Thursday, November 8, 2012

When an Art Critic is Felicitated: Keshav Malik at KNMA

(Keshav Malik at Kiran Nadar Museum, New Delhi on the day of felicitation 7th November 2012)


‘Keshav ji, you created me,’ says A.Ramachandran, veteran artist and scholar. Keshav Malik turns back from the front row and greets A.Ramachandran. ‘I am a back bencher always and most often artists do not like what I say,’ A.R continues. His talks enliven and add lightness to the grave atmosphere that has been filled by the ruminations of three speakers namely, Ella Dutta, Prayag Shukla and Kishore Singh on art criticism and art writing in India. The venue is Kiran Nadar Museum, South Court Mall, Saket, New Delhi and the occasion is the felicitation of Mr.Keshav Malik, octogenarian art critic and poet who still remembers the first line of art criticism that he had written almost six decades back, on his 88th birthday. It is interesting to see the tall figure of Keshav Malik sitting elegantly amongst the contemporary cutting edge works displayed on the walls of the KNMA.

Malik has been around in the scene of art criticism and art writing for quite some time. Prayag Shukla remembers how artists from far away towns and villages used to come to Delhi only because they knew there was an art critic called Keshav Malik. ‘The most accessible art critic,’ says Shukla. ‘And also a gentleman’. Malik has never hurt any person through is criticism. He is an aesthete par excellence. His way of seeing this is just looking. That was what he used to do as a young boy who was sent to Florence, Italy to do his schooling. He kept looking at things without an intention to grab the meaning. The more he looked, the more the innate qualities of the art that he had seen revealed to him. He never thought then that he was going to be a full time art critic at some stage in his life and would remain one for the rest of his life.

(Veteran artist A.Ramachandran speaking from the audience)

That is the reason, now in retrospection we should understand, why Malik still keep seeing the works of art irrespective of the name, fame and age of the artists. Go to Keshav Malik-ji. Get a forward written. You have crossed several hurdles at one go- that’s the way artists still believe. I do not know how much patience he has to look at ‘contemporary’ art today. But he likes paintings and he says that he spent and still spends his life looking at paintings.

What happens to such an art critic who is so benevolent and democratic and gentlemanly in his nature? Coming from a well to do family with connections with powers that are/were, Keshav Malik had inculcated the Nehruvian idealism in him. For a brief period, the crucial period of independence and partition, Malik was a personal secretary to Jawaharlal Nehru. The story goes like this that after a meeting with a cultural impresario of those times, Uma Vasudev, Malik was introduced to the editor of the Hindustan Times and he was given the assignments to ‘cover culture’. So he started ‘covering’ culture. That was how Malik became an art critic. But he persisted and widened his knowledge through constant reading, travelling, visiting museums and seeing a lot of works of art. Irrespective of his ‘high’ social standing he mingled up with struggling artists of the time. Artists thought that a paragraph in Malik’s column that mentioned their names and works, or a forward by him in the catalogue was a passport to success.

 (The felicitation panel- L-R- Roobina Karode, Kishore Singh, Prayag Shukla and Ella Dutta)

Such influences are rare in our times; the times where every failed poet is an art critic and every failed art critic, a curator and a failed curator, a consultant. When you fail in all these and when you have more than enough money, you start a galley and make compensations for what all have been lost. It is not rule but exceptions are rare. But democracy, leniency and gentlemanliness will not always help the critic’s life worth following. ‘Malik ji is one art critic who has never taken a stance,’ says A.Ramachandran. For a moment it sounds like an accusation. But A.R changes the tone of his speech. He says that Malik has never hurt anybody. He wrote on good, bad and ugly art works. ‘Whenever he failed to respond to a work of art or an artist’s works, he wrote a poem for them,’ comments A.R.

Perhaps, A.R does not want to hurt Malik on this auspicious occasion. But there is a grain of truth in what A.R says. The present day critics or scholars or art students do not refer to the writings of Malik. Has democracy, leniency and gentlemanliness paid off? Do Padma Shri and other high honours satisfy him? I do not think so. Malik belongs to a pioneering generation. Charles Fabri was the one who started art criticism as a daily staple of readers of culture. It was a time when Richard Bartholomew, K.K.Nair (Krishna Chaitanya), Santo Dutta and Malik were active. People who belong to these two time frames and who had seen them in person, speak of them reverently and remember what they have written. But somewhere a critic like Malik fails to flow into the minds of the contemporary generation. Is it because that he wrote for anybody and anything? Is it because his writings went to poetic heights when he did not have anything else to say? Had he been deceiving himself as an art critic all these years by containing his ‘right to critique’ within his poetic opulence? Or is it the fate of an art critic? Just to maintain social relationships or just to hold the durbar of an impresario, you need to be benevolent to one and all?

(Keshav Malik listens good words spoken about him. Sangeeta Singh on the right)

I am told that when Malik walked in artists thought the god had come in their midst. It was the same when Santo Dutta or Richard Bartholomew or K.K.Nair or Charles Fabri walked into an exhibition space. Artists gasped. They became anxious till they see the next day’s paper to see what those giants of art writing had written about them. In fact, Malik could have exercised restraint at that point of time? May be he is more a poet therefore a humanitarian. He considered everyone equally. As an art critic with two decades of experience behind me, I feel that an art critic, however famous or accepted he is at his time, is bound to fail in the long run if he becomes too lenient towards his broad aesthetic preferences. An art critic is not a God. That’s the primary lesson each art critic should learn. But today where are those art critics? They are all either working in backrooms of galleries and museums or they are all claiming themselves to be curators in facebook.

Prayag Shukla, who writes mostly in Hindi and has been actively writing on art for the last four decades is more perceptive when he speaks of Malik. Shukla came to Delhi in 1960s with an intention to become a writer. He struggled and it was people like Malik and their devotion to art that gave him enough courage to struggle further and establish his career in the field of art criticism. ‘In every other art form, critics have the freedom to sit and watch. Only in art one has to stand and watch to do criticism. In that case Malik is one art critic who has walked and stood a lot in our scene of art criticism,’ says Shukla.

One feels such tribe of art critics have become a thing of past; art critics who read and writes poetry and art critics who write poetry when they don’t feel like hurting artists with harsh criticism. Ella Dutta, another veteran art critic and art writer laments how the new generation has gone away from pursuing art criticism due to crass commercialisation of public mediums and shrinking of space for art critical writings. Kishore Singh, an art writer and consultant with the Delhi art gallery speaks of the new avenues where art criticism has migrated into. It has become more inclusive in a sense that involves artists’ lives, their cuisine and their life style. Art criticism is dead and long live art criticism. Also Singh cites how two of the major newspapers published from Delhi where Malik has contributed his columns now have done away with their art critical pages completely.

Malik listens. People who have crossed a certain age do not feel challenged as they see life and death, fame and glory, material opulence and penury with equal detachment. At times they take things absolutely in a detached way and at times they take things too seriously. Malik, after speaking a bit about his formative years, reads out a few poems. He is serious in his recitation. Delhi has a mushaira culture (poetry recitation culture). When poetry gets up people sit down and say wah wah. But today, when poetry gets up, people too get up and walk out. They attend their missed calls and face their angry spouses’ angry words. Recitation ends. Fellow artists speak good words about Malik. A.R remembers only Malik had come for his first group exhibition in Delhi. Malik with a photographic memory still not sepia tinted looks straight at A.R and tells him what those images were. Everyone is impressed.

(Invitation for the program)

Then starts a documentary on Keshav Malik by artist Sangeeta Gupta. I should not be harsh but I need to tell her that documentary making is not her forte. Documentaries have a language of their own. Either she should stick to that or she should break all the norms and should come up with something really catchy. With fast running subtitles from right to left, with shaking camera movements and poor sound quality, the documentary does not do any justice to a man who has stood all his life of lucid and clear writing. Sangeeta Gupta should have called her work a loose anthology of interviews.

Post script: Kiran Nadar Museum wants to set high professional standards. Hence the invitation card says that the program is strictly one hour in duration; thirty minutes speeches and twenty minutes documentary. The evening started at 6.00 pm though mentioned as 5.30 pm, and went on till 8.00 pm. Setting professional standards is a good thing. But we are Indians and we have a tendency to talk beyond the stipulated time. So let us be open and be proud of it. Otherwise stick to the schedule and be completely professional.




Wednesday, November 7, 2012

United Art Fair 2013- The Thoughts of the Project Director and Chief Curator on the Second Edition of the UAF

(JohnyML and Annuarg Sharma at the closing press conference of the first edition of the UAF)


It was May 2012, when I first took charge as the Project Director of United Art Fair 2012. Now the UAF Management has announced the second edition. Once again I am the Project Director and Chief Curator of the Second Edition, which is slated to take place from 14th to 17th September 2013 at Pragati Maidan, ITPO, New Delhi. Tipped to be the biggest Art Fair in India, the second edition of the UAF is going to be different and the difference will be felt right from the way of approaching artists to the actual installation/execution of the final projects.

For me the first edition was an adrenaline driven affair. I was brought in almost five months before the actual fair and it was a difficult task before me. With the help of efficient team mates and the able leadership of Mr.Annuag Sharma, I could establish the brand name of United Art Fair through a wonderfully curated and organized show. Since I joined, I lost my sleep. I was almost like a man in love. There is a saying that three types of people in the world generally lose their sleep: Lovers, those who seek money (for paying off debts) and those people who seek revenge. I was like the first one. I fell in love with the idea of an artists-driven fair.

 (JohnyML at the UAF 2012 Seminar)

When I sit at the same seat this time, I am in a different mood. I cannot behave like a lover who sees the face of his beloved right from moon to dustbin. Now I am more realistic and I need to be so because the first edition has created some realistic financial pictures for the management to think on. Hence, I approach the second edition of the UAF with the romance of a married man who is expecting his first child after the marriage. The sweet-bitter memories of the honeymoon are not yet over. But the lover knows that he cannot enjoy the heavenly pleasures with her because she is pregnant. But still he can admire her beauty, more rounded and full, chubby and brooding than seen during the days of abandonment, frolicking and love making.

I look at the UAF 2013 with a sense of reality, love, care and purpose. United Art Fair is here because it thinks that there are still artists in this country who need a bigger platform to be featured, appreciated and sold. The UAF recognizes the fact that the artists have enjoyed the first ‘free’ edition of the UAF where everything was ‘free’, right from participation to transportation. When you do a first edition of anything there are chances to have glitches. The first love making brings forth blood, they say. War too draws blood. One can spill blood by making someone blush, says Levinas, the philosopher. The first edition of the UAF had spilled blood, the blood of pleasure. But it has not stained anybody’s image. On the contrary, the image of art and artists has been boosted up. That’s why once again the UAF takes the courage to come out and tell the world that we are going to do it again. But this time with a difference; it should be like love making. It cannot be like a routine. It cannot be like the partners going to North and South poles respectively after the love making. They have to move forward together in the ultimate happiness of union. It should be like having an orgasm while talking after love making. UAF second edition is a union of the artists and the grand effort called ‘United Art Fair 2013’.

(A trial poster for the second edition of the UAF)

I would like to explain, when I am holding the curatorial and directorial reigns once again, that it is no longer a free exercise to bolster up anybody’s ego; neither of the artists nor of the organisers. Ask Annurag Sharma, the founder director of the UAF, why one should spend so much of money to have an ego trip? The UAF was a vision-dream or dream-vision. Having materialized that, one cannot remain solipsistic. One has to expand the scope of it. The organization has to expand the scope of the vision into a monetary reality where artists, art workers and the management get benefitted immediately and the art market in general in a larger sense. Let me tell you that’s why the UAF is no longer free.

Now you listen to me carefully, why the UAF 2013 is not free in terms of application, selection and transportation? It is not free because anything given free is often taken for granted. Any price tag attached to it, you start valuing it. It is simple human psychology. When you are in love you fight. You crave for a kiss. She turns her face away. You coax her, cajole her, humour her. But she does not relent. The price of a kiss goes sky high in the process. May be you are so much in love that you might even buy a whole mall for her, just for that one ‘kiss’. Yes, that’s how things get importance in this world. I want to tell you that the UAF second edition is a kiss of fortune that just does not come on to your lips freely. You need to work towards it. You need to sweat towards it.

(from the first edition of the UAF)

Keeping my amorous analogies aside for a moment, let me analyse the situation theoretically. The first edition of the UAF was free because, like my artist-friend Gaman Palem puts it, it was like a free software given as a trial version. Once you know the qualities of it, you are ready to buy. Now, the UAF first edition has created a value based international platform for the young and emerging artists of this country. It was a trial run. Now let us get into business. And let us view it in a larger sense. Many artists, even when they were having a consignment contract with the UAF, tried to undercut the UAF by making private deals from within the UAF Edition One. They offered works to the buyers without commission from their studios. Some buyers were also entertaining this because they thought that reduction of 35% commission was good for them too.

Realistically approaching the whole issue, I could say that it all happened out of desperation of both the artists and the buyers. Many artists who involved in this practice were desperate because they knew that we had been going through a very bad economic climate as far as the art market was concerned. So anything coming on way was welcomed. Buyers also thought that it was a good chance to grab some good works without paying commission to anyone. Both indulged and revelled in a sort of unethical practice. It happens in the art scene or any scene where money is involved. People undercut people for gaining profits. But it is unethical. The UAF is an ethical platform where each and every aspect of consignment and agreement are spelt out. So in the second edition such unethical practices cannot be allowed or entertained.

(The UAF team at the closing press conference)

Now, let us analyse the etymological roots of this unethical practice of buying and selling by undercutting the organiser. By making the UAF first edition a free one, the management was entering a relationship with the artists who had grabbed this opportunity. Here the management became a ‘giver’ of charity and the artists, the ‘takers’ of this charity. When the word ‘free’ connotes the notion of ‘charity’ (which is inevitable), an imbalanced relationship is automatically created between the organizer and the artists. It is an imbalanced relationship because the charity giver feels an imagined authority over the taker the taker feels humiliated for having to accept that charity out of necessity. This causes a contained bitterness that seeks expression at some stage. The actual fair ground is the place where they take it out. By undercutting the UAF in sales, what they feel is a perennial pleasure of revenge. Through this revenge, they balance the relationship between the organizer who had given them charity and themselves.

I understand this complexity perfectly. And I don’t want the artists of this country to be stuck up as the receivers of charity. The UAF also has recognized the fact that it is high time that the UAF being an artists’ platform, the responsibility of this fair should be the responsibility of the artists: right from application to the participation. Hence, we have devised an application plan against a payment. You get your services against a payment. To enter in a contest you need to buy the application form. I call it a contest because several artists are vying for the same platform and same name and fame. So it is a contest where you are supposed to prove your worth. When you pay a small amount, buy an application form and apply, you feel that you deserve it. It is nobody’s charity. It is your right.

(The Hindu highlighting artists from the UAF 2012)

Coming to transportation of works; again it was free. As the parent company of the UAF is an art logistics company, it could handle the works easily. But it has brought in a heavy financial burden to the company. Let us be realistic. When 3000 works are transported without charging, it would cost a lot to the company. It is unimaginably big. And because it was free many artists sent their works in abundance. Where we were expecting a five by five work they sent us ten by tens. Of course we had agreed to have them because we too were enthusiastic in the beginning. This time, when you are asked to send your works and take back your works, you will become more perceptive and reasonable. You will stick to the terms and conditions because it is your work and it is your money and it is your fair. Its success is your success. Its failure is your failure.

Responsibility to the artist is the mantra of the UAF Second Edition. And by applying you are entering in a larger world of art. You are not going to the galleries and showing their CDs so that the gallery owner at some stage would take interest in your work. Here you are coming to the UAF, where a person like me leads a team of friendly experts and executives in this second edition. You will be treated with respect, love and care.

(The promotional posters in fb by artists - a poster featuring artist Priyanka Govil)

In the first edition, the catalogue was heavy both in terms of volume and price. This time it is going to be different. It is going to be voluminous but it is going to be very handy and affordable. There will be more and more interesting features that your four days of spending in Delhi would make memorable. And I will be there to receive you personally. Grab your application forms now. 






Monday, November 5, 2012

Delhi...That Was- A Raghu Rai Exhibition at Ojas



Standing in front of the photography titled ‘At Diwan e-am- 1973’ by the ace photographer, Raghu Rai, featured in the ‘Delhi....That Was’ show curated by Anubhav Nath for his own gallery, Ojas Art, New Delhi, I feel drawn into the picture. There is an old Muslm man with a grey religious beard, in his white kurta and pyjama and a distant look in his eyes walking towards the photographer, perhaps totally unaware of the young photographer standing before him, taking a low angle shot. Two girls walk along with him; and we do not know whether these girls have come with him or not. They are in their own world of innocence, laughing on some private jokes, and too are unaware of the camera wielding tall figure of Raghu Rai. A question comes to my mind. What could be the age of these girls now? And what could be they doing today? Are they dead or alive? Married, widowed or orphaned?

The girls must be ten or eleven years old in 1973. Then they must be fifty years old now. At the age of fifty, these girls, as I assume that they are Muslim girls, must be grandmothers of several children. Perhaps, they might be living in the same locality of Old Delhi without even once venturing outside the new part of the city. They may not even know that their pictures are featured at Ojas Art Gallery, next to the historical Qutub Minar and a person, sitting hardly a kilometre away from the same gallery, is currently thinking and writing about them.

Life is like that. Someone somewhere is always writing about someone else’s life, determining the courses that it could take. While a photographer freezes a moment in life, a writer re-animates it into a narrative. An eminently adorable show created out of images culled from the archives of Raghu Rai, ‘Delhi...That Was’ tells the story of people who live/d in the city of Delhi. It is the story of Delhi too; a bunch of stories encapsulated in a series of frozen moments. The time span of these pictures ranges from 1960s to 1990s. Seen against the backdrop of four decades, Delhi is a city of flux and transition, which still has not realized its own character in its fullest possibilities. Perhaps, Delhi would never find one because history says that ‘Delhi is still away.’

Delhi is still away. From what, one may ask. Delhi is a magical city, a city of Djinns as William Dalrymple puts it. Here every one is a Djinn, kept captive inside their own lamps of existence. They come out when their real mettle is tested by rubbing against the harsh realities. Unlike several authors and photography artists who have captured the images of the city of Delhi, in the present show, which is a cross section of a possible retrospective of Raghu Rai, the artist does not try to feature the historical flux of the city through iconic images or the images of monuments and landmarks that define Delhi. Instead he takes a different route, giving Berger-ian interpretational possibilities. One simple glance at the picture, ‘At Quitab Minar 1972’ tells us how the three men walking past the monument, with their heads down, open up an ocean of interpretations that include class, caste, economics and politics.


Raghu Rai, though he has portrayed the seats of power and ‘powerful’ people of/in Delhi, he seems to be having this idea as a working thread in most of his works; people’s power. He cannot envision a city without the presence of people. Most of them belong to the working class and middle class, though the choice of subject does not seem to be too much deliberated as the artist himself says that it has always been his effort to understand the city of Delhi through its people. As a young man he came from Punjab in 1960s and he found the city in the text books was absolutely different from the one that he had seen with his eyes. Then he viewed it through his lens and it became habit and then an obsession without knowing that one day he was going to be the chronicler of ‘modern’ Delhi through the people.

There is always a sense of unsettlement in Raghu Rai’s pictures. Coming from Punjab, the partition memories and narratives must be strong in the artist when he was training his camera at the people. The people in Delhi streets were looking at the monuments, they were trying to eke out a living there, they were just like tourists looking at the monuments and suddenly unsettled by a sand storm. What one could deduce from these pictures is the idea of exodus and migration; two phenomenon that construct any modern city in the world. A modern city is constructed through the obfuscation of the existing and the old or the remodelling or re-articulation of the same. There are interpolations that leave the original (as seen in the historical monuments which too had a history of obliteration of some other structures and times) remain the same but meaning changed. Museums are the places where objects from a historical past are brought for display and changed as per the needs of the contemporary times. Similarly, a city is a museum where the historical past is brought as it is and interpreted for the present’s convenience. People are the interpolations in the space of a city and the city’s architectural and changing geographical and topographical memories are a ‘given’ historical past that is conveniently altered by the contemporary times. Raghu Rai sees people as the interpolators as well as the interlocutors of a modern city and he captures them with a sense of objectivity. Delhi is a museum of memories retold; and Raghu Rai takes part in its incessant retellings.


Though people narrate the history of Delhi, it is the power and powerlessness that people hold and succumb to that govern the dynamics of it. Raghu Rai does not posit the weak against the powerful or vice versa; no clever juxtapositions and jaded comparisons in his works. The people are seen in their own context but what he does not fail to register is the structures of power that control the locations and movements of the people. Interestingly, in these pictures, we do not see modern buildings like hospitals or schools or scientific or military establishments against which people generally seen vulnerable. The mightiest of structures that we see here are the Rastrapati Bhavan (Presidential Estate) and Red Fort (Old Delhi). Historically speaking, they link up two extremes of power centres from two different time-space correlatives. Ironically, in both the cases people are seen ‘witnessing’ than partaking in the processes that these buildings presumably engender (or had engendered). Witnessing is an act of exercising power over the incident as we know the gaze of people or the presence of them control/change the course of events. But at the same time we understand that witnessing is a sort of effeminization of the people who are not allowed to participate therefore rendered weak and useless. Raghu Rai’s works feature these two aspect of power relationship as seen and exercised by people.

Before closing this rumination over the pictures of Raghu Rai, I would like to touch upon two aspects of this selected body of works; one, the notion of nostalgia and two, the aspect of male gaze. Though pictures are texts that are no longer the texts of the author once they are taken away from the writer’s desk (read, from the archives of Raghu Rai), the autobiographical element imprinted in these pictures cannot be overlooked because of the very title that the photographer himself chooses for the show. It says, Delhi...that WAS. The artist posits Delhi in the past (tense) and tries to feel what Delhi ‘was’ for him and by saying that he asserts that the Delhi of ‘those’ days were different and it ‘was’ something else. Perhaps, it is one way to be non-judgemental about a city that has changed treacherously over a period of time. Male gaze is something that often a photography artist (male) is accused of. Raghu Rai’s pictures in this selection do not flaunt male gaze. However, in some of them we see the male eyes of the artist finding some interesting female figures in the line of pure objectification. The absence of a strong gaze, luckily absolves the artist of being a saint in the eyes of the hardcore feminist critics (in the case of this set only)







Sunday, November 4, 2012

Something Called a Day

(A painting by Shibu Natesan- for illustration purpose only)


‘A writer checks his pulse by writing on a difficult day. If he succeeds, he feels he is alive’
-          Unknown Author 21st Century AD

Yellow blood of an opportunist flows into the white porcelain soul of a woman who accepts the stain with a strange kind of anxiety that could cause her shell-like soul break into thousands of shards leaving a blue glimmer along the edges of each piece; yet she receives it, gets stained by it and then washes it with her tears, repentance and love. Poisonous fumes emerge from the blood that flows along the narrows streets lit up by the windows where lonely human beings wait patiently to catch up with a passer-by; they greet each other at times, share affected pleasantries and bid farewell. Some linger on, ensnared by the thoughts of desire, revelries and some salty, syrupy excitements shared through black and white letters projected and interpreted by the receivers’ feverish imaginations. Confessions start in these streets called ‘Longing’.

I am a stranger in this street. Looking out through the window of a moving car driven by a restless young man, I ask myself what I have been searching for all these years. Answers come in the form of changing cityscapes; they were not like this till last year. There were a few rows of pale buildings with scabbing paint all over like a wrinkled old man abandoned by the relatives who still live on his pension fund. Today they look different. The facades are changed with tinted blue glass panes reflecting everything around it, distorting reality into some unrecognizable colours and shapes. I could see my car turning itself into a python, then a swan that turns slowly into a toad, till it regains its car-ness at the end of those buildings.

Security men, clad in their boredom, ill-fitting authority and perennial insecurity about life look out at anything moving around them with passive eyes; eyes that keep calculating the monthly income and tally it with the family expenditure elsewhere in the villages that lie far away in North Indian belly, at the table of furrowed forehead, look at me as if they just found a strange animal caught in trap by its own mesmerizing eyes. Was I searching for these men who are hopeless just like me? No, I tell myself. I am on my way meet someone who is waiting for me with some money and some good words. Perhaps, for a writer, it comes in the reverse order; good words of appreciation and money.

At the traffic intersection where once accidents frequented like ghosts in a cemetery, order seems to have taken position thanks to the stringent measures of the traffic police who often fine a poor bike rider and let the fat men in expensive car who either look like powerful politician or property dealers. Powerful people look alike; they either look like politicians or property dealers. May be both realms of action deal with buying, selling and making profits. A doctor who looks like a politician must be dealing with properties too; that is the way this city works. And none feels bad about it. Small cars are dented and big cars are smooth surfaced. Why, you may ask. Because the small cars keep safe distance from the big cars and never dare to touch them even accidently. Streets replicate social hierarchy, fear and anxiety.

A knock at the glass wakes me up from day dreaming (or should I call social analysis in a creamy solution of indecisiveness?) A young mother in tatters and dust cups her palms and peers into my car. Across her chest which was once full blossomed breasts, in a sling there lies a baby that defies all definitions of infancy. The mother’s hand moves simultaneously across her mouth and the lips of the child, gesturing the universally identifiable signs of hunger and deprivation, while her eyes probe my hands, the reluctance of my body and mind, and she believes that her silent pleading could chip away a piece of piety from my hardened heart of apathy. She taps at the glass again. My driver shows a gesture, which could be universally translated into the act of shooing someone away; a gesture that could make anybody’s identity into a sort of abominable garbage.

The woman walks off. Was I searching for her? A woman who could tell me truths of the world? Could a suffering woman tell me the truths then women from all over the world must be telling truths only. Don’t get me wrong, dear friend, I tell an invisible presence that I conjure up as per my needs. I am not saying that all women tell truth and truth alone. Women tell truth tinged with the colours of their lives. Men who suffer tell truth but there is one colour to that truth; it is called arrogance. Men, like women, enjoy telling stories. They tell stories differently but they are heard in the same tone; the usual male’s story of conquests and victories. Women tell stories and they are heard in different tones; the usual stories of surrendering and defeats. Recently, in a party, a research scholar, a white woman with full of smile and warmth asked me to recount a story. I wanted to tell her a story; the story of a man who wanted to tell the story but left the world without telling it. But exactly like the man in the story that I would have told her in that party, I left it without saying a word. I owe her a story.

I meet the man who has been waiting for me with good words and some money. He speaks to me in broken sentences. When two men meet perhaps for the third time in their lives, they speak in broken sentences. If they are meeting for the tenth time, they speak in silence. I respond to him in broken sentences. We sit in the middle of a few paintings painted alike by different artists hung as if they had been ordered to be hung until death, surrounded by the gloom of the words that we have just shared. We sip tea; dip tea. Tasteless tea touches my tongue and my brain recognizes the tastelessness of tea and it remembers several of such meetings done in the middle of works of art. I smile at him and he smiles at me. We both are born on the same year. Conjoined by the year of birth, we sit; an art critic and an artist connected by a few words written by the critic on the paintings done by the artist. They will be remembering each other forever; the artist, for the words and the critic, for the money that he has just received from the artist.

The editor walks in. I greet him. Or we behave politely. My woman had once told me; move out when you start behaving with me politely. Politeness in a relationship is the result of hypocrisy and fraud. Better move away than being polite. If that is the case, are we fakes, I ask myself and look into the eyes of the editor. He hands me over a book of poems written by an artist who has combined poetry with paintings. I flip through the poems; they sound dark and nostalgic. I don’t want to connect nostalgia with darkness; but isn’t it true that nostalgia is like a womb which is filled with perennial darkness of destiny and mysteries? If so, nostalgia cannot be old, therefore golden. It should be dark. The poet in the painter wants to go back to his mother’s womb or the painter in the poet wants to take a re-birth. I see him curling under the pressure of immensity and imminence of existence. I feel myself like a seed lost in the enormous womb of my woman.

Along with the book, editor gives me a thin envelope that contains a cheque for some article that I had written for his magazine a few months back. I open the envelope mechanically and peer into the cover, ascertain the amount dispassionately and feel that each drop counts in the ocean of survival. I feel a vast field of freedom spread before me as I see iron chains breaking at the touch of my woman’s finger. She is instrumental in setting me free. In her silent prayers that curls up like smoke from an invisible fire in which curses and camphor burn alike, my existence breaths a new fragrance of existence. The screaming and shouting of the present fade into a past where most of the people live as ghosts, hurts and memories.

The huge building is one of the most sought after and identifiable buildings in the city. Culture moves like an interactive bell work that everyone likes to shake with some vigour and runs away with fear once it starts shaking. The bells beckon me. I walk in slow motion, exactly the same way I did on the same steps when I shot an interview with an artist in the same hall a month back. My woman came in dreams and told me, ‘Never put words into their mouths. They will take advantage of what you ask and they will elaborate upon that.’ A revelation that art critics rarely get to experience in their apparently ordinary looking lives. I remember the art critic whom I met a few minutes back at the cafe. He looks old, tired and burdened by the memories of all those works of art that he has been seeing all his life; a good fifty years. An art critic who sees and analyses the art of his time for fifty years at a stretch would finally end up in living like a vagabond who collects brochures and catalogues, and innumerable cuttings of his newspaper articles. He would lie down on pavements like an unclaimed corpse that breaths while the new age artists zoom past him in their flashy cars. He would collapse under the mild winter sun in the afternoon into the dew laden leaves of grass in the fine arts academy park with molten intelligence round and gloomy as the setting orange sun.

I decide then and there not to become an art critic forever. I should move on. Art criticism should be one of the avenues of my writing career. An art critic should limit himself writing about art after a period of time. Then he should turn himself into a historian. And he should turn into a historian only when he has got stories of people spoken through their words filtered by the analytical intelligence of the historian. Artists do not represent people. Hence art does not represent people. Art criticism is a limited option whereas art history is that of the people who have absorbed the essence and ripple effects of art. They could have a Picasso print at home without knowing anything about Picasso or his art. Art becomes the voice of people when people forget both the artist and his life, and enjoys only his work of art. It is historian’s job to excavate the life of the artist and his time through the stories of people and the stories of the artist and the stories of his own self. I am a historian of people and their art. I am a chronicler of difficult times.

I see people living in difficult times; in the streets and garbage dumps in Delhi. ‘Save the Children’, an advertising standee announces and I turn curious when I see the name of a great photographer, Raghu Rai printed there. He has a show on the next day at my friend’s place. I never knew that there was a show going on like this in this building. I go inside the gallery. There is a row of disturbing pictures taken by him of people and children living in direst conditions in the city of Delhi; under the bridges, at the garbage dumps, at construction sites and so on. The pictures disturb me. And I recognize that these pictures are taken by the veteran photography artist as a part of his collaboration with a non-governmental organization that works for the welfare of children and women in the ghettoes. I see the face of a woman recurring in these pictures. I see the eyes of a child following me from a tightly framed picture on the wall. It looked like the eyes of a monkey.

I wait for my car. The angry young man brings the car from the basement. I look at it emerging from the mouth of the basement like a beetle that has been released from a matchbox. I get into it. The invisible spirit of my woman gets in from the other side. She looks at me and smiles. ‘Had enough?’ she asks. I nod. She touches me with her soft invisible palm at my rib cage from behind. I fall into an ink bottle and turn into a dream.


Monday, October 29, 2012

Hundred Sounds That Would Inspire An Artist



I was at the park. Fifteen rounds in twenty minutes. Ten minutes of breathing exercise. While focusing on breathing, I heard the pebbles being crushed under the jogging shoes of other people who had just come inside the park. I heard various sounds of nature. Then I thought of hundred different morning sounds that might inspire an artist/writer to begin a work:

1.       The murmur that rises from the breathing of your kids or partner. Don’t call it snoring.
2.       An impatient flutter of a dove’s wing that wakes up before the usual time.
3.       The weary whistling of a night watchman who has just woken up from an ugly dream.
4.       Rustle of wings of those ghosts going back to their nether abodes.
5.       Long mooing of a buffalo from a distant stable.
6.       A train rushing against time along the rails made out of the parallel egos of people that never meet.
7.       The gurgling sound of the neighbour’s flush who has just forced his bowels empty along with the nightmares.
8.       A long piercing sound of water cutting water as your urine falls into the pot.
9.       A young boy practicing film songs with so much sincerity.
10.   The twinkling of an anklet worn by that girl who refuses to move out of your eyelashes even after your dreams have ended.
11.   The hissing sound of the refrigerator, as you open it to see the stock, with a yawn.
12.   Moaning of a ceiling fan that has seen the violence of familiar interiors.
13.   Chirping of birds.
14.   A long belching of an old man who has just woken up, accompanied by an uncontrollable fart.
15.   Sizzling of steel as a cup of water boils in it and receives a spoonful of tea powder.
16.   Whispering of two lizards involved in a kitchen conspiracy.
17.   A creeping sound of a cockroach that goes back into the dark secrets of a drain.
18.   The swan song of a moth.
19.   A dragon fly’s grizzly wings fighting against the smooth whiteness of a tube light.
20.   A group of devotees hailing their gods in aggressive mantras.
21.   Sound of a falling leaf.
22.   The sudden shiver of the tree.
23.   Bells of a neighbour’s devotion who had farted a few minutes back.
24.   A muezzin’s call for prayer from a distant mosque hiding from public view.
25.   A die hard jogger’s heaving foot falls.
26.   An old couple wobbling along the grey street.
27.   Ram naam saty hai, a procession leading to the cemetery.
28.   A dead man’s desires walking along with the pall bearers.
29.   A shy sob from a veiled woman.
30.   The thud of a chilli fallen from the beak of a parrot.
31.   Anxious and asthmatic sounds of water pumps vying with each other to suck the last drop of water from the main waterline.
32.   Desire of a young kid to grow at a bus stop.
33.   Fluttering of the eye lashes of a young school teacher.
34.   Zipping sound of a guy who has just urinated at the wayside.
35.   Revving of an engine of an old car that refuses to start on a cold day.
36.   Screaming of a mother at her children.
37.   Hush hush English of young mothers to their young children ready for school.
38.   One last kiss of a young husband on the lips of betrayal before he leaves for the job.
39.   One forced embracing of a wife who knows her husband cheats on her.
40.   A bike that brings milk.
41.   The sound of an aeroplane looking for a space to land.
42.   Blooming of a flower.
43.   Shy scalding of a layer from a sanitary napkin by a young girl who has reached puberty recently.
44.   Desire of girl’s reflection on the mirror.
45.   A cat’s laughter.
46.   A dog’s philosophising.
47.   Love making of pigeons.
48.   Silhouetted sound of a pair of monkeys making love against the rising sun.
49.   A muffled scream of a middle aged woman who has made love with her husband after a long time.
50.   Rhythmic movement of a cot from a neighbour’s house.
51.   Thud of a paper bundle thrown by the paper boy.
52.   Falling sound of a minister.
53.   Breaking sound of a party.
54.   Clashes on the streets.
55.   Shootouts.
56.   Raping of women.
57.   Bomb explosions.
58.   Hacking of limbs.
59.   Rumblings from the stomachs of starved farmers.
60.   Silky sounds of long legged girls walking on runways.
61.   Arrogance of a film star.
62.   A favourite newscaster’s voice.
63.   Kishore Kumar.
64.   Kumar Sanu.
65.   Sonu Nigam.
66.   Shreya Ghoshal.
67.   Mika
68.   Innumerable Punjabi Mundas singing same songs in same tunes.
69.   Two eggs breaking their heads on a hot plate.
70.   A pressure cooker imitating married couples.
71.   Footsteps of a woman keeping pace with her brisk walking husband.
72.   School buses.
73.   School vans filled with dreams, desires and anxiety of growing.
74.   Cycles with ancient memories.
75.   Laughter of a group of old people trying to gain health through grinning.
76.   Two crickets laughing at the boys who play cricket with rubber balls and plastic bat.
77.   Pranayama of people turning violent under a tele guru.
78.   Flapping of flab.
79.   A dog’s breathing nearby.
80.   A bug telling stories to a dew, which is about to fall.
81.   A group of ants marching towards a handful of rice and sugar thrown by a nature lover.
82.   A wind brings the freshness of a young girl’s humming.
83.   A sweeper’s anger turning into clean strokes.
84.   Heaving of the road.
85.   The tickling of a tree trunk by a cow’s neck.
86.   The falling of water drops on the silk blouse of a girl who has washed her hairs a few minutes before.
87.   An evil eye who has just voiced its anger at the girl’s beauty.
88.   Burning of chilli in gas burner by a mother who just realized the presence of the evil eye on her daughter.
89.   Whistling of a young boy.
90.   The dart of a young girl’s long eyes.
91.   Flutter of butterfly wings.
92.   The fast beating of a boy’s heart.
93.   Quivering of wet lips.
94.   The panting of a dream frantically searching for a beautiful sleep.
95.   Opening of Microsoft window.
96.   Various ringtones of mobiles.
97.   Wailing of a group of people on the death of an invisible ideal.
98.   Turning of imaginary wheels.
99.   Admonitions of an old man.
100.                        Sound of an ambulance, police van and a fire engine.

Sunday, October 28, 2012

Some Kitchen Thoughts for Sunday



There are two types of kitchens mainly- family kitchens and bachelors kitchens. Most of the middle class family kitchens are well arranged like a properly run private museum. Bachelors’ kitchens look like government run museums, terribly misplaced in their positions. I am not talking about exceptions but norms. Exceptions, whether they are bachelors or married, are cleanliness-maniacs and control freaks. They don’t want anyone else to touch their kitchen wares. Often you feel that it is better that they remain bachelors. They remain bachelors because they don’t want their orderliness to be shattered by another person. They are like strict curators in a museum never visited by anyone other than the officials. Protocol is what matters to them. There are many different types of kitchens than the above mentioned two; there are sad kitchens, happy kitchens, bruised kitchens, screaming ones, yelling ones and kitchens where tears boil in a pot along with the reflection of a waning moon.

At a married friend’s family kitchen where his wife cooks so many times a day for his never ending stream of visitors, I sit asking him whether I need to help them in doing something as they are cooking for me and my family visiting them. We sip from the half filled glasses of deliberate oblivion. The last piece of ice cube from the crammed freezer of the refrigerator floats like a thin slice of polar memory in my friend’s glass, which he pushes with the tip of his tongue for testing its patience to stay for the next round of filling.


I insist on doing something for him. He gives me seven big onions and asks me to cut them into very thin slices so that he can fry them for lacing the Biriyani which is already in the cooking pot and is on its way to the gas stove. Like many in this world, who have hated cooking or being kitchen helps, I too like cutting vegetables and onions for it saves you from many other kitchen related works like washing the meat, rice, preparing the dough and so on. Cutting vegetables need minimum skills provided if you have a good cutting board and a sharp knife. There are also you find some problem only if your host is two particular about the sizes of the pieces that you cut out of a potato besides being strict on the shape of it. There are some friends who would show off their recent purchase from a mega mart- a machine that could cut anything into size, except your ego. It has several blades in different shapes. And it is too handy to be used till it finds its permanent place in the cupboard as a museum piece for the coming generations to gaze and wonder upon.

He gives me a cutting board and a sharp knife, and throws a couple of instructions. Then suddenly the kitchen is abuzz with the discussion on why and how everyone else in there hates cutting onions. Onion makes most of the people cry. It is one vegetable that takes revenge straight on people the moment violence is inflicted on them. The other vegetables do it slowly once they are ingested and digested. Salad seekers are revenged by bad taste in the name of sophistication. Anyway, the discussion keeps moving around onion and I set out on my own track of thinking on path flanked by trees that have sleeping eyes for leaves, melting watches for flowers and alphabets for branches and an abstract defiance for the main trunk. I walk along the shadow-less path along the tree and wonder why there are no shadows of the trees all along. From nowhere I listen my photographer friend’s voice, who has been struggling with his drinks, phone calls, cooking efforts, children’s screaming and a lot of unnamed ghosts in his head for quite some time, and it says, ‘where the light falls parallel and almost close to earth how there could be shadows? It gives only a hue of light that fills in the places like a film set, like a dream.’

(Potato Eaters by Vincent Vangogh)

The smell of onion comes along with me in my journey. Cutting onion is different from peeling onion. Peeling onion is a journey to nothingness. It is like knowing the essence of Hinduism in the right sense. Each layer tells you ‘neti neti’ (na iti- not this). And you keep peeling until you reach nothing else to peel than your own fingers approaching each other like two swans in the pool of time trying to grace each other with their beaks. In kitchen you get philosophical and you feel like leaving everything and going into nothingness. But like the true Hindu philosophy, the tear jerking element of it holds you back to the earth, to the stool on which you are sitting and cutting the onion, into your own world of woes. I ask, what is the greatest solace of someone who holds a onion at one hand, a sharp knife on the other and his or her nose running? The outside of right palm, the right shoulder. Someone cutting onion alone in a kitchen and immersed in a chemical driven crying that turns into the memory of something really poignant and capable enough to force real tears is the most touching scene, a blend of comedy and tragedy, that one could imagine. You should see it in a more Guru Dutt-esque light.

Bachelors cut onion and vegetables well. Living in semi-penury also makes people cut vegetables well. That’s why people during their college days, when they stay in hostels or in rented accommodations cut vegetables very well. There could be many reasons; shortage of resources is one reason while occupation of meaning is another. In hostel days, apart from the dreaming of love making or being in love, what one does fruitfully is cutting vegetables and cooking frugal meals and sharing them with friends. Studying is an excuse for crossing the turbulent river called youth. Hostel rooms and rented apartments are pools of fire where bodies and souls of young people get baked for future life.

(Frugal Meal by Picasso)

However rich you have become in your later life, however expensive your life has become, do you think that you have ever tasted something like a dal-chawal that your friend had served before you when you came out of a long slumber induced by drugs and cheap liquor. Has the chicken ever tasted so well, many times better than the star dishes served in silver plates by turbaned butlers with a hopeless band singing sad songs for happy hours as an acoustic backdrop, than the one curry that all of you made together after pooling in money from for almost a week’s parsimonious living? Have you ever eaten an omelette as tasty as the one that your friend made one evening when hope was setting along with the sun in the western ghats and the stars of your madness were trying to peep through the sky above the neem tree?

Kitchens are places where philosophy originates and finds its flights of fancy. Life is like a wash basin filled with the dirty plates of previous night’s dinner. You need to clean it up. Wash all complaints aside, pack them well into black polythene bags and keep outside the door. Time is the closest stream of river Ganges. Immerse till you choke, rise, pick up an onion and start cutting.




Friday, October 19, 2012

Gandhiji and Me- Once Again at Sabarmati Ashram

(Gandhiji- the Superstar)


Once again I am here at Sabarmati Ashram; the abode that Gandhiji had left on 12th March 1930, for symbolically raising the conscience of a nation crushed under the yoke of the British rule by making the most elaborate performative act of the last century, the Dandi March. I have been here several times for professional and personal reasons. In fact I have travelled all along the same route that Gandhiji had taken for the Dandi March. What a symbolical and sacrificial act for Gandhiji was extremely a professional one for me. I, along with a curator friend of mine, Anubhav Nath was trying to translate Gandhiji’s ideology into the language of art market. However, the moment I came here something had struck me and till date I am under its influence.

(Sabarmati Ashram, Ahmedabad, Gujarat)

Sabarmati Ashram is a haunted place. Haunted, a word when used in the context of horror, is all about dead souls hovering around a house where a drunken husband sits all day staring at a vacant television screen and a black and white wife coughs her sorrows into the shadowed corridors lined by pale walls with cobwebbed ancestors breathing out of ancient canvases. But when used in the context of love and affection, it is a looming presence, like the character Rima in W.H.Hudson’s Green Mansions. Gandhiji is a loveable spirit at Sabarmati Ashram that spends all its time in sparkling the edges of each object, even the sand particles and making the place an abode of ethereal peace. At times Gandhiji must be thinking about the futility of his acts when he stands at the concrete walls raised along the river front of Sabarmati, and throws the little pebbles of memories of Mira Ben at the river.

 (JML at Sabarmati)

Have you tried to hop pebbles along the surface of water? Generally people sitting at the river fronts throw stones and pebbles at water. When you are sad you throw them with some kind of frustrated force and see the pebble cutting into the water like a dart of disparage that you have received from your beloved. The pebble sinks in force sans noise and the ripples spread like the shock waves of your despair. For a moment you realize that you are not different from the river. When you are gay in the Wordsworthian sense, you try to flip and hop the stones along the water. You arch your body slightly backwards, like an Artemis or a Poseidon you extend your left hand as if you were in a game, you bend your right hand at the elbow and fling the stone in a perfect horizontal line and it hops as if it were a deer chased by a tiger cub. And look at the lines that it creates; it looks exactly like the trajectory of an arrow represented by a physicist. Sorrow creates ripples and joy, the path of a shooting star. Gandhiji creates ripples for himself.


(Ripples)

I understand his sadness. I sit with him on a circular cement platform made around an ancient tree laden with yellowing memories for leaves, which now has broken marble pieces around it for support and beauty. We both look at the small hut which has two doors; one leads to where Vinoba Bhave had stayed and the other leads to Mira Ben’s room. I could hear Kasturba Gandhi calling out Gandhiji, like any other wife would call out to her husband. Her voice has complaints in it. She sounds like any other wife who thinks that her husband does nothing but wasting time in social service. Gandhiji does not respond to her shouting. I look at him. He mutters something under his lips. I know that it is in Gujarati. Kasturba Gandhi comes out of the Ashram’s kitchen. She pushes her hands into her midriff and glares at Gandhiji. I avert my eyes into my autobiography.

(Mira Ben's Hut seen from the main ashram)

Each time calamities strike people like me walk back to Sabarmati. We walk like a films division documentary played in reverse; awkward movements that push time backward and making smiling men to gloom, rejoicing women to silent bruises, curious children to utter loneliness, departing volunteers into their entreating brides. One good thing about playing documentaries backward is that there you see the enhanced dignity of freedom fighters on their faces and bodies before the cruel arms of the powerful strike iron and stick on to them, you see the lips locked in pure love before they are paled, dried and distorted by death, you see brave mothers sending their brave daughters to warfronts of marriage before they come back permanently scarred or burnt. I walk back to Sabarmati to the moments of my dignity.



(Two eagles)

Gandhiji has always been a source of energy to me. Sitting with him at Sabarmati Ashram re-invigorates my sagging soul and gives me the wings of an eagle and the colour of a parrot. I soar up there in the sky like a green eagle. Another eagle joins me in my lonely pursuit to creativity and freedom.