Thursday, November 19, 2026

Takshan at NGMA


 I read 'Takshan' as 'Takshak', the divine serpent. That's my cynicism, perhaps. But who taught Jyoti Tokas, the curator and a host of assistant curators that sculptures should be exhibited like paintings along the wall?

The scene is from the Jaipur House, the heritage architecture, where the original NGMA is. The rest of the architectural atrocities that came up in the same campus during Rajeev Lochan's time look pathetic with their garage type iron doors, often seen at the private builders' properties in Delhi.
Perhaps, the old mosaic floor tiles with geometric patterns are fragile and are not capable of carrying the weight of sculptures. But what justifies the painting like display of them along the walls?
Organised with private gallery collaborations, this exhibition has some very good works on display. Works of Sarbari Roy Chowdhury, Himmat Shah and Prithvipal Singh Ladi on display are rarely seen otherwise.
The maze of galleries with no signage or arrows take you to different kinds of works and some of them are really impressive. Alex Davis, Nandan Ghia, Vibhor Somany and so on have a huge presence. The beauty of display is sometimes royally screwed by the labels directly pasted on the work itself.
Exhibitions should have a viewerly pattern. Visitors make efforts to see, identify and interpret the works on display. Labels are helpful when it is a group show. They should be placed uniformly; That's how brain reads patterns. Here, one Label is on the left and another is on the right. Some are placed below the pedestal. Some on the far away walls.
Why the NGMA management can't send its curators to some crash course in their assigned job. Abroad is good. If not just next to Jaipur House there is Bikaner House. There is a lot to learn from there; how to do and how not to do shows.
After the three tier security check (for what?) we get to see a gallery painted pitch black that has screwed almost all the works exhibited their including the installations of Manish Pushkale and Satish Gupta. Pushkale must be having the shock of his art career after a successful Parisian sojourn with the same work that presents the linguistic death of the Boa tribe.
The scroll downs from the buildings give an eerie feeling as if we have entered a B Grade horror movie set. I meet an female Australian sculptor in the gallery and ask her to give me a frank assessment about the lighting. She says that she hasn't really seen this kind of lighting. That's an intelligent answer from someone who doesn't like to be deported for wrong reasons. 'Maybe they want to give certain emphasis,' she tells me with a smile.
JohnyML

Jogen Chowdhury- Obit


 

I was overseeing the display of a small solo exhibition at Triveni Gallery when I received the news of Jogen Chowdhury’s passing. I did not tell the artist, thinking that a tide of death might dampen her spirits. I thought of sitting in the nearby cafĂ© and jotting down a few words of remembrance about Jogen Da. I decided against it because I suddenly realised that I did not have much intimacy with him when he was alive. I used to meet him, say hello, and move away.
When I came to Delhi to try my luck in the art world, around thirty-one years ago, I met fellow strugglers from Kolkata who shared more or less the same dreams. They took Jogen Chowdhury’s name very liberally. I knew the name, but not the person. Friends told me that he was very helpful to them, supporting their efforts to find funds, scholarships, and eventually recognition. He was the Keeper at the Rashtrapati Bhavan museum. Keeper was what they called a curator in those days.
One day, I saw him from a distance. It was winter. Jogen Chowdhury appeared to me more like a Hindustani classical vocalist or instrumentalist than a painter. He had long hair, a frail physique, and fragile fingers. Of moderate height, he had a smile that, in retrospect, reminded me of his famous cross-hatchings. Anybody could pick him out in a crowd. He dressed differently, in silky kurta-pyjamas and flowing shawls. Bengalis literally mobbed him, fighting for a chance to talk to him. I do not remember him hanging around the galleries for very long.
I thought Jogen helped only Bengali-speaking youngsters. So I never went to him for help or an introduction. I couldn't have complained, because by then I had found support from Malayali biggies like K. S. Radhakrishnan and A. Ramachandran. Our relationships were never about money. Whenever I approached them with my problems, they solved them in a jiffy, offering moral support and showing me the right paths.
Looking at Jogen’s works was an interesting experience. I liked his surrealism and overtly sexual imagery. Some of his works also carried an intense kind of pain, like stab wounds, festering wounds that refused to heal. Though they appeared physical, I felt they were mental wounds. He spent time building them up through cross-hatching, a painstaking process in itself.
At one point, he turned to single-brushstroke drawings, which made him a darling of the fake artists. The market was flooded with those profiles of women and flowers, signed with a single Bengali letter, all done in one stroke by him.
Jogen Chowdhury became a Rajya Sabha member as a Trinamool Congress nominee. I do not know much about his stint in Parliament. He founded an art establishment called Swaad in Santiniketan, where artists had studios and exhibition spaces. Later, KSR’s Tokaroun Museum and Sanjay Kumar’s Arthashila came up in the vicinity, turning the area into an art centre. Later still, in Kolkata, Jogen started Charubosana, a museum dedicated to his works and contemporary art.
Jogen Chowdhury’s paintings and drawings are appreciated in galleries and auction houses alike. He developed a personal style that any art lover could identify anywhere in the world. I do not know much about the person. His works, I always thought, had a kind of flowering eroticism in them.
He will be remembered fondly by Bengalis and artists. He will be missed in the galleries too.
JohnyML

Why We Don't have Such Vast Variety of Art

 When I see art critics and art vloggers from all over the world post varieties of art creation on Instagram, I wonder why we don't have such variety in art. I found the following reasons:

1. We have a very limited art market despite all it claims of growing or showing growth potential.
2. Limited art market is directly proportional with the number of art buyers, collectors and investors. Their mutuality and interdependence have caused the limitation of our art market.
3. While the market shows a clear positive bias for the dead and gone masters or about to be dead artists, the galleries do not exert a counter thrust with contemporary artists by giving them more visibility and space to articulate, the way it happened during the first boom of the new millennium.
4. This has caused a negative impact on the possibility of myth making around the contemporaries early on, which would eventually become the qualitative literature for their future markets.
5. Press space for art criticism is next to nil now. No complaints. But the leading art magazines have become semi sales catalogues of their own artists. At the other end of the spectrum B and C grade magazines publish AI driven trash against a payment. The role of the magazines was very pivotal. We have lost it.
6. Thanks to this the new crop of artists and their cultural output are confined to a certain sector of art players, never giving them a chance to become big names. Temporary and instant fame on Instagram seems to be the only avenue that gives these artists a semblance of fame.
7. There are no chance to have definitive writings that discuss the characteristics of our contemporary art; the materials, topics, approaches, understanding of history, economics, culture, ideology and so on.
8. We produce good art but nobody wants it to be brought into the cultural duscourse
9. We produce a lot of bad art. But that has been the case in any country.
10. Art fairs are where one could see some glimpses of novelty. But being short affairs, nothing is done to mainstream them. Of course, I do not discount the efforts of the galleries in supporting them in various ways.
Any solutions?
I believe it is a churning time. As generally observed, many have fallen before the dominant cultural climate of the nation, turning them the apostles of the ruling ideology through aesthetical production.
Churning will throw up solutions. We need to cultivate art among people and turn the cream of middle class into actual art buyers. To make this happen the old ways of looking at cultural production should change.
Unfortunately, we are forced to adhere to tradition and self congratulatory aesthetics of pre-history. We are a community that failed modernism. We use new tools to live the old comfortably. We need to see the world of today through aesthetical means. We should summon up all our crafts and new tools to that end.
And, our art market should encourage variety than norm and trend.
JohnyML

Folk and tribal art are no longer marginal


I chanced upon a reel in which I found Dr. Ashrafi Bhagat, an art historian specialising in the Madras School and South Indian art, arguing that we should 'mainstream' the folk and tribal art of India. She also mentioned how a work by a folk artist had fetched crores of rupees at an Indian auction.
Folk and tribal art are no longer marginal. There has been a growing interest in these genres of art, along with a newfound interest among buyers in Mughal miniatures. We cannot pinpoint the reasons for this. There could be two reasons, in my view. One, the moderns who rule the market need a somewhat larger historical and aesthetical backdrop for a longer run, which could be provided by traditional and folk aesthetics. History cannot wander around in a liminal space. It needs roots that affirm both continuity and rupture in the flow of creative juices.
Two, buyers and art collectors are becoming sceptical about untested and overtly experimental contemporary artworks. This touch-and-go attitude towards contemporary art, in fact, shows the maturing of the Indian art market. Though we may think that the market is over-infested with the moderns, to the point of dejection, it could also be an indication that the market is consolidating. And before chugging forward, it needs some backup from traditional and folk art. I was looking at the lineup of artists in the booths at the forthcoming Art Mumbai 2026. The ratio is 80:20: 80 seniors, super-seniors and the dead (together making up the 'moderns') and 20 contemporaries (and even among them, you mostly find artists in their late 40s and 50s). The blind investment in contemporaries that characterised the first boom of the millennium seems to be absolutely absent these days.
Coming back to the mainstreaming of folk and tribal art, I would say that we should accept the fact that we have multicultural, heterogeneous and plural aesthetical practices in our country. The mainstream of art, until recently, was constituted by academically educated or academically associated artists. Of late, things have taken a different turn. There are many galleries that specialise exclusively in folk and tribal art. There are institutions and individuals who have devoted their lives and research time to these genres of art.
However, I want to make a distinction when it comes to the cultural uses of art and its ability to evoke discourses that would be beneficial to cultural progress, the making of history and the enhancement of socio-cultural and political discourse. By equating folk and tribal art with modern and contemporary art, we are doing a great disservice to both categories. When we break down everything into economic gains, there may not be such a glaring problem in conjoining them. But if we want to take our discourse further, we need to keep them separate, without denying either category its status, dignity and economic freedom. We should also make sure that no parties involved in these transactions are exploited at any stage of the deal.
Modern and contemporary art are informed practices with academic and intellectual depths. They cannot exist simply as hereditary practices or ritualistic exercises. They have a social role to perform, beginning with informed formal aesthetics and extending to their connections with previously existing models and thought processes, and finally to the interpretative zones that move a work from being an innocent aesthetic object to becoming a potent historical document and living evidence of a particular time.
While Mughal miniatures could attract academic interest for various reasons pertaining to the migration of artists, patronage, the cosmopolitan outlook of the rulers, caste transgressions within the Karkhanas, the temporary disappearance of religious boundaries, or the transcendental and aesthetical co-habitation of various religions and sections of society, along with their transnational literary and stylistic lives, folk and tribal art often lives within the ritualistic zone (with all the intellectual and emotional paraphernalia accompanying it) of the individuals who make it. It tries, once in a while, to experiment with 'new' experiences but eventually returns to its fixed aesthetical norms, only to become a prisoner of its own loose visual grammar.
It is pertinent that we promote both modern and contemporary art without losing focus on folk and tribal art. However, equating them without qualifications would be fallacious and anti-historical, leading to nothing but discursive chaos, signifying nothing.
JohnyML

 

The Symbiotic Ecosystem of Art


 

Art means different things to different people. For a serious artist, it is a TINA thing: There Is No Alternative. Art is not a career option but an existential compulsion. The artist spends a lifetime making it, with or without materialistic success. For an art historian, art is an object of erudite investigation. For a critic, it is a pursuit of an imagined idealism, informed by historical knowledge, aesthetic positions and personal convictions. For the market player, it is a product to be packaged, showcased and marketed well.
These different choices and missions establish one fundamental fact: none of them can exist in isolation. They are interdependent, cohabiting like members of a human family. They may have different interests, ambitions and motivations, but they are tied to the yoke of the same culture. Remove one from its place, and the others begin to lose their footing.
Artists, being the creators of art, often assume a position of superiority over the other categories of actants. They believe that without their creativity, the rest would have nothing to do. But imagine a situation in which there is no market for art. Art is bartered for services and valued primarily for its decorative or utilitarian functions. It remains a life-craft, fulfilling the needs of confined societies. Its existence does not necessarily require critics, historians, galleries or auction houses.
But art refused to remain confined within such limited social arrangements. Artists sought patronage, travelled to newer locations and entered unfamiliar cultural territories. They needed a market. The market, in turn, needed to establish the artist's lineage, artistic strength and stylistic identity. It wanted to know where the artist stood in relation to his time and what continuities he maintained with the past. Art historians fulfilled this demand. Sellers never wrote history, but they respected those who did. History became an instrument of cultural authentication.
History dealt with the larger picture, bringing time into the equation as its principal category of assessment. Criticism became its immediate and temporal contributor, recording facts, opinions, conflicts and perspectives. Art criticism gradually became a documentary source for historical research, providing evidence to substantiate claims made by artists, sellers and collectors. What was written as an opinion in the present could become historical evidence in the future.
Collectors collected because they believed they shared a sense of history and belonging to a geographical territory. Parochialism gradually acquired the vocabulary of patriotism, and patriotism, in turn, gave birth to inclusive and exclusive forms of nationalism. To demonstrate their allegiance to this evolving cultural identity, the rich and affluent began patronising artists through collecting and commissioning. They selected artists whom critics praised or those whose works invited intelligent criticism. When they chose relatively unknown artists, they often asked their scribes to write about them, ensuring that these artists found a place in the annals of family histories. Cultural history, in this sense, was not always written from a distance; sometimes, it was commissioned from within.
Then came the asset class. It wanted everything it owned to be periodically assessed and accounted for as an asset. Portfolio managers discovered that art, too, could enter the investment portfolio. The cultural meanings of art began to recede, while its potential for economic returns came to the foreground. Buying art became an addictive game among affluent peers, particularly through auctions. Auctions did more than facilitate transactions; they manufactured visibility, established price benchmarks and reinforced the perception of value. The art object increasingly became a symbol of economic transaction.
But here is the irony: to make these economic transactions credible, the asset class needed everything it had once considered secondary or peripheral. It needed artists to produce the objects, galleries to introduce and position them, critics to interpret them, art historians to authenticate their historical relevance, and collectors to establish their desirability. It also needed curators, arrangers, interior designers, art consultants and several other intermediaries to keep the machinery moving.
What we have, therefore, is not a hierarchy in which the artist occupies the top and everyone else serves a subordinate function. It is a symbiotic ecosystem in which cultural production, historical validation, critical interpretation, patronage and economic speculation feed into one another.
The artist may create the work, but cannot single-handedly create its history, market or value. The historian may record its significance, but cannot create the work. The critic may interpret it, but cannot guarantee its survival. The market may assign it a price, but cannot independently manufacture its cultural relevance.
Each claims a certain authority over art, yet none possesses art entirely. That is the paradox of the art world: everyone believes that art needs them more than they need art. But the ecosystem knows otherwise. Disturb one element, and the others will eventually feel the tremor. Remove enough of them, and the entire structure begins to collapse.
JohnyML

Santosh Morajkar: A Life in Art


 


'Santosh Morajkar: A Life in Art' is a volume of tribute to the late artist, who passed away at the age of 53 earlier this year. It has been brought out by the Museum of Goa (MOG), with which he shared a long relationship. Sharada Kerkar, Director of MOG, raises a pivotal question in her preface to the book: "What happens when the artist is no longer here to speak about the work? We often say that art lives beyond the artist. But without continued engagement, documentation and institutional recognition, artists and their practices can gradually become invisible."
Morajkar was certainly a great artist who cared little for the market but invested everything he had in his art. He started off as a printmaker before turning to drawing on surfaces with graphite dust and fine lines, skills he had developed under teachers like Rajan Sripad Fulari and Laxma Goud. But he was in no mood to stop at the world of two-dimensional art. When Subodh Kerkar, a senior Goan artist, invited Morajkar to use his studio facilities to create sculptures, a new phase of his life began. There was no stopping him after that. Morajkar almost abandoned everything else to make sculptures that were quirky, erotic, surrealistic and unsettling in nature.
This commemorative volume captures the life and journey of Morajkar. The publication of such volumes is a rare act in our art scene, where, apart from a few obituaries written by near and dear ones, artists are seldom remembered in any substantial way, especially when they have not contributed significantly to the existing interests of the art market. Morajkar enjoyed moderate success in the pan-Indian art scene, which we often mistake for the Delhi-Mumbai art circuit. Ironically, this happens in a country with a hugely diverse population and an equally varied range of cultural practices.
As one of the few Indian curators to have had the opportunity to curate an exhibition of exclusively Goan artists in Delhi (Goa Reloaded, 2011, NiV Art Centre), with Remo Fernandes, the pioneer of Indian pop music, as its inaugurator, I had the chance to observe many Goan artists and their practices from close quarters. Subodh Kerkar had initiated the project and invited me to Goa. I spent many days visiting studios and interviewing artists, with Kerkar's Panjim gallery serving as the fulcrum of all activities. Later, when I curated the United Art Fair in 2012, a large number of Goan artists participated with great enthusiasm. Morajkar was one of them, and he had a distinct personality.
Thinking of their characteristic variety, I would say that every Goan contemporary artist has a distinct personality and style. If Norman Tagore is reclusive and saintly, Morajkar was like a drunken fool from a Shakespearean drama: wise, witty and incisive in his observations. Pradeep Naik and Viraj Naik are silent and intense in their work. Vitesh Naik is quirky in his work and stylish in his personality. Sripad Gurav is distant but hardworking. Siddharth Gosavi flourishes when he paints elephants. I could name many more, including seniors like Alex Fernandes and Hanuman Kambli. Chaitali Morajkar, Shilpa Naik and Harshada Kerkar constitute the female trio. I am sure many have followed them, including Suhas Shilkar, Siddharth Kerkar, Schon Mendes, Sonatina Mendes and Sonia Rodrigues. My chronology may be wrong, and let it be so.
Morajkar cannot be seen in isolation from all of them. He lived with them, in them and through them. These aspects are adequately captured by the contributors to this volume, including Rajan Sripad Fulari, Vivek Menezes, Viraj Naik and Ahasthy A.
We need to remember Santosh Morajkar, and this volume is a first step towards that. It should serve as a model for other commemorative volumes dedicated to artists who have passed on, leaving behind a substantial body of work but little 'national' recognition.
JohnyML

The Speaking Wall II



 

The Speaking Wall II, an exhibition by artist Harshwardhan Sharma at Sridharani, is interesting for the stylistic modernism he pursues and his choice of subjects, predominantly human faces. Trained at Kala Bhavana, Santiniketan, under doyens like K. G. Subramanyan, Sharma went on to build his career as a painter and pedagogue in Jammu, his hometown. He currently serves as the Chief Art Advisor to the New Delhi Municipal Council.
Sharma paints people he encounters. They are often filtered through his interpretations and take on a different shape on his canvases. One could almost feel that the 'inverted' portraits of people by the German Neo-Expressionist Georg Baselitz have been inverted once again. Bold strokes and stark colours almost de-characterise and re-characterise his subjects simultaneously.
According to Sharma, he never makes his models 'sit' for him. They could be his fellow workers in a college or office, or strangers glimpsed in a crowd. But some of them leave an impression on his mind, and they eventually manifest in his works. One could stand before these paintings for a long time, wondering about the stories and histories of the people in them. Any deductions one makes would probably lead to stories and histories of people from any part of the world, where regional, religious and geographical affiliations become irrelevant.
One thing that particularly struck me was the absence of godly figures or mythological likenesses in Sharma's paintings. While some artists, including very famous ones, try to flow with the times — times that are going through a religious revivalism — by painting and sculpting religious images, Sharma does nothing of the sort. Closely associated with organisations that have strong religious affinities, he nevertheless shows no hint of his religious or spiritual affiliations in his works. Perhaps the artist feels that one should not wear one's identity on one's sleeves, forehead or creative output. So, if you are expecting Hanuman, Ram, Jatayu and so on in Sharma's paintings, you will be disappointed.
JohnyML