Monday, November 8, 2010

Rocks and Roses: Medha Prabhakar’s Wall at Sandarbh

(Medha Prabhakar at work)


Walls and flowers attract Medha Prabhakar. In the beginning it was flowers, history of flower markets. Then she realized while working in a public project in Bangalore that the flower markets have a history of colonial divide. The flower farmers and workers were demarcated from the mainstream society through the creation of ‘walls’ that divide their locality from the main one. Medha saw this in Goa too.

(The Wall)

While in Luhari Village, as a participant of Sandarbh Nature Art Workshop, Medha has not expected to see something similar to her former experiences of walls. While walking around she comes to see a stone wall running through the forest land. Enquiries reveal that this wall was made by the Portuguese who once occupied this land. Maratha kings supported Portuguese to establish their colony in Silvaasa. They wanted the South Gujarat chieftains to be away from this land. The walls were made to demarcate the Portuguese land and in the process the villages also got pushed to the fringes.

(Medha decorates the walls with flowers)

To commemorate the lives of the poor souls who are pushed around always by the colonizing powers, Medha decides to adore this wall with flowers. She finds that some yellow flowers are used by the locals for decorating their hairs, idols and homes. She collects those flowers and with the help of the friends in the camp decorates the wall in all its length.

(Pari Baishya performing on the wall)

This act of decoration is supremely temporary. A wind can blow it away, sun can dry it up, rain can wash it out and the cattle can eat it away. Before things like that happen, Pari Baishya, a young volunteer artist comes forward to do a performance on this decorated wall. She decks herself as a ‘pari’ (a forest angel) with the borrowed clothes from a girl in the neighborhood and she walks along the wall, singing songs and acting out spontaneously. For Medha, the wall decoration and the act of Pari together emphasize a tribute to the times that had divided people and land through the making of walls.

(One final look)

Medha moves on to a field near by. The harvest season is just over. The fields are empty with the half dried stubs of paddy sticking out of it like the rough hairs on a man’s face. She sees some villagers stacking the hay for further use as a cattle fodder and manure. These hay stacks give an identity to the agrarian villages. Medha attempts to make one for her but with a different purpose.

(Medha making a phallic hay stack)

She goes around the village. People are reluctant. Medha pleads with them and some relents. She gets enough hay to build her stack. She wants it to be a phallic structure, showing the might of the earth. And she wants to see it as a condom also. Hence she gets some hay weaved like a ball and she fits it on the top of the stack. She puts a pot too up there.

 (Getting some help)


Hay stack with no ‘life’ purpose is not a stack worth respecting: that is the attitude of the villagers. They have seen Medha making it and they know for sure that she is not going to use it. So they wait for their chance. When Medha comes back on the next day to refurbish her phallic stack, she finds several things missing from it. The woven hay and the pot are missing.

(Villagers come forward to help the artist)

Medha brings it again and fits them to the stack. Documents it. And takes a last look at it. Yes, next day the whole stack is gone. People do not want ‘art’ which do not excite them. They want their stuff back. When they are not allowed to touch anything, they pilfer it. That is history.

(Stands alone)

While I appreciate the Wall work of Medha, I don’t quite understand why she calls this hay stack work, phallic. The critical association of phallic as the symbol of aggression and imbalanced power distribution does not quite work well in a village situation like this where people still struggle to make their ends meet. And the phallus of the encroachers? How can one associate that with a hay stack; it should be rock/steel strong.




Sunday, November 7, 2010

Factory Outlet: Barcodes of Anil Thambai at Sandarbh

(Anil Thambai)


Anil Thambai paints. In his paintings flora, fauna and art history take newer shapes. Heady concoction of images, right? Anil used to bring images from the technological world to the world of vegetables. Those were not surreal works because they were real to the hilt, till he shifted to hardcore art historical images. Like Lilliputians, the images created by world class masters move around in his canvases.

(the Factory at Luhari Village)

What does Anil Thambai do when he is not given any canvases or colors? What does he perceive in nature and the interpolations in nature? Can he come up with something that would correspond to his existing ideas and trigger a few new things? At Sandarbh, Luhari Village, things seem to have worked out well for Anil.

(The beginning of Factory Outlet)

Across the road that winds into the innards of a backward village there stands a huge factory that produces more smoke and sound than any identifiable products. And behind it there is a vast stretch of land undulating and disappearing into a valley from where occasionally girls and boys pop up with curious eyes and doubtful smiles.

(Painting the pillars)

This land has a boundary wall that runs several meters along the road side and then takes a right turn towards the valley. The boundary wall however is no longer a boundary wall. The pillars remain and the walls have become holes. The angry villagers have pilfered bricks from it. Or the holes in the walls tell you about their anger against the new occupants?

(Anil at Work)

Anil says the latter is the case. He speaks to the people out there and they tell him that the land belongs to them. But the multinational corporation came in a few years back, showed them wads of currency and got the land away from them on throw away prices. That is the history of civilization ever. People wear strange clothes, strange languages and strange weapons come in and take away your land and other possessions. When it is done by foreigners we call it colonialism or imperialism. And what do we call when it is done by our own people?

(Slowly they transform)

There are no ‘our’ people today. We have only ‘our’ interests. There is a clear divide between us and them. So Anil looks at those skeletons that remain out of the walls. The series of pillars vanishes into the valley from where the girls come and look at you. Are they real or apparitions?

(The barcode)

Anil makes out that the pillars are for real. They have divided the land into our and their. He looks at the pillars and something triggers in him. He decides to paint them black and white alternatively. Then suddenly someone steps in from nowhere. He is obviously not from the village. His attire shows that he is right from an office. He represents the corporation there. Anil tells him that he is not here for encroaching the encroached land. He is here to do some art.

(from one of the angles)

The man looks at him with suspicion and asks whether his art is going to be permanent or temporary. Anil tells him that is only a temporary work. Relieved, the man goes back. And Anil continues his painting the pillars black and white. Slowly, the pillars start looking like the lines of a barcode.




 (A panoramic view of Factory Outlet)


Yes, that is what Anil wants to make. He wants to make a barcode out of it. Then he cuts digits out of cardboard sheets and paints them black and white alternatively. To suggest a barcode he pastes these numbers on each pillar. Now the barcode is ready. Against the setting sun and the rising sun, the barcode stands there reminding you of a sale deed.

(Anil Thambai with his work)

Anil Thambai calls it ‘Factory Outlet’. Literally and metaphorically it is a factory outlet. The land is in the backyard of an existing factory. And it is an outlet. Factory outlet is the showrooms where the wares are sold in cheaper rates. Here ironically, the land is taken away from the people of the village on cheaper prices. An irreparable damage has been done. To underline this, the pillars now converted like barcodes by Anil stand tall.

(Anil Thambai and JohnyML at the site)

It is impermanent. In the coming days, the apparitions from the valleys are going to take away the digits cut out from the cardboard sheets. The cows are going to rub their bodies against the pillars. The boys are going to urinate under each pillar with a vengeance. The village elders are going to look at these pillars with some sort of nostalgia. Anil’s alteration of these pillars into a barcode might not affect them. But it could affect those people who come from the cities to do picnic here and litter up the place with cultural waste. They understand barcodes. They understand Bar Codes too. Silvaasa is a place where there is no liquor duty.

(Another panoramic view)

The black white stripes remind you of Robert Motherwells’ stripes. Do they? Not exactly. This is the jogging of a historian/critic’s imagination. But the black and white obviously stand for certain things. According to Anil Thambai, the black and white show the racial difference between the powerless and the powerful. It shows the good and bad in the social parlance. It also shows the exchanges of black and white money in the market as well as in the land deeds.

‘Factory Outlet’ is one of the most successful works by Anil created at the Sandarbh Nature Art Workshop. And interestingly, this is the first site specific work by Anil Thambai. When he leaves Luhari Village, Anil says, he is inspired, ‘inspired to do more site specific works.’

Let us wish him all the best.






Saturday, November 6, 2010

Foot Prints of Culture: Vaibhav Sharma at Sandarbh

(Vaibhav Sharma at his site in Luhari Village)


The Facebookians must be familiar with Vaibhav Sharma’s works by now. There has been a torrent of images posting by the Sandarbh 2010 participants in the facebook during the last few days. However, I find it pertinent to reveal my thoughts on his site specific work in Luhari Village where the Sandarbh Nature Art Workshop took place in October 2010.

(Looking for materials)

Vaibhav Sharma hails from Faridabad, Haryana and currently he pursues a post graduation in fine arts at Chandigarh College of Fine Arts. Faridabad has an industrial belt, which runs along the Mathura Road. On the other side are housing colonies with an ample amount of greenery. Having spent his childhood here, Vaibhav knows how the green patches fight for existence against the industrial pollution.

(Carving the foot prints on the ground)

Luhari Village is just an evocation of what Vaibhav already knows. Here the forest and agricultural lands are aggressively acquired by multinational corporations, turning them into industrial plants. One comes across sparsely clad village boys lazing behind the grazing cattle in a landscape which is still green. But there is nothing romantic about it as you see the skyline getting smeared by the dark smoke heaved out by the giant pipes penetrating into infinity.

(Foot Prints of Culture..sickling it out)

While the boys watch over the grazing cows, the village men and women, who once depended totally on forest produce for their lives, go to the nearby factories as daily laborers.

This is not a one sided flow. As the villages flow out to the factories, picnic makers and revelers flow in with their car boots filled with packed food and liquor. Vaibhav picks up this human osmosis, the ‘osmotic nature of culture’ as his point of departure. He finds out a low lying land near a factory. He clears it out and makes two foot prints of a giant human being as if he had walked across this patch and disappeared into the ditches.

(Collecting cultural debris from the forest land)

In every village in India you find a myth that tells you about the visiting of some titans during the mythological times. This is the place where Sita sat and wept. This is the place Bheem rested his cudgel. This is butterball kept by Srikrishna. These are the footsteps of Hanuman and so on .Vaibhav remembers the titans once walked on the earth and now extinct.

(Foot print filled with cultural waste)

There is a pun and irony in this foot marks. Vaibhav fills up the footmarks with the debris collected from the vicinities; beer cans, liquor bottles, wafer packs, abandoned water bottles and all other plastic waste imaginable. These are the foot marks of the ‘cultured human beings’ who once walked on earth. And are they going to be extinct soon thanks to this kind of vandalism that they inflict on the earth?

(Details)

The footmarks should have been filled with ferns and figs. But Vaibhav does not find them in the forest, instead he gathers what he has found; all this cultural debris. Hence he calls it, ‘Cultural Foot Prints’. The foot prints of culture, almost fossilized by the intervention of a creative thought.

                             

(Close up)

On the last day, Vaibhav decides to clear up the debris and bury them into a ditch that he has dug elsewhere. He has seen cows in urban places eating away plastic waste and dying of stomach problems. He does not want to replicate the same here only because he is doing some ‘work of art’. He starts cleaning up the place, slowly and painstakingly. People ask him to leave it there and tell him that the cows here do not eat plastic waste.




 (Foot prints of culture)


Vaibhav, however feels that one day when there are no longer any grass and tender shoots to eat, the cattle would obviously turn to plastic. He does not want to be the early lesson giver to them. However, to his dismay, during the process of cleaning up, Vaibhav finds the debris scattered by the village kids.


 Making of a work of art can leave the artist immensely happy. A re-look at the work would give him/her some sort of pleasure. But in retrospect, Vaibhav feels pain about the work he has created. May be an artist has to find different ways of doing it, he ruminates. That is the spirit of a young artist and this attitude gives the indications that this artist is destined to go a long way, with a lot of responsibility.


Tuesday, November 2, 2010

E for Elephant and E for Erasing/Erasure- Jinson Joseph at Sandarbh

(Jinson Joseph at Sandarbh)


Hyderabad based Jinson Joseph is a pure painter. Also he is a narrator of small little tales about his native place in Kerala. However, these characters do not appear in his paintings. He is more interested in landscapes and nature. In his watercolors you see the reintroduction of skill along with concept.

(The primary school in Silvaasa)

Sandarbh at Silvaasa is a great opportunity for Jinson because it goads him from inside to bring forth his stories and narratives in a work of art that he intends to do there. During his trekking for finding an adequate site as well as a feasible idea, Jinson chances upon primary school where ninety four kids from the surrounding villages study. For the ninety four students, the building looks absolutely small. But the student strength is directly proportionate to the ‘noon meal’ program. Children are given a meal here. There are two teachers.

(E for Elephant...getting started)

For Jinson it is a eureka moment. He has found his place and his idea. The school stands on a hillock covered with dry grass. Around the fringes, you see greenery, giving faint impressions on the beginning of a forest. Jinson thinks about the kids, alphabets and animals. A for apple, b for ball, c for cat, d for dog e for elephant…Cat and dog are too small and too familiar. What about an elephant.

(Jinson with the kids from the school)

‘E for Elephant’ is a temporary sculpture. It has the image of an elephant, more like an African mammoth, made out of a bamboo armature covered with dry husk and grass. Jinson collects bamboo pieces from a house near by. Children and teachers support him with great enthusiasm. They are going to have an ‘elephant’ of their own.

(The man with sickle)

Everything goes smooth for Jinson. Artist friends come around to help him. But one villager does not want to let things happen just like that. In a story there is always a villain, he thinks. He comes forward, pretty much intoxicated by all what he has drunk and chewed and asks Jinson about his intentions.

(Almost ready)

Jinson is often cool headed. He smiles at him and tells him about the making of an elephant. The moment he figures out that the armature is going to take the shape of an elephant, he joins Jinson to help him, but only on one condition; Jinson should give him some money.

(From a different angle)

On that day, the drunken man, after helping the artist for a while, slips away from the school premises. The next morning he re-appears in the scene with a sickle. If Jinson does not pay, he will cut the armature down. “I am not afraid of killing an elephant,” he swears. Jinson hands over hundred rupees note to the man and the next moment you find him joining hands with Jinson in making the elephant. He runs around and brings a lot of dry husk and grass.

(Stand alone)

The village kids are not just cucumbers or urchins or dumb people. They are intelligent. They know the difference between an Indian elephant and African elephant. One day when they come back to school, they find some changes made to the elephant by the artist. After looking at it for some time they understand what the change is. On the previous day the elephant was looking southwards and today it is going in the opposite direction.

(The elephant and the school)

“Some how the armature was not giving support to the front side of the elephant. So I decided to turn it around where armature has more grip,” Jinson says with a smile. Finally the elephant is done. All those five days, children come everyday to the artist. They ask him questions in a language that Jinson do not understand. Somu makes his occasional appearance from nowhere and negotiate with the local language.

(the burning elephant)

On the final day, Jinson decides to ask the kids to draw the image of an elephant on a piece of A-4 size paper. They all draw. To everyone’s surprise, all of them make very good drawing of an elephant, but obviously not the elephant that Jinson has created. They draw the image of an Indian elephant going somewhere with its legs in motion. Rajesh Pullarwar, a fellow artist asks, “Why all the elephants go towards the right side of the paper?” “That’s how they do their writing. So the trunk of the elephant starts there,” he explains.

(Still burning)

On the last day of performance (29th October 2010), Jinson buys sweets and candies for the school kids. And he does his final act. With the help of friends, he sprinkles a bit of kerosene on the elephant sculpture. Some of us are ready with buckets of water. And he invites the teacher of the school to set the elephant on fire. And with a lot of happiness, the teacher does it. And look, the elephant goes up in fire. In a few minutes, it’s all over.

(Jinson Joseph and JohnyML putting out the fire)

Why does Jinson burn it? “In school we learn alphabets and most of the time we keep erasing them as we make a lot of mistakes. If we use slate and pencil, it is easier to erase but when we use paper and pencil, it is difficult and even if it is erased, it leaves some marks, at least for some time. I burned it because I wanted to feel the elephant as a drawing and a way of learning. I wanted to erase it as I know that there are mistakes in it. This is a process of entering into a linguistic structure, which is not familiar to us. There are a lot of erasure, some violent some benign. In this forest village, I have entered into their linguistics and I understand it is very difficult to learn it. I have to erase it to relearn it. What I leave is just some marks, some impermanent marks, which would be washed away by a rain or a wind,” he explains.

(The man and his act of erasing)

The burning elephant- quite surreal. But a lot real here. Perhaps, each time we recollect the act of making and breaking, we could read more into it. Did Jinson feel too lonely after burning down the elephant? I think, he did. Art is like the saying, ‘kids put you in the maya (trap of illusions).’ Art too does.














Monday, November 1, 2010

Risk, Responsibility and Blame- Paribartana Mohanty at Sandarbh


(Paribartana Mohanty)


Paribartana Mohanty rebels to live. Long live rebellion. He rebels to create art. Don’t ask why he is rebellious. Hailing from a village in Orissa, with his ‘self-acknowledged inability’ in articulating his ideas in English and with a lot of anger and doubts in him, 29 years old Paribartana’s rebellion may be ‘misinterpreted again’ by the urban born and urban brought up art critics (who write in Queen’s English and celebrates Lalu English with no reservations) and they might say that he is venting his ‘frustrations’ through his art. That’s how rural lads with lot of creative fire in them are treated initially when they relocate themselves in urban spaces. Paribartana’s rebellion has a charm in it. And I am sure there are so many takers for it now.

‘Misinterpreted Again’ is the title of a performance that Paribartana did at the Sandarbh Nature Workshop in Silvaasa on 29th October 2010. This performance was based on his experience of being invited to a workshop like Sandarbh and being asked to do a work based on a given theme, ‘nature’. ‘Nature’ as an idea has been troubling him for a long time. While doing a residency program in Sarai, New Delhi, he was asked to forget his nostalgic past (which is rural) and was asked to focus on urban spaces. It has been a question for him worth probing, where he could locate the ‘nature’ in him and in his works or even in the surroundings that are ‘given’ to him on a particular context.


(Paribartana at the Sandarbh Nature workshop at Silvaasa)


At the Luhari Resort where the Sandarbh Workshop was conducted has a huge halogen lamp pole in the middle of a rock garden with expanses of lawns around it. Whoever spends time in this garden at night, thanks to the diffused white light flooding from the halogen lamps would think that it is moonlight. This is an accidental simulation of moonlight. For Paribartana, it becomes almost a stand in moon and when he approaches this light with a different logic, even the ‘natural’ moon light gets misinterpreted as a light created by huge halogen lamps.

Paribartana’s idea was to create a plywood cutout of a crescent moon and placing it on the top of the halogen light pole, in a way blocking the light in the shape of a dark crescent, so that the accidental simulation of moon light would become a deliberate one, realizing the interface of nature and culture through the introduction/interpolation of problematized object. While negotiating practicalities of this work, the organizers raised the issue of possible ‘accidents’ that this work could cause. The major points raised were the following: “There is a risk in this act of placing a crescent moon. If anything goes wrong who will take the responsibility. Who will be blamed for any mishap?”

 (Paribartana performing the "Misinterpreted Again' Monologue performance)


Paribartana’s decision to create an object based work transformed into the formulation of a performance piece then and there. The three words that he picked up from the organizers’ talk, ‘RISK, RESPONSIBILITY, BLAME’ became the core of his thinking process. If the production of a work of art could generate ‘risk’ why at all a work is to be produced? If a work of art is dangerous to a society who would take the ‘responsibility’ of producing it? If art could harm a society, who would take the blame for doing it, the artist or those who facilitate the production, dissemination and consumption of it?


(Under the moonlight created by Halogen lamps Paribartana performs)


‘Misinterpreted Again’ is a monologue of/by Paribartana, almost like that of Prince Hamlet (to be or not to be). He speaks of his rural past, the six years that he spent in Delhi as a student of art history and an independent practicing artist. Every day was a ‘de-naturalizing’ process for him; learning to operate within a new socio-cultural and linguistic system, finding ways to negotiate between himself as an artist and a social being. In the performance he speaks about his innocent days where nature was not just a backdrop or an issue and he speaks of the television channels that censure ‘natural’ life of animals only because they have been portrayed as ‘brother and sister’. He speaks of the hundred and one ways of getting ‘cultured’. He speaks of the abusive words. He asks the audience how would it have been had the trees of this forest could speak and act. He raises a series of questions and in this act his naïve speech assumes the quality of a political speech and act, the innocent gestures become the gestures of defiance. And finally he problematizes the artistic act through the notions of ‘Risk, Responsibility and Blame’.


(Paribartana with Bhuvanesh Gowda and Vaibhav Sharma)

While in working in Sandarbh, Paribartana was declared the winner of the FICA (Foundation for Indian Contemporary Art) Emerging Artist Award 2010 in New Delhi. With this award, Paribartana gets a chance to do a three months residency in Switzerland and a solo show in Vadehra Gallery, New Delhi in 2011. Also Paribartana’s collective also has been short listed for one of the Public Art Funds.

At Luhari, Paribartana’s achievements were celebrated by the participants and well wishers. And the FICA Award was celebrated by cutting a cake for Paribartana. His rebellious actions and words were debated. Hugs and tears were exchanged.


(A Star waiting to rise- Paribartana Mohanty)


There is a star in Paribartana. And let’s wait for the rise of this star in Indian art firmament first and later in the international sky. Whoever takes him up, let them be ready for the ‘risk, responsibility and blame’.

I wish Paribartana a great journey ahead.