Art means different things to different people. For a serious artist, it is a TINA thing: There Is No Alternative. Art is not a career option but an existential compulsion. The artist spends a lifetime making it, with or without materialistic success. For an art historian, art is an object of erudite investigation. For a critic, it is a pursuit of an imagined idealism, informed by historical knowledge, aesthetic positions and personal convictions. For the market player, it is a product to be packaged, showcased and marketed well.
These different choices and missions establish one fundamental fact: none of them can exist in isolation. They are interdependent, cohabiting like members of a human family. They may have different interests, ambitions and motivations, but they are tied to the yoke of the same culture. Remove one from its place, and the others begin to lose their footing.
Artists, being the creators of art, often assume a position of superiority over the other categories of actants. They believe that without their creativity, the rest would have nothing to do. But imagine a situation in which there is no market for art. Art is bartered for services and valued primarily for its decorative or utilitarian functions. It remains a life-craft, fulfilling the needs of confined societies. Its existence does not necessarily require critics, historians, galleries or auction houses.
But art refused to remain confined within such limited social arrangements. Artists sought patronage, travelled to newer locations and entered unfamiliar cultural territories. They needed a market. The market, in turn, needed to establish the artist's lineage, artistic strength and stylistic identity. It wanted to know where the artist stood in relation to his time and what continuities he maintained with the past. Art historians fulfilled this demand. Sellers never wrote history, but they respected those who did. History became an instrument of cultural authentication.
History dealt with the larger picture, bringing time into the equation as its principal category of assessment. Criticism became its immediate and temporal contributor, recording facts, opinions, conflicts and perspectives. Art criticism gradually became a documentary source for historical research, providing evidence to substantiate claims made by artists, sellers and collectors. What was written as an opinion in the present could become historical evidence in the future.
Collectors collected because they believed they shared a sense of history and belonging to a geographical territory. Parochialism gradually acquired the vocabulary of patriotism, and patriotism, in turn, gave birth to inclusive and exclusive forms of nationalism. To demonstrate their allegiance to this evolving cultural identity, the rich and affluent began patronising artists through collecting and commissioning. They selected artists whom critics praised or those whose works invited intelligent criticism. When they chose relatively unknown artists, they often asked their scribes to write about them, ensuring that these artists found a place in the annals of family histories. Cultural history, in this sense, was not always written from a distance; sometimes, it was commissioned from within.
Then came the asset class. It wanted everything it owned to be periodically assessed and accounted for as an asset. Portfolio managers discovered that art, too, could enter the investment portfolio. The cultural meanings of art began to recede, while its potential for economic returns came to the foreground. Buying art became an addictive game among affluent peers, particularly through auctions. Auctions did more than facilitate transactions; they manufactured visibility, established price benchmarks and reinforced the perception of value. The art object increasingly became a symbol of economic transaction.
But here is the irony: to make these economic transactions credible, the asset class needed everything it had once considered secondary or peripheral. It needed artists to produce the objects, galleries to introduce and position them, critics to interpret them, art historians to authenticate their historical relevance, and collectors to establish their desirability. It also needed curators, arrangers, interior designers, art consultants and several other intermediaries to keep the machinery moving.
What we have, therefore, is not a hierarchy in which the artist occupies the top and everyone else serves a subordinate function. It is a symbiotic ecosystem in which cultural production, historical validation, critical interpretation, patronage and economic speculation feed into one another.
The artist may create the work, but cannot single-handedly create its history, market or value. The historian may record its significance, but cannot create the work. The critic may interpret it, but cannot guarantee its survival. The market may assign it a price, but cannot independently manufacture its cultural relevance.
Each claims a certain authority over art, yet none possesses art entirely. That is the paradox of the art world: everyone believes that art needs them more than they need art. But the ecosystem knows otherwise. Disturb one element, and the others will eventually feel the tremor. Remove enough of them, and the entire structure begins to collapse.
JohnyML

No comments:
Post a Comment