Thursday, November 30, 2023
When Someone Places Curio Shops over Art Galleries and Works of Art
Friday, November 17, 2023
Prof.B.N.Goswamy No More: A Quick Portrait of the Art Historian
(Prof. B.N.Goswami 1933-2023)
Prof.B.N.Goswamy,
the renowned art historian is no more. He was ninety years old. A man who
inherited his classy lifestyle and erudition during the tumultuous years of
colonial era kept that on without compromising even after India gained
independence. He was an IAS officer for a few years and left his administrative
skills behind to do further research on Indian art, especially Pahari and Sikh
art. His curiosity moved from recognizing the lesser known manuscripts and
illuminations from the regional varieties of Indian miniature traditions and
writing volumes about them, to the identification of artists who did signature
style works in the courts of northern provinces since the Mughal period. He pored
himself over innumerable volumes of documents kept by the temple priests whose
relentless documentations of the donors in cash, kind and art, without losing
the finer details such as the painters’ names, those of the donors and
witnesses under certain chieftains and kings, and brought out volumes on
artists such as Pahari Masters: Court Painters of Northern India, Nainsukh of
Guler: A Great Indian Painter from a Small Hill State, Manaku of Guler: the
Life and Work of Another Great Indian Painter from a Small Hill State.
I met
Prof.B.N.Goswamy personally in 2012, when I was invited by Chandigarh Lalit
Kala Akademi to give an illustrated lecture. Prof.Goswamy, to my surprise, came
and sat in the front row and kept listening to my rather lengthy presentation for
slightly over one and half hour. After the lecture he shook hands with me and
said he enjoyed looking at the contemporary works of art that were detailed in
my presentation. Reading B.N.Goswami has always been a pleasurable thing. His
volumes are written in chaste English but never pretentious or deliberately
tedious and complex. He never encumbered his writing with unnecessary jargons.
He could transport an art history enthusiast and a general reader to the layers
of Indian art traditions prevailed in the northern provinces of our country both
in his writings as well as in his illustrated lectures. He had this theatrical
flourish in his presentations, which often ended with an image where Lord
Krishna was presented in an absent form, through a blooming tree.
Prof.
B.N.Goswami always reminded me of the late painter, Jehangir Sabawala; both of
them exuded a sense of Victorian elegance. While Sabawala was aloof in nature
(may be he was accessible to his friends, galleries, collectors and dealers,
which I was not) but Prof.Goswami remained accessible to students and scholars
alike, but never made himself a populist. He stuck to his methodology and
writing style and did not traverse to the realm of contemporary art (except for
once) as some art historians specializing in 19th century or earlier
centuries tend to do. Most of them believe that methodology makes art history;
a sort of stencil application of the historical methodology over contemporary
arts done in different contexts and intents, and make hybrid art historical
writings, overtly jargon infested and opaque. Prof.Goswamy never fell into that
fallacy. To put it differently, he did not emulate a Hindustani singer who
thought he would rap for a change and cut himself a sorry figure.
Brijinder
Nath Goswamy, that was his full name. I never knew it till recently. I was reading
his book ‘The Indian Cat’, his last work on art history, approached through a different
trajectory where he picked up a set of Indian traditional works of art where
cats are depicted as a side character or a predominant one. In that book, one
of his foreign friends calls him ‘Brij’ and I was curious. Like the book revealed
another side of Goswamy, it also revealed to me that his name was Brijinder
Nath Goswamy and his close friends called him Brij. In every person there are
two persons, at least. One is for public consumption and another one for exclusive
private use. How was B.N.Goswamy in private, did he always wore a scarf around
his neck like some old film stars, or did he always sleep on a spotless
bedsheet and so on, we are not privy to know. But the public personality of
Prof.Goswamy was that of a meticulous art historian, always looking for a lost
name of an artist and giving him his due acknowledgement in Indian art history,
a delayed justice but what a justice!
We are
going to miss Prof.B.N.Goswamy for a long time.
-JohnyML
Wednesday, September 20, 2023
Do Not Mistake Sher-Gil’s Money as Indian Women Artists’ Gain
(Story Teller by Amrita Sher-Gil sold for Rs.61.8 Cr)
Amrita Sher-Gil is in news again, obviously for
monetary reasons only. Of late people speak about art when it fetches exorbitant
prices in the auction market. The gavel went down for Sher-Gil last week for a
whopping price of Rs.61.8 Crore in the Saffronart Auction for her painting
titled ‘The Story Teller’. I am not here to debate the price or the ethics of
art market. I am just curious about the ways in which the news was reported
both in the conventional and social media. Money makes news and news make
money, that is the trend of our times. So, Amrita Sher-Gil’s painting fetching a
huge amount is definitely newsworthy.
It is curious to see how unknown people exchanging
money in ways unknown to ordinary people throw the latter into orgasmic spasms.
Most of the people who have commented on the incident seem to have taken ‘ecstasy’
or some similar potion as they gush about Sher-Gil and her market worth as if
she belonged to their families. Money’s intoxication seems to have become so contagious
that it sends people hallucinatory in a sense. Someone posted in a whatsapp
group, ‘Finally justice is done to Sher-Gil. It is a new dawn for the women artists
in India.’ I was wondering about the kind of injustice that had been done to
Sher-Gil by the Indian art scene till she fetched this kind of money. So I
asked, did that person who posted the message really believed whether it was a
new dawn for the women artists in India.
It felt like a hungry man feeling satiated upon smelling
the fragrance of the delicious dishes cooked in the neighbor’s kitchen. I asked
a few women artists whether they felt the same with the price of Sher-Gil, a
sort of liberation, hope and aspiration. None felt so. Everybody thought that
it was a market ploy that everyone knows about. Though people do not know clearly
how auction houses function according to a pre-planned sketch, a blueprint for
structuring the flow of money, everyone today knows that periodical
transformation of dead artists into heroes and heroines is a necessity to keep
the art scene guessing; who could be the next. As you play your cards on the regular
Progressives a sort of ennui could set in. To dispel boredom better you introduce
surprises. In fact, for those who closely observe the pattern of auctioneering,
there are not many surprises in store for them.
Auctions are like a sort of beating hot and cold.
Major works of Amrita Sher-Gil are in the National Gallery of Modern Art, New
Delhi. The rest of her works must be with her relatives and family estate if
any or in the extended family of Sher-Gil. She is said to have done only 200
works in her life. So gathering the paintings from these sources is important.
Auction houses need provenance and they know how to establish provenance in the
absence of a real one. Once the work is found, provenance is ready and there are
stake holders, it is the time for surprise. And the players are not the auctioneers
and the faceless/unknown collectors. There are a number of players in between
and around who decide what to be hot and what to be cold for the season.
I was looking at the reports that came after the grand
fetching of money by Amrita Sher-Gil’s work. All the newspapers, portals and
other mediums said the same thing about Sher-Gil. They all expressed happiness that
finally Amrita got her due. Why so? In the same reports they say she had fetched
Rs.6 Crores back in 2004, a whopping price for those times. Hadn’t she got her due
then? Language of journalism, I tell myself in order to pacify the mild tremors
in me. Then all of them invariably go on talking about her biography. Amrita
Sher-Gil was born in Hungary and her mother was blah blah blah. Some words
about the painting, ‘Story Teller’ that stands in the middle as the reason for
this euphoria? No. Nobody seems to have something to say about it.
Some among the journalists write a few lines about the
work and mention the year of its making, 1937. Thank god, at least that much
information is there about the work! Then they too have to show their research.
So they ramble on about Paul Gauguin, Pahari Miniatures and Ajanta Murals, the
styles that had apparently influenced Sher-Gil. It is very easy to draw Gauguin
into the picture. He was exotic and alien in Tahiti and also exploitative to
certain extent. Somebody could mistake even Sher-Gil for the same; for her
selective use of orientalism in a Gauguin-esque fashion. She was famous for making
tableaus before making a painting. She modelled her paintings after the women
in the hills in their utter poverty and gloom, exactly the way Gauguin had used
the Tahitian women for his sexcapades and sexploitation.
‘The Story Teller’ comes from the same stable. The gloomy
colors typical to Sher-Gil is very much in the palette. There are five woman
and boy in an inner courtyard, a location that Sher-Gil had always liked and
used repeatedly as a recurring image in many of her works. She, a libertarian
knew the plight of her rural counterparts and their wretched lives confined in
the inner courtyards. They may be decking up a young bride or taking an
afternoon nap, their world is confined in the courtyard. Sher-Gil knew it and
she made them pose in those locations itself. The maximum she did was to keep
them inside the rooms, against gloomy walls. Sher-Gil must have been enamored
by the dark beauties, a kind of her own doubles in other bodies, in other
guises and in other locations. This must have given her a different kick.
The five woman are seen animated in their own ways.
The painting is called story teller. The woman in the lower middle is seen
recounting something but it doesn’t mean that the other women are glued to her
story. They all seem to be in their own world of reveries. The boy who is on
the charpoy with his mother or aunt is interested in the story. There is a dog
cooling off under the charpoy and there are three bovine creatures minding
their own business, except one which is looking intently at the betel leaf that
the lady is holding. There is a man in the picture who has not been given any
permission to come in. He wants to inform something to ladies or he is keeping
an eye on them. His precarious position shows that he doesn’t hold any power on
the women in their own locations. The liminal line that separates two worlds,
of the men and women, though not really an emphatic one plays a pivotal role in
the painting which only a pair of trained eyes could see.
Happy that money is flowing into the Indian art market
which will have trickle effect on the younger contemporaries. However, Amrita
Sher-Gil’s painting fetching sixty one crore rupees is definitely not going to
help the Indian artists in general or the Indian women artists in particular.
Auction results are a different game altogether. One thing is true; Amrita
Sher-Gil’s works will slowly re-surface in the coming days and there would be a
lot of activities in the secondary market. It is always good for the art
market. Auction house results expands the boundaries of the rigid art market
and definitely, slowly the money bags will loosen the strings before the
contemporary works of art too.
JohnyML
Tuesday, September 19, 2023
Female Artists in the Land of Male Artists: The Curious Case of Kishori Kaul
While standing in front of the paintings of Kishori
Kaul, a question flashes in my mind. Is her visual language male or female? Language
is neutral and devoid of gender, they say. But we know that language is an ideologically
driven tool, and it has gender. Visual language too has gender and ideology. The
more an artist becomes aware about her leaning towards ideology and gender
politics the more she uses gendered and ideologically driven language. What
would have happened to those women artists who were destined to live among the
dominant male artists and carve out a niche for themselves? Either they would
leave the place altogether (exactly the way Amrita Sher Gil left Europe saying
that she was leaving Europe to Picasso and taking India for herself) or stick
to the same place and compete with the male artists (like Leonor Fini and
Dorothea Tanning during the surrealist period and Lee Krasner of the Abstract
Expressionist time) and gain marginal success and fame.
Kishori Kaul belongs to the latter group who decided
to stick to the same place where the male artists dominated. She was born in
Kashmir and went to study art in the illustrious Faculty of Fine Arts, Baroda.
Both the artist and the institution were taking baby steps, and the enthusiasm
was very high. It was post-Sher Gil time and B.Prabha and Nasreen Mohammedi
were her contemporaries, with slight difference in years. Sher Gil was a huge
possibility and a hindrance for most of the women artists. Sher Gil had the
socio-cultural means to be a liberal and liberated woman artist much ahead of
her times. She could negotiate with the royal houses and could find patrons
among the rich and powerful. The case of the post-Sher Gil women artists was
not like that. They were absolutely home grown and had to wage war against the
existing social conditions that prevented women from becoming independent human
beings with creative abilities.
N.S.Bendre was one of the teachers who established the
fundamentals of teaching modern art in Baroda’s faculty of fine arts. He was a
maverick and worked like a magician using different palettes, brushes, knives
and other tools. He was more inclined to make rural subjects with lean and dark
figures, obviously a departure from the so called Indian School of painting, which
again is a derivate of the Calcutta School of painting perfected by
Abanindranath Tagore, Asit Kumar Haldar, Nandalal Bose and so on. While the
earlier doyens stuck to their premises with limited palettes, romantic effects
and lofty philosophies to substantiate their creations, N.S.Bendre created a
different kind of aesthetics across the Indian mainland without any restrictions.
But Bendre, despite his urban experiences reminded rural at heart and his
creativity overflowed when he worked on the rural imagery.
Ideologically, Bendre did not lean too much towards
any nationalistic project the way his elders had done. Perhaps, Bose had some
influence regarding the choice of the subjects. Inspired Ajanta paintings, off
and on Bose went into the mythological stories of both Buddhism and Hinduism.
It was a part of the larger cultural makeup of the country, which the modernists
somehow preferred to keep aside, allowing only occasional entries into their works.
Bendre, however kept mythologies out of his works and focused on secular
subjects, something that defined the Baroda School of painters including the
imported K.G.Subramanyan. B.Prabha, coming from the Bendre school of painting,
turned her attention towards the rural folk and fish mongers and one could say
that her works had this distinct quality in terms of subject matter. However, when
it came to the style, she could not move much away from the Bendre school of
painting.
Kishori Kaul too, in the big bad world of male
painters, seems to have been stuck with the male visual language. Kaul’s works
from the 60s are best example of this. She uses thick impastos of oil paint
using palette knife for its application. The works have that modernist vintage
flair that attracts one towards her paintings. As you keep watching her works,
the question that came to my mind in the beginning refuses to budge. Keeping the
biographical details of Kaul apart from her works, how does one discern that
the works are painted by a female painter. The works currently on display at
the Triveni Gallery in Delhi, presented by Anant Art Gallery, impart this feeling
that Kaul is one kind of a woman artist who has not differentiated her language
from that of the male artists of her formative years and later on. There is intrinsic
evidence that tell the viewer of her indebtedness to the late 19th
and mid 20th century male painters of the West routed through the
Indian modernists.
As she progressed in age, she seems to have loosened up
her otherwise tight palette with thick knife applications and let the canvas
peep out through the brush strokes. She has finally picked up brush and left
the knife behind. The change in the tool has made all the difference. The
background becomes lucid, and the contours are visible in their curvaceous lines.
They almost look like Japanese portrait paintings with blank background created
by pigment swatches. Further we move to see her works that are inspired nature;
there are landscapes, close up of lotus ponds, lily ponds and so on. The spring
in her mind comes back in random strokes on the canvas through liberated color
applications.
The organizers have called it a retrospective. There
is only scant literature about the artist in the internet space. Each piece available
says the same thing; her early days in Kashmir, a great grandfather who was an
artist, an affliction of tuberculosis during her teens, her first tryst with
colors and canvas, her art education in Baroda and so on. There are mentions about
the influence of the spring, snow, hills, valleys, flowers and water from her
native in her works. But the works say a different story, at least in the
exhibits. When Kaul paints, she paints like a male artist. There is nothing that
leads to make her distinct from the male artists of the time. I don’t blame
her. It was the dilemma that most of the women artists of the time had gone
through. Salvaging Kishori Kaul from those dominant male visual narratives and
finding a space for herself in the hall of fame is important. Hope that will
happen soon, before she is made into a spectacle in the auction sales (or the
effort to make her a spectacle in the auction sales) because auction houses
also need some convincing narrative to make a sales pitch.
-JohnyML
Monday, September 18, 2023
House of Memories and the Strange Pilgrimage of Objects: A Note on the Installation of Aakshat Sinha
Objects are the products of history. An object having
an existence without history cannot be called an object. Objects are cursed to
carry history with them. History, in turn is not the lofty stories of those who
had won the battles, established monuments and registered their legacies in
various mediums. History belongs to the people the way streets belong to them.
Bound between leather covers, the annals may contain historical registrations
that look profound. However, the shelves that carry such tomes, the chairs that
are sat in to read those volumes, the accumulated darkness on the hand rest of
those chairs, the inkpot and everything have got histories; nothing can escape
the fate of being converted into a component of history.
Aakshat Sinha knows the relevance of history inscribed
on the objects. For him collecting and accumulating are two different things.
Collecting is practiced by someone whose interest lies in objects with special
connotations that inspire his ideas and the classification that he does based
on chronology or any other mode gives immense satisfaction to his curiosity in
building an understanding about the world. One could call it creating a narrative
universe through objects of worth. Accumulation on the other hand is a practice
that is partially collecting but indiscriminate in nature. What comes into the
hands of the accumulator does not go out only because the accumulator finds a
value that transcends its object-hood and attributes it with a meaning intrinsic
to the narrative universe of his making. Each object stands in association with
the autobiography of the accumulator and by virtue of him being a social being
the objects thus accumulated become the building blocks of a collective
biography of the times that he has lived in. Hence, anyone one who sees the
accumulated objects quickly finds an emotional association with them.
‘Yaad Ghar’ (the House of Remembrance) is an open air installation
with such objects with collective history, accumulated and presented by Aakshat
Sinha, a curator, artist and a mechanical engineer by profession. Museums are
houses of remembrance because the objects collected and displayed in those galleries
remind us of the histories pertaining to them. Those objects are the syllables
of a grand narrative, each waiting for deciphering. The more remote are the
objects in time the more they look distanced, romantic and enveloped by magic.
Though well founded histories are written about those objects the magic of
their detached existence, something separated from the labels, QR Codes, Museum
manuals and the audio guides, goad people to weave their own stories around
them. Museums are methodical and randomness cannot be permitted in its
narrative. In Yaad Ghar, there is madness and randomness, but both presented
with some poetic methods.
Right in the middle of the atrium of the India Habitat
Centre, New Delhi, Yaad Ghar stands like a makeshift place of worship with the
objects arranged there look like parts of an esoteric ritual around the idols created
out of random objects. The sanctum sanctorum is flanked by a two discarded
mannequins salvaged from an old boutique run by Sinha’s mother at some point of
time. Those erstwhile beautiful plastic human forms are now bandaged and
bruised, wearing heavy facemasks worn while a chemical war or fatal pandemic
rampage is underway. The chairs have been there at his home and the beanbags, the
marvel cards and the knick-knacks also have been a part of Sinha’s life at some
point. They are all memory holders; for the viewers, they are memory makers.
Sinha, the self-styled accumulator of things believes
that he is a hoarder. He just cannot throw away things. Hence, his house is full
objects that reminds him of the life that he has lived so far. Imagine anything
that you grew up with since 1970s till date in an urban center, Sinha has them
all. Spring cleaning is the last thing perhaps he does every year and he cleans
only to save those discards from disappearing. Sigmund Freud calls the collectors
and accumulators anal retentive people. Children who are afraid of defecating
because of their fear of losing something of their own are anally retentive
creatures. As they grow up they learn to discharge the refuse and maintain
personal hygiene. Grown-ups showing anal retention is something different; they
know what personal hygiene means but they just cannot throw things away. They
find strength in the materials accumulated; I should say, they find life in the
objects that are capable of invoking exquisite narratives about their lived
lives.
Keeping one’s own life open for the scrutiny of others
is the driving motto behind most of the autobiographies. They use verbal narrative
as a medium of explication. Here in Sinha’s case he uses the accumulated
objects as his medium and interestingly everyone finds a little bit of themselves
in those objects. Art of any kind is supposed to create empathy among the viewers
and reliving the lived memories is the way to cathartic effects that leave the
people relieved of existential burdens. Object based art as well as verbal and
non-verbal aesthetical communications do the same thing to the onlookers. The
installation of Aakshat Sinha too does the same thing; it draws people into the
chaotic randomness of the objects and make them unspool the memories at the very
sight of those objects; a Proustian effect.
Orhan Pamuk, the Nobel Prize winning Turkish novelist
has created a ‘Museum of Innocence’. As he started writing a novel with the
same title in 1990s he felt like collecting all those objects that he has
mentioned in that novel and house them under a single roof. Slowly the novel
and the museum evolved together, objects giving ideas to the novel and novel
making the novelist to look for those objects from his childhood elsewhere.
With the novel he completed the museum and today it is housed in a 19th
century building where the objects speak to the visitors irrespective of their
familiarity with the novel’s plot or not. In Urdu there is a word for Museums, ‘Ajaib
Ghar’, the house of strange things. During the colonial period, museums were
developed as the cabinet of curios where the colonial masters, merchants and
the new gentry collected exotic objects and opened it for their personal
guests.
Detached in and from time, the objects that constitute
Sinha’s installation, Yaad Ghar also transform themselves as exotic things, their
familiarity now shrouded by disuse and decay. They become uncanny objects,
filling in déjà vu with its edges sharpened with unfamiliarity. The decaying objects
impart a magnetic horror, as we see in the termite eaten pulp fictions carefully
stuffed in a plexi-glass vitrine. They could have been confined to flames, erasing
their existence even from the memory, but in Yaad Ghar they stay put with some
kind of stale stubbornness only death can demonstrate. The installation as a
total is a memento mori, a reminder of death and decay, the futility of
accumulation but at the same time the unbearable lightness of being both in
carnal bodies and in memories.
-JohnyML
Thursday, September 14, 2023
Writing an Obituary about an Artist and it becomes the Writer’s Own Obituary in a Different Way
(K.P.Valsaraj)
Artist K P Valsaraj is no more. Is it an obituary that
I am going to write? Do I know him enough to write about his life or art, let
alone his personality? I had met him once, spent a few days in a camp and had talked
about art. Is it enough to write about an artist? I look at the social media
thinking that I get some more information than that I know. Most of the
artists, at least from Kerala, have condoled his passing. Everyone underlined
his mild nature and silence that he maintained in a crowd. People remember him
as a good person, devoid of blemishes. Goodness is a shroud, a public image
that we all are destined to cover ourselves with, especially when we are dead.
If I am not going to write about Valsaraj, what am I
going to ramble around? I would like to write about death. But I realize that
death is a subject that cannot be contained in a small essay like this. Many
have written about death so brilliantly that one feels like dying for the sake
of experiencing that exquisite feeling imparted through the words. I understand
that I am not qualified to write about death because I have not experienced
death. However, I can write about someone’s death in the social media.
Valsaraj was active in social media. They say, one’s
character could be assessed by the books that he reads or keep. Today, in the
age of social media, one’s personality assessment could be done by the messages
that he posts or the information that he shares. While there are people who masquerade
themselves as different people with high level of IQ and EQ through their
carefully curated social media posts. There are others who expose themselves of
their vileness through careless and mindless words. Valsaraj was not one among
them. He posted what he liked deeply. Rarely he posted his own photos or his
works. He shared mostly information and opinion that he thought socially
relevant therefore closer to his heart. There was no posturing of an
intellectual.
Some people are liked by others not because they are
great in their field of activities but because of their public image as calm and
composed person. They call it ‘a sorted personality.’ Dealing with a sorted
personality online and offline is an easy affair. There wouldn’t be subtexts
and innuendos or covert messages. Valsaraj came across as a straight person.
His posts didn’t make much in the market of ‘like economy’. But death tells us
that he had actually gained a lot of respect while living. There are people
like that in the social media whom we miss if they do not post anything for a
couple of days. Getting into that category is a really difficult thing. There
other people who are simply tolerated because they are in our friends list. We
may not like them or their posts. Their outbursts of self-righteousness may be
nauseating for us, still we simply tolerate them.
Artists die. Their families and friends mourn for some
days. Then they are healed of his/her absence. Time heals them. They come back
to their lives. Even when the families forget their diseased kin some other
people elsewhere remember them once in a while. Not because the social media
throw up memories but because they have left some deep impressions. When it
comes to the case of Valsaraj most of them, including myself said the same
thing; they had met him once in a camp or in some cultural program. The
mourners seem to have lost the chance of talking to him because all of them
said the same thing; they saw his tall and deep personality from a distance. A
silence enveloped him always so they kept themselves away from him.
Isn’t it a miracle that a person whose life is an
enigma to the rest of the world barring his family and close friends, liked by
many in the same way; simply because they have not talked to him? Many haven’t even
seen his works closely. Was he a celebrity, a reticent one? Not at all. He was
a person who perhaps preferred to live a life far away from the maddening crowd
of artists. He had a past and he too was arrogant when he was young and a radical,
so said one of the posts. He was devoted to the ideology that he subscribed to
in those days. He was a part of the Radical Painters and Sculptors Association
otherwise known as the Radical Group (which some JNU professors finally called
the ‘Kerala Radicals’). The Radicals were against the retrogressive aesthetics
prevalent in 1980s. But the facts show us that they were not radical enough.
They were against the money making artists. The art boom of 1980s (a temporary
phenomenon that hadn’t impacted the art scene of India as a whole) brought
forth the then middle aged and old artists like the Bombay Progressives. Everyone
wanted a Husain or a Souza in their homes. That was the decade when Ravi Varma
got it from both the sides. He was equally criticized by the retrogressive
aestheticians as well as the radicals. Finally, Ravi Varma made all the money,
so were the Progressives. The Radicals committed symbolic suicide followed by a
real one.
Valsaraj was against Expressionism, I should say because
the artists accused of retrogression were painting in the Expressionistic style.
So he time travelled to reach the period of Impressionism and Fauvism, an offshoot
of Expressionism while his colleagues were working with various forms of
Expressionism. So it was a contradictory and funny situation. Valsaraj however
extricated himself and settled in the area that he had chosen. He did not
change. When I saw him painting in 2018, I was astonished. He still painted in
a derivative impressionistic and expressionistic style. Can I accuse him of being
stubborn or Peter Pan-ish? No, I cannot. There are artists who works in a
certain way even after known that the style of their choice was old and no more
in fashion. Still someone pursues it, there must be an artistic stubbornness.
Who is going to write about artists when they are gone?
People who knew them definitely will jot down words of emotion. But will there be
someone to assess and appreciate his works, beyond an obituary? It boils down
to the need for artists make their own legacies, legends and folktales so that they
are widely circulated in social media or in friends’ circles. Isn’t it terrible
that an artist passes off with no evidence than his works, but no stories, no
legends and no folktales? When you are writing someone else’s obituary, in fact
you are writing your own obituary because your writing adds to your legend and
folktales. Hey, this man used to write good obit pieces. And here today he is
gone so let’s talk about the obituaries that he has written till date.
JohnyML
Wednesday, September 13, 2023
Performing Painting for the People: A Thought
Standing at the stairs leading to the foyer I looked
at the young people waiting enthusiastically in the lounge for the senior artist
to start his demonstration. A live painting session was in progress there and
the audience were mostly young artists and aspirants from the local art
colleges. As per the new world order and its resultant customs, they looked at
the artist and his canvas through the lenses of their mobile cameras. Some of
them were clicking stills of the man who was engrossed in demonstrating his
skills and some others were recording the session in videos thinking that they
could study the nuances of the brush strokes and mixing of the colors later. Once
the ritual of mobile mediation was done they all focused on the painting
process with their own eyes.
What do the live sessions do to the young art
students, I thought. Was it like a musician or a dancer performing before an
audience? Obviously the performing artists impact the emotional level of the audience
before they invite the attention of the audience to the nuances of their performance
and technical virtuosity. Students of the performing artists do learn from observing
their gurus. As far as the art students are concerned apart from the class room
demonstrations that their teachers give they don’t get to see other artists
making paintings or sculptures live. The art of making art is a covert thing;
in the privacy of the studios artists make art and people are allowed to see when
the work of art is finished. That’s is a sort of rule.
However, there are exceptions to this. There are
artists who are comfortable in the company of others. They can draw or paint
while someone is watching or talking. They are not afraid of their styles and
techniques being copied or imitated. But others, whether they are afraid of
copycats or not, they are comfortable in their private worlds. Even if visitors
are allowed once in a while it is not for showing the process of working but to
show them the finished work. At times, these reticent artists too reveal their processes
before an audience especially when they are video documented for a mutually
agreed upon documentary or when they are in a camp. Artists who regularly go
for camps or workshops are not afraid of being before an audience while they do
the work. Sometimes camps are organized for the benefit of the young artists
and art students. Those artists who do not want to work before an audience do
not go for camps. Nowadays camp means sight-seeing pleasure trips. Works are to
be given to the organizers only when the artists are back in their studios.
One thing is sure that people never lose interest in
watching an artist work. It is really the magic of making. Artists working
amidst a crowd are like public performers, like street magicians and street artists.
They are aware of the public and at the same time they know how to hold the interest
of the public safe from waning. They take out their work materials as if they
were magicians or a street vendor displaying his wares. The moment they start
working a small crowd gathers and it swells into a strong one. Each line and
stroke is followed closely by the attentive eyes. They twist and turn as the
lines take different shapes. There is a physical response to the artists’
performance of making art. I have seen people waiting the works to be finished.
It is not just about the lucky one who has been picked up as the model by the
artists but also the onlookers. They all want to see the finished work and feel
good about what they have just seen. Each one in the crowd feels that he or she
should be picked up as the next model. None would mind if the artist is just
making a landscape exactly the way the Barbizon School painters in the late 19th
century did in Paris and Shibu Natesan does these days.
Artists’ studios are highly guarded places. Artists
are like the proverbial giants who sit over the treasures. But in history there
are some artists who apparently showed their prowess in making art for the sake
of others. Some of the artists are performative in nature and as I mentioned
before they are ready to show their abilities at any given time. Pablo Picasso,
Jackson Pollock, Yves Klein and artists like them performed their paintings for
others. Generally, art teachers are comfortable in performing before the
students or other people. Photographs available in the archives show artists
like Nandlal Bose, Binod Behari Mukherjee, Ram Kinkar Baij, N.S.Bendre,
Prabhakar Kolte enthusiastically demonstrating before the students. May be that
is one reason why there are so many students evolved like them in their artistic
styles. They become part of a school, a style and a sort of philosophy. You may
ask if it is good for the growth of the students. Replicating the style is a
thing of past and was done to death with the demise of the guilds. Modern and
contemporary art demand uniqueness and experimental styles from the artist. So
following one artist or his style is not a thing to be cherished anymore.
The way art is taught in institutions is also changed.
Previously, as we have seen already, demonstration was the prime way of teaching
skill and style. Today, most of the artists and art teachers believe that art
cannot be taught so the students should be left to their own devices. Art teachers
should be just facilitators. They should be more like sounding boards who would
help the students reflect on their art than hand holding them to make art in
certain styles. However, it is observed that where the art teachers are practicing
artists themselves the students feel like emulating the working methods than
imitating the style. Following the work routine of the master/teacher is always
good for discipline. It has also been observed that where the art teachers draw
with their tongues than with their hands the students tend to do the same,
eventually becoming preachers of sorts than artists, conceptual or otherwise.
Artists need appreciation from the public. Artists do
not discern between the initiated and the ordinary folks. Artists are happy
when they could arouse curiosity in others through their works. Artists, though
sometimes reluctant in talking, feel soul satisfied when people spend time
before their works. People in turn want to see how much they could grasp the
magic of art, the hidden meanings of it. When they fail to do so, they turn
their faces away. When an artist performs a painting before the people they get
enthusiastic because it is a treasure hunt in an unchartered land with no GPS
in hand. Artist him/herself guides the people towards the final point and it is
an exhilarating experience.
-JohnyML
(All the pictures are from Lalit Kala Akademi Galleries
where Prof.Pranam Singh performed a painting)























