The same eloquence Nana Patekar used when he appeared on Rajat Sharma's *Aap Ki Adaalat*, a popular courtroom-style show, where he recited a poem about 'water' with nonstop rendering and clarity. Ageing had changed his nasal intonation into a more guttural voice, but never took away its charm. Like Denzel, he proved his histrionic power by acting in comedy roles, which later film lovers thought were not really for him, despite his fine comic timing. He needed more meaty roles where he could cut into and take out all his acting craft.
In Baroda, as a student, I escaped in the afternoons into the air-conditioned darkness of a movie hall called 'Rajshree'. It was there that I watched *Krantiveer* and later, in Delhi, *Agni Sakshi*. The latter was a movie that brought out the negative side of an obsessive husband, and Nana Patekar acted convincingly by terrorising a young Manisha Koirala. But those were the days of negative heroes. Shah Rukh Khan's *Darr* and *Baazigar* had made waves. Nana Patekar was no less than Shah Rukh Khan.
Nana Patekar always looked healthy; therefore, his passing sounds very abrupt and unexpected. Looking at his filmography, one can say that he had not acted in so many movies. Even among the movies he acted in, many were eminently forgettable. But the ones that we remember, Nana Patekar had given his best. He has earned his name, and that is going to be etched in our minds so long as we remain.
JohnyML

 

Stories of the Jantar Mantar Chappals


 

This morning, I was looking for an appropriate photograph to accompany my social media post. Then I chanced upon a photograph published by 'National Herald' online. It shows a group of paramilitary personnel and Delhi Police officers standing alert at the beginning of Sansad Marg (Parliament Road), obviously to prevent the protesters from breaching the heavy barricade.
A closer look at the photograph reveals something more. Look at the scattered footwear worn by the protesters. Except for one pair of sneakers, the rest are odd shoes, having come off the feet of those who were scurrying to get away from the brutal beating by the policemen. So, the picture captures a scene of forced retreat and the impending possibility of their coming back. The state forces stand in a tense liminal space, metaphorically and literally, as they always have.
This picture brought to mind an iconic photograph by Kishor Parekh, again featuring a lone boot that had come off a soldier’s foot. The setting is the Bangladesh Liberation War of 1971. India had sent the Mukti Bahini to liberate East Pakistan from its parent, West Pakistan. India won. Bangladesh was liberated into further chaos, as India did in 1947.
Parekh’s photograph is taken from a low angle, keeping the lone boot in the left foreground and capturing the action in the middle and far ground in a tilted distortion, as we see in the deliberately difficult angles preferred by cinematographers of war movies. The soldiers, with their guns, are inching forward to attack the invisible enemy on the other side.
Their identities are not revealed, but from their attire, we can make out that they are homegrown guerrilla warriors wearing lungis as their battle fatigues. Their bodies are taut and lean, showing a lack of nourishment. The street looks vacant and silent, except for the irregular gunshots, and people seem to be inside their homes, either respecting the government order or staying indoors out of fear for their lives.
I can imagine Kishor Parekh behind this boot, with his left knee firmly placed on the floor or road, supporting the camera with his right hand, his elbow resting on his raised right knee. It is a very precarious moment. He cannot spend a lot of time there looking for the right angle or light. But, as Bresson would put it, it was the decisive moment. Everything has come right in the picture: the diagonally falling light and the background darkened by the buildings on either side of the street.
Parekh’s boot and the scattered footwear in the *National Herald* photograph cannot be subjected to an aesthetic comparison. Both pictures were taken during tense moments. While the *National Herald* photographer might have had a few more minutes to click away, Parekh seems to have managed it in one or two clicks, and that too in an analogue format. Someone clicking with a digital camera gets a fraction of a second between two clicks to check the result on the screen. A photographer using an analogue camera can only imagine the possible result. But these two photographs tell us stories that we have failed to witness in real time.
JohnyML

Terra Fly in New York- K S Radhakrishnan


 Now, New Yorkers could find themselves being watched by K S Radhakrishnan’s ‘Terra Fly’ as they loiter around King’s Bend Park in Pittsford. The fifteen-foot-tall sculpture was formally unveiled at the park on 10 October 2026 by the city authorities and art patron Vikram Dogra. After Anish Kapoor and Bharti Kher, it is now KSR’s turn to offer a different aspect of India’s contemporary sculptural practices.

When the idea of ‘Terra Fly’ was initially conceived by KSR in 2010, critics saw it as a take-off from his cartwheeling Musui form. But the artist had something more to say through his sculpture. He initially conceptualised it as a public sculpture to be erected on the Kalabhavan campus in Santiniketan, his alma mater. This was a time when Kalabhavan was undergoing some major makeovers. K G Subramanyan redid his famous black mural in the campus building, and Master Moshai’s (Nandlal Bose’s) studio was redone once again by K G Subramanyan, this time with carefully crafted tiles.
Those were not easy times for these artists. Controversies erupted as the accidental regionality of the two artists, both belonging to the same state of Kerala, was unnecessarily highlighted. To make matters worse, at the Uttarayan campus, Tagore’s home, along with the bronze cast of Ram Kinkar Baij’s ‘Santal Family’, A Ramachandran’s ‘Sujata’ and KSR’s ‘Maiya as Arrow’ were also installed. The possibility of a regional rift was averted as art lovers found that the artists and their works had the merit to stand on the campus.
KSR’s ‘Terra Fly’ was, at the outset, a novel concept to capture in sculptural form the sentient presence of Tagore, the reigning soul of Santiniketan and its surroundings. Taking one of Tagore’s poetic metaphors of a flying bird, KSR turned his Musui—a common symbolic vehicle for his sculptural ideas—into an omnipresent and omniscient ‘eye’ above a pillar, a sculptural motif that has served not merely as a pedestal but as an integral element of monumental traditional sculptures since the Gupta and Maurya periods.
KSR created a cylindrical pillar with his stick figures crawling up towards the heights where ‘Terra Fly’ stood on its hands—a moment drawn from his cartwheeling forms, suggesting the eternal cyclical nature of history, time and creativity. Those stick figures were merely suggestions, like embossed impressions, imparting a textural quality to the bronze pillar, a part of the sculpture that people could touch. But if you look at KSR’s oeuvre so far, you will see that the idea of this pillar has been with him since the early phase of his creative career.
Look at the flying ‘Maiya Holding on to the Pillar’, where a vertical pillar, without any stick-figure suggestions, is held dearly by a Maiya figure flying horizontally towards it. KSR has always experimented with the concepts of pillars, thresholds and ramps as his sculptural ‘spaces’. In ‘Terra Fly’, we see the soul of a space, an ancestor-like figure watching over the goings-on on the campus. The students who come later could be those stick figures crawling up to the top. Benevolent eyes watching over people with transcendental aspirations could be one of the meanings the artist wishes to impart through the sculpture.
However, beyond the apparent metaphorical meaning, KSR has always thought about the ‘eyes’ that watch us in the form of state control through surveillance. CCTV cameras (which were merely an urban phenomenon in those days) were like cold, dispassionate and cruel eyes that could turn a person into a potential ‘suspect’. KSR’s idea of ‘Terra Fly’ was all about creating a pair of ‘counter-eyes’ that are benevolent, compassionate and encouraging. Through his sculpture, he was making an artistic attempt to disregard the eyes of the state.
KSR has created many versions of ‘Terra Fly’ since its debut in Santiniketan. Any work of art becomes famous and culturally absorbed when it is ‘repeated’, ‘lampooned’, ‘referred to’ and ‘landmarked’. Over time, ‘Terra Fly’ has experienced all of these. In 2012, KSR mounted a ‘Terra Fly’ sculpture in the famous city-circle garden of Kozhikode (formerly Calicut), called Mananchira Maithanam. Though there was resistance from some quarters at the time, sooner rather than later, the sculpture came to be referred to as the ‘Gandhiji Doing Handstand Sculpture’. Some people use the name to make a joke; others seriously cite it as a landmark. Newspapers publish photographs of the sculpture when something important happens in the city, and photographers try to see the city through the ‘eyes’ of ‘Terra Fly’. Major Malayalam films set in Kozhikode open with drone shots of the sculpture to establish the spatial context.
Unlike its counterpart in India, the Pittsford ‘Terra Fly’ has not created any controversy. The infrastructural work required to erect the sculpture has been going on for over a month, and the city has wholeheartedly welcomed it. I am sure that, in the coming days, people will visit the park to be looked at by this Indian ‘Terra Fly’.
JohnyML

Sacred Spaces: V Ramesh

 



‘Sacred Spaces’, a solo exhibition of V Ramesh, presented by Threshold Gallery, is currently on at the CCA Galleries, Bikaner House.
Famous for his layered works, faintly resembling the intaglio prints of Krishna Reddy in their formal aspects, Ramesh visualises everything around him in a complex fashion, almost prodding viewers to spend more time before his works in order to understand their interpretational nuances.
Most serious artists create their visual ensembles based primarily on two sources. One is the general body of references that includes history, art history, mythology, and other socio-cultural and political symbols that are easily identified and conveyed. The other is a carefully crafted personal mythology and philosophy that demands special attention from viewers for a proper understanding of the intertextual references. In doing so, these artists make cross-references between the two sets so that they can be strung together into a comprehensible narrative.
V Ramesh, one of the highly acclaimed veterans in our art field, has been known for his personal pursuit of spirituality through the teachings of Ramana Maharshi, whose ashram is in Thiruvannamalai, Tamil Nadu. Ramesh visits the ashram periodically and immerses himself in the sage’s discourses, meticulously published by the ashram. However, in his works, Ramana Maharshi does not appear as a lifelike portrait. Instead, the artist presents him as a persistent, dominant musical tone that determines all the other tonal varieties attached to it to make the music.
Those who know Thiruvannamalai and Ramana Maharshi could easily identify why and how the artist returns again and again to these references. The ever-present Arunachala Hills make a befitting backdrop to many of his paintings, especially when Sage Ramana is not directly referred to. In a huge self-portrait of the artist and in many other smaller works, we can feel the presence of this hill. The artist, seated in his easy chair with his legs raised on its armrest, becomes a passive figure, calm and composed in a self-imposed spiritual clarity. To counterbalance this, he has also created some works in which we see dogs resting with this divine mountain in the background.
Like any other devotee of Sage Ramana, Ramesh has also moved on to the Shiva cult prevalent in Thiruvannamalai, a cult that had attracted the young Ramana to become an absolute devotee. This naturally leads devotees to Shaivite literature created by saints like Karaikkal Ammaiyar and Andal (Kothai). He makes references to the Periyapuranam and the Skanda Purana. As with his formal renditions, things get complex. Perhaps, the artist demands complete devotion to and meditation on his art in order to achieve his artistic intent effectively.
Ramesh uses a complex formal surface or structure that makes the images animated and abstracted. At times, he anchors his works in popular woodcut prints depicting pivotal scenes from Hindu mythology, such as the Death of Bhishma on a Bed of Arrows, Jatayu Vadh, and Ahalya Shaap Moksh. In some places, the curator has displayed prints of the source images used by the artist. The transference of these images into Ramesh’s style makes the works look like woodcut matrices deliberately overworked to obfuscate the images and prevent their immediate identification.
In my observation, Ramesh’s works are like cross-sections taken from sites where history itself is being excavated. There are many layers, one over the other: some compressed and some released, some containing scant evidence and others rich in artefacts. It is the job of the intelligent viewer to delayer, separate, and carefully classify the images one by one in order to weave a logical narrative through and around them.
There is a variety of works on display: the complex ones, watercolours rendered in a naturalistic fashion, and hyperrealistic oil paintings on canvas. I particularly like one work titled Hence It Is Called Food. It is a diptych, with the left panel showing a ritual feast laid out on a banana leaf and the right panel showing the same leaf after the meal is over. It looks like an evocative still life, though Ramesh has another work titled Still Life. Sometimes, the hyperrealistic style and the matrix style confuse viewers. They wonder which one should be seen as the defining style of V Ramesh. For me, it is always the complex Ramana works.
I still do not understand why works of art should be shown in darkness, with window lights framing them. The whole show is badly lit. If the normal gallery lights were shed on these works, viewers could have seen them clearly, empathetically, and aesthetically. The lighting has screwed up the effect of the show in a big way. I do not know whether I visited the show during a power outage or a shortage of electricity. The front corridor had no light at all!
JohnyML

Jatin Das Drawings


 Three drawings on newspaper sheets, displayed at the Sridharani Gallery as part of the ongoing exhibition of Jatin Das’s drawings, presented by Art Pilgrim, caught my attention. They feature Delhi’s scavengers and sanitation workers. The subject matter seemed quite unusual. Krishan Khanna had taken up Delhi’s bandwallahs as his subject. Satish Gujral had turned to folk dancers. Mumbai’s working class was the subject for Altaf and Sudhir Patwardhan. Savi Sawarkar, in his innumerable drawings of people on the periphery and the invisibilized, has not drawn sanitation workers as such.

Jatin Das comes up to me and says, “I have done more than three hundred drawings of these men, who go unsung.” I am impressed. Perhaps there should be an exhibition devoted exclusively to these drawings. “That is in my mind,” says Jatin Das. At 84, he is a compulsive sketcher. An ace provocateur, his acerbic and wry humour still makes many people uncomfortable. Evening drinks on the lawns of the IIC are invariably accompanied by a few drawings, both of and for his friends. He knows a few Malayalam words and phrases with which he always greets me: “Choru tharumo?” (Give me rice) and “Vellam kudicho?” (Have you had water?). I smile and sometimes repeat the same words.
This show, generically titled Drawings, brings together a cross-section of works from various periods, perhaps going back to the 1970s, when he was drawing the postures seen in traditional Indian sculptures. One can see how his lines have evolved from precision to fluidity, capturing every imaginable human and animal posture. The lines are accentuated by rapid, bold brushstrokes that lend volume and shadow to the figures. Whether it is conte on paper, lines embellished with watercolour, or simple charcoal strokes, Jatin Das is equally at home.
One of the statements on the wall says that Jatin Das makes most of his figures nude, interestingly, most of them male, because he does not want his images to be disrobed by others. He gives each of his figures an independent agency. These autonomous structures form the basis of his paintings as well. Interestingly, one can see that Jatin Das is among those artists of the second half of the last century who were not terribly influenced by Picasso’s lines. Picasso’s hair-thin lines find no resonance in Jatin Das’s works. On the contrary, his lines are thick and sharp, at times forming angularities rather than curves.
This quality of Jatin Das’s lines essentially makes his works look more like the drawings of a sculptor than those of a painter. There also seems to be a certain impatience with the very act of drawing, as though he is already on his way somewhere once the work is done. This is a kind of virtuosity that he flaunts in most of his drawings. He claims that none of the works on display was made using models. “These are mental images,” he insists, showing me a book of portraits of his friends, all famous people who have made great contributions to their respective fields.
I am curious about the way Jatin Das has portrayed women in his drawings. The busts of women he has drawn reveal a kind of Fauvist sensibility. Some of them, with their slanting Chinese eyes, remind us of Henri Matisse’s portraits. When he draws dancers and ordinary women, he seems more engrossed in their gestural beauty than in the kind of voluptuousness that his contemporaries, such as Souza and Laxma Goud, were seeking.
Jatin Das must have made millions of drawings by now. It is impossible for a rasika to see all of them in one go. But I am told that he has meticulously documented most of the drawings made in his studio. His style is recognisable but inimitable, thanks to the spontaneity he brings to their making, which ensures that they cannot easily be reproduced by counterfeiters. Given his prolific output, however, there will be a steady supply of his drawings in the market for many years to come. Yet today, despite being an extremely famous artist, he has not become a darling of the mainstream auction market.
There could be two reasons for this. First, Jatin Das’s works are available to everyone at reasonable prices in the primary market itself. This also means that demand for his works in the secondary market remains limited. His valuable works must be those from his early period and his mature phase, many of which are currently held by art collectors. The second reason is his outspokenness as an artist. Despite all the recognition he has received from the state and private agencies, Jatin Das remains a staunch critic of establishments and the infrastructural deficiencies they so blatantly display.
A rare quality of Jatin Das is that he tries to see every exhibition in Delhi, whether he is invited or not. He talks to young artists and shakes them up to reality, while distributing enticing packets of romantic ideas about the importance of being an artist in today’s world.
JohnyML

Takshan at NGMA


 I read 'Takshan' as 'Takshak', the divine serpent. That's my cynicism, perhaps. But who taught Jyoti Tokas, the curator and a host of assistant curators that sculptures should be exhibited like paintings along the wall?

The scene is from the Jaipur House, the heritage architecture, where the original NGMA is. The rest of the architectural atrocities that came up in the same campus during Rajeev Lochan's time look pathetic with their garage type iron doors, often seen at the private builders' properties in Delhi.
Perhaps, the old mosaic floor tiles with geometric patterns are fragile and are not capable of carrying the weight of sculptures. But what justifies the painting like display of them along the walls?
Organised with private gallery collaborations, this exhibition has some very good works on display. Works of Sarbari Roy Chowdhury, Himmat Shah and Prithvipal Singh Ladi on display are rarely seen otherwise.
The maze of galleries with no signage or arrows take you to different kinds of works and some of them are really impressive. Alex Davis, Nandan Ghia, Vibhor Somany and so on have a huge presence. The beauty of display is sometimes royally screwed by the labels directly pasted on the work itself.
Exhibitions should have a viewerly pattern. Visitors make efforts to see, identify and interpret the works on display. Labels are helpful when it is a group show. They should be placed uniformly; That's how brain reads patterns. Here, one Label is on the left and another is on the right. Some are placed below the pedestal. Some on the far away walls.
Why the NGMA management can't send its curators to some crash course in their assigned job. Abroad is good. If not just next to Jaipur House there is Bikaner House. There is a lot to learn from there; how to do and how not to do shows.
After the three tier security check (for what?) we get to see a gallery painted pitch black that has screwed almost all the works exhibited their including the installations of Manish Pushkale and Satish Gupta. Pushkale must be having the shock of his art career after a successful Parisian sojourn with the same work that presents the linguistic death of the Boa tribe.
The scroll downs from the buildings give an eerie feeling as if we have entered a B Grade horror movie set. I meet an female Australian sculptor in the gallery and ask her to give me a frank assessment about the lighting. She says that she hasn't really seen this kind of lighting. That's an intelligent answer from someone who doesn't like to be deported for wrong reasons. 'Maybe they want to give certain emphasis,' she tells me with a smile.
JohnyML

Jogen Chowdhury- Obit


 

I was overseeing the display of a small solo exhibition at Triveni Gallery when I received the news of Jogen Chowdhury’s passing. I did not tell the artist, thinking that a tide of death might dampen her spirits. I thought of sitting in the nearby café and jotting down a few words of remembrance about Jogen Da. I decided against it because I suddenly realised that I did not have much intimacy with him when he was alive. I used to meet him, say hello, and move away.
When I came to Delhi to try my luck in the art world, around thirty-one years ago, I met fellow strugglers from Kolkata who shared more or less the same dreams. They took Jogen Chowdhury’s name very liberally. I knew the name, but not the person. Friends told me that he was very helpful to them, supporting their efforts to find funds, scholarships, and eventually recognition. He was the Keeper at the Rashtrapati Bhavan museum. Keeper was what they called a curator in those days.
One day, I saw him from a distance. It was winter. Jogen Chowdhury appeared to me more like a Hindustani classical vocalist or instrumentalist than a painter. He had long hair, a frail physique, and fragile fingers. Of moderate height, he had a smile that, in retrospect, reminded me of his famous cross-hatchings. Anybody could pick him out in a crowd. He dressed differently, in silky kurta-pyjamas and flowing shawls. Bengalis literally mobbed him, fighting for a chance to talk to him. I do not remember him hanging around the galleries for very long.
I thought Jogen helped only Bengali-speaking youngsters. So I never went to him for help or an introduction. I couldn't have complained, because by then I had found support from Malayali biggies like K. S. Radhakrishnan and A. Ramachandran. Our relationships were never about money. Whenever I approached them with my problems, they solved them in a jiffy, offering moral support and showing me the right paths.
Looking at Jogen’s works was an interesting experience. I liked his surrealism and overtly sexual imagery. Some of his works also carried an intense kind of pain, like stab wounds, festering wounds that refused to heal. Though they appeared physical, I felt they were mental wounds. He spent time building them up through cross-hatching, a painstaking process in itself.
At one point, he turned to single-brushstroke drawings, which made him a darling of the fake artists. The market was flooded with those profiles of women and flowers, signed with a single Bengali letter, all done in one stroke by him.
Jogen Chowdhury became a Rajya Sabha member as a Trinamool Congress nominee. I do not know much about his stint in Parliament. He founded an art establishment called Swaad in Santiniketan, where artists had studios and exhibition spaces. Later, KSR’s Tokaroun Museum and Sanjay Kumar’s Arthashila came up in the vicinity, turning the area into an art centre. Later still, in Kolkata, Jogen started Charubosana, a museum dedicated to his works and contemporary art.
Jogen Chowdhury’s paintings and drawings are appreciated in galleries and auction houses alike. He developed a personal style that any art lover could identify anywhere in the world. I do not know much about the person. His works, I always thought, had a kind of flowering eroticism in them.
He will be remembered fondly by Bengalis and artists. He will be missed in the galleries too.
JohnyML