Saturday, January 5, 2013

Mamallapuram Diary

(Crocodiles can Jump- with my Daughter)


Madan is a pleasant young man and he goes by his first name like many of the South Indian guys. He hardly speaks and smiles a lot. When he speaks he does it in Tamil. Madan drives a taxi. And I have a problem. I landed at the Chennai airport with this confidence that I could handle a Tamil situation in a Tamilian’s way. I know a bit of Tamil which I had learnt while watching Tamil movies inspired by the acting of Kamal Haasan and Rajnikaant, a film parallel to the then Ambassdor and Fiat cars. We had this duality during the pre-global days. When we said Tata we added Birla. Hero and villain were too defined characters. Grey shades were absolutely kept out of heroic characters. Despite the Eastman colours, our way of looking at the world was black and white. I could render Tamil dialogues with some kind of verve. And I thought with the changing times my confidence too had increased.

A hot afternoon in Chennai proves things otherwise. I try to speak to the taxi driver in Tamil and what comes out is a language which is mixed with Hindi, Tamil, English and Malayalam. I try my level best to tune my language skills to Tamil and it just does not happen. But business does not need too many languages. Though I find myself at the tower Babel, the driver understands me. He takes me and my family to Cholamandal artists’ village. I meet Madan on the next day. With Madan I could retrieve my lost pride, I think and I try to speak to him in Tamil. The more I try the more Hindi comes out. The more I try to keep Hindi under check the more English comes out. When I smother both these languages to death something does not sound either like Tamil or Malayalam comes out. I smile at myself after each statement that I make. Madan knows my linguistic emergency. He tells me that he could understand Hindi and English, a little bit, he adds. I tell him as an act of saving my face that I also handle Tamil, a little bit. We are on the same boat. We share the same pain and pleasure of strange languages.

(A croc resting in his pond)

Madan’s pleasant smile and friendly nature make me forget the language problem. And the first destination for the day is to the Crocodile Park in Nemmeni fifteen kilometres away from Cholamandal. People, children and grown-ups alike, throng here. They all want to see the crocodiles who in fact do not want to see so many people. But the crocs don’t care. They just sleep on. There are thousands of them in different cages, ponds and pools. Each section belongs to a different species. But I don’t have the patience to see the difference between one species to another. For me they all look alike, ferocious and dormant for the time being. At each fifty meters there are sign boards that tell the people to abstain from throwing stones at the stone like crocs. They may be looking disinterested. But they can fly like birds and make you lose a limb. So instead of throwing stones and sand at the crocs people take their photographs. I also join the ritual by clicking the pictures of my family. Kids are super excited seeing so many crocs at one go.

In one catchment, amongst the hundreds of crocs in different resting postures we chance upon one croc climbing on another. Instantly I realize that they are making love. But most of the people, perhaps even after knowing that it is a very private moment film them in the act as if they were watching a very steamy scene in an x rated movie. One young girl with her parents shoots the act. Mother shares the excitement by saying that one croc is climbing on the other. The father shies away from the scene after giving it a covert glance. I see one young dark complexioned fat woman in her silk saree and jasmine flowers on hair, sheepishly recording it. After a few moments she runs away from the scene giggling. I think of her sharing the pictures she has just taken with her friends secretively.

(A signboard at the croc park)

Here is a very daring act of a few men and women. In a catchment I see two crocs lying along the walls of the pit. Three men and two women are in the same pit, a few feet away from the ferocious reptiles, cleaning the water and pit. People gather around them and for a moment they all forget that they are there to see the crocs. They wonder at the courage of the men and women who are in the pit. In another area there is a signboard saying that to see the most dangerous animal on the earth open the box. There is box erected on a perch. I know that there is a mirror in it. But I share the enthusiasm of the kids and open the panels of it as if I were mortally frightened. There we see our reflections in a mirror. Perhaps, it is predictable for me as I have seen similar experiments. In the United Art Fair 2012, artist Megha Joshi had done an installation. It was a temple made of chappals. Inside the temple at the shrine you could see a mirror reflecting your own image. I had seen a lot of people taking their pictures at Megha Joshi’s shrine. Also I remember Sree Narayana Guru, the illustrious social reformer of 19th c Kerala. He also had enshrined a mirror in the place of an idol. Then I think this installation at the croc park in Nemmeni is a better installation than many that we generally seen in art galleries.

From there Madan takes us to Mahabalipuram. It is Mammallapuram in fact. The Pallava King Narasimhavarman II commissioned the making of these monolithic rock temples in 7th century AD. One could see the craftsmanship and the sculptural understanding of the artists who had carved these temples. There are five of them in one site and are called Five Rathas (Five Chariots). They are also called Pandava Rathas with reference to Mahabharata. Archaeological Survey of India clearly notifies that it does not have anything to do with the Pandavas. But the guides who eke out a living have done the damage by this time. They tell people that these temples are Pandava creations. They point out the enormous rock ball sitting precariously on a rock land and tell people that it was a butter ball kept by young Krishna. None asks when young Krishna came there with a butter ball all the way from Mathura, which in North India. Guides make their own stories in all the archaeological sites.

 (Mahabalipuram rathas)

I remember listening to a story told me by a tourist guide in some rock land in one of my expeditions. He shows me a groove along the rock and tells me that it was the groove created by Bheema who was hauling a chain. None asks him why Bheema was on chain in that particular place. There is a place in Kerala called Chadayamangalam. It is a derivative of Jatayu Mangalam. It was in this place where Jatayu had confronted Ravana who was abducting Sita. Some people show some recessions on rock lands and tell that those are the foot marks of Sita. In Kanyakumari (cape comerin) you see the foot prints of Devi. But they look embossed. How come Devi had such a footstep? Religious belief is something that does not expect logical questions. Sometimes it is always better not to ask questions. The stories told by guides are seriously amusing. Once a guide took me to Fatehpur Sikri and made me to stand in a corner. He made a sound and it echoed. Then he told me that it was how the soldiers communicated with each other when the enemies appeared at a distance. It sounds logical for a moment. Then it is a sham when you think of it. Similarly when you go to Khajuraho, the guides show you where exactly the copulating couples could be found at the outer layer of the temples. I had heard a beautiful story. In Dwapara Yuga, when Bheema was wandering in the forest he found a huge ring. He took it up, raised above his head and then let it go. The ring fell around him without touching his body. Some sage later on told him that it was the finger ring of Sita who had lived in Treta Yuga. When Ravana was abducting her she threw her jewels down. It was her finger ring. Sometimes myths make sense, beautifully. In Kaliyuga we are small people.

(Mrinal explaining a sculpture to Maitreya)

It is always good to have an in-house art historian. It is always convenient. Mrinal knows art history well so she explains the history to my son, who is at that age of understanding history in the form of stories. However, I listen to music of chisels unheard now but heard in a rhythmic pattern for years together in 7th Century AD. I see the devotion of the artists and craftsmen. They used to work in guilds. The first group of carvers carved cave shapes out of rocks. The second group was more skilful than the former. They chiselled the sculptures. The last group was the finest artists. They gave the detailing to the individual figures. It was a glorious moment in time. And their spirits are still around. If you have a pair of eyes you could see.

(shore temple)

The shore temple is no longer shore temple. The shore has been pushed out through a strategic fencing. I was here three years back. That time the fencing was not so prominent. Now the shore temple is an isolated island. The Tsunami in 2004 had brought a few sculptural works out from the pit of sea. Now they are kept preserved and conserved. We walk along a narrow pathway leading to the beach. On the one side there is a line of shops that sell trinkets to fried fish, carved stones to figurines and statuettes, hats to chappals. Women and children come behind you pleading to buy some beads and malas. At the beach, I could make out those people who have seen sea before and those who have never seen it. I could make out people from North and South. The first timers revel at the sight of water. They throw away their clothes and jump into water, men and women alike. They outdo the waves in their mirth. Horses move around the beach with their tenders. If you are interested you can have a ride.

On the way back to Cholamandal, we visit, Dakshinchitra, a living museum of craft and architecture from different parts of India. It is a site of culture that has been manufactured with the sole purpose of consuming/selling. Still it has a sort of energy in the reproduction of architectural samples. I take a few photographs and pose for a few. Family try their hands at pottery. The potter with a benevolent smile holds the hands of women and helps them to shape pots out of clay. Bangle sellers and pottery teachers could touch women’s hands without asking for permission, I think. Otherwise one should be a palm reader. I am none of the above so I don’t get a chance to hold the hands of women. But I am happy to hold some hands that have invested their complete faith in me.





Thursday, January 3, 2013

Chennai Diary

(Cholamandal Artists' Village, Chennai)


I remember two analogies with Delhi’s cold. A coconut fell on someone’s head. He did not realize anything. He did not feel any pain either. But he felt something fell on his head. He took it up and looked at it. It was a coconut. Seeing it, he fainted. The other story is about a guy with less knowledge of English language. He read some pornographic story. Nothing happened to him. He went home. Pulled out a dictionary from the bookshelf. He flipped through the pages and he had a huge erection.

I did not know about Delhi’s cold while heading towards the Indira Gandhi International Airport. In the flight, I flipped through the newspaper and found that it was the coldest day in Delhi since last forty four years. I started shivering. But the shiver did not last long. Two seasoned Air India airhostesses who came from Lucknow and were heading towards Chennai, warmed the atmosphere around me with their deep sleep waves. They were just sitting next to me. The other hostesses on duty were extremely nice to them. They were literally respecting their age and experience. Old is gold. In front of Air India hostesses, passengers including the most mischievous kids behave. So did my kids. So the flight to Chennai was rather eventless.

(The Cholamandal guest house)

Airports attract me in a different way. In airport everyone is special, except for the parents who take their kids for a vacation. They are miserable in similar ways. I see kids howling at an invisible god sitting inside the vending machines and demanding packets of wafers and packaged juices, and their parents gloriously ignoring them by vacantly looking into space or peering into their laptop screens or even rolling eyes at the screaming kids. I look at one parent and he turns into a mirror. I see myself there and he seems himself in me. And we smile at each other as if we knew well in our previous life. I was a pig and he too was one. It is our human phase. This too shall pass, I tell myself.

I digressed, I know. Digressions are inevitable habit of story-telling human beings. If there are no digressions most of the stories could be finished in three lines. He was born, he loved, lived and died. The in between things could be sufficed in two or three lines again. He fell in love with a woman. He married her or lost her. Invariably he married to some woman thanks to the unavoidable hormonal drive which is often dubbed as familial responsibilities, suffered, fell in love with another woman and died. I remember O.V.Vijayan explaining how Bhagavat Gita was written. In Haryana, there lived two families. They were blood related. They had some issues related some farm land. One day they gathered a placed called Kurukshetra. They were supposed to fight it out. There was this guy called Arjun on the one side. He looked at his relatives and felt bad. His friend Krishan was exhorting him to fight. Arjun did not relent. Krishan got really irritated. He said, ‘Bhen...od..Maaro saalon ko’ (Sister fucker beat them). Some poets were around. They listened the whole abuse and they sang it in poetic meters. This was the birth story of Bhagavat Gita, according to late O.V.Vijayan.

(Interior of the guest house)

So, airports are nowhere places. They are sort of no man’s lands. You may have a passport and a ticket. However, unless and until you get into a flight and reach your destination you are in transit. Airports are transit places. You may try to show off. But if your flight is delayed then you are a screwed up refugee in a no man’s land. There was a time when the former USSR was rapidly disintegrating into smaller countries. Some people from the former Soviet Union were travelling. When they were in some transit lounge at some airport, their country had become something else. Their passports were no longer valid. They were refugees without a land all of a sudden. Fortunately, we Indians have learnt to live with our Indian-ness. Despite the reformation of new states carved out of earlier states, we still remain Indians. If we have any problem, we will be dubbed as Maoists and could become the guests of state very soon. So we remain polite citizens in the transit lounges.

I had my tryst with state once. I was about to be called a Maoist. Stars were in my favour. It was in 2008. Art market boom was in full swing. The party was on. It was the day of the annual display of Baroda’s fine arts faculty. A friend of mine booked a ticket for me from Delhi to Baroda. I was travelling like a mad person in those days. I was supposed to go in the morning and come back at night. Next evening I was supposed to fly to Seoul. Kingfisher was my flight to Baroda (today both Boom and Kingfisher are in bad shape). I got my boarding pass and got into the flight. As I was coming back in the same evening I had not taken any bag with me. I was wearing a black jeans and black T-shirt. To add value to my presence I was holding one book in my hand.

When I entered the flight, I had a sense of uneasiness. The people who were going to Baroda were not looking like the seasoned Gujaratis. They were all looking like people from North East. I shirked off my doubt and tightened my seat belt. The doors were closed. The airhostess announced. The flight would take three hours. I jumped up. Where was it going? I asked loudly. Someone rushed to me. Sir, she muttered. I wanted to go to Baroda. How come a Baroda flight took this much time? I asked furiously. She said the flight was going to Bagdogra in Assam. I looked at my boarding pass. Yes it was a boarding pass to Bagdogra. My friend had booked for Baroda and the agent had booked it for Bagdogra. We were all drunk by the market boom so we did not even care to check the ticket once. I raised alarm. My Seoul trip was going to be screwed up. The flight had already started moving. I insisted I wanted to get out.

 (Kids playing on an installation)

Airhostesses ran. People shouted at me. Suddenly there was a situation. An ordinary Indian citizen appeared in front of them as a potential terrorist. Was I looking like one in my black attire? The plane came to a halt. Something was happening outside. In five minutes commandoes entered the flight. They got me. They checked me thoroughly. Their suspicion increased when they came to know that I was travelling without any luggage. Finally with a lot of commando security I was led out of the flight. I was taken to a destination which I never thought existed in an airport. They made me sit there. Many officials interrogated me. They told me I could go free but the flight should land at Bagdogra Airport safe. If not... For the first time in my life I prayed for the safe landing of a flight in which I was not travelling.

Two year ago I had written about the airport bookstalls. They display a very eclectic collection of books. May be you chance upon a good book perhaps you never intend to read but by accident you see them, pick them up and then fall in love with them. Today too when I am at the airport I check three different bookstalls full with the latest hot books. But none attracts me. My son says he is attracted to many books. I buy a couple of books for him. I pick up Vishnu Sharma’s Panchatantra. I have read it so I keep it back. Then I pick up Khushwant Singh’s latest work on spiritual sayings. I keep it back too. I look for something very light to read. But when I touch each book they tell me I know the content. Or I feel that I don’t have time to read them all. I go through the Narcopolis by Jeet Tayyil. I flip through the pages of Guru Charan Das’ latest work India Develops at Night (or something like that). Then I go through Manu Josheph’s new novel. I keep it in its place thinking that I would read it later. I open the Open Magazine. The lead story speaks of how the new urban couples lead an underground life. I feel some kind of agitation in me and I throw it back. Somehow today I found the airport bookstalls not attracting me.

So I think of writing something that I would like to read. It is not about my arrogance or ego. Sometimes it is always good to write in order to read. In another bookstall I feel like stalling my ego by touching a travelogue written by R.K.Narayan. Also I chance upon the latest work of Umberto Eco’s eclectic collection of essays written on different contemporary issues. I read a few lines and I feel that I know the content. But then I also know that I don’t know the content. But I don’t feel like reading. I should have read them all for polishing my style of writing. I postpone the reading. Then I flip through the pages of an Osho book. But I can hear each word printed in there in Rajneesh’s voice. So I decide to write what I want to read. All what I have written so far is what I want to read today.



(The guest house campus)

In Chennai airport the people who alight from the flight look like the people from an alien land. They all rush to reach the lavatories to remove their woollens and jackets. They are now in a land where the temperature is thirty degree Celsius. I too remove my layers of clothes only to reveal my slimmer self to the world. At the pre-paid taxi counter they tell me that they don’t know Cholamandalam Artists’ Village. They ask me for a correct address or a phone number. But I am adamant. I tell them that it is their duty to find out the place otherwise why they are running a pre-paid taxi service. Finally the man at the counter makes a couple of phone calls and finds out where it is. It costs me Rs.800/- And we get into the old rickety ambassador car and drive towards Cholamandalam Artists Village.

At Cholamandalam we are received by Mr.Nagayya, a black complexioned man with white facial hairs that give him the appearance of a negative that has yet to be printed positive. He does the rituals of a receptionist and allots us the pre-booked guest house. It is a studio apartment with an attic for a bedroom. Spacious, roomy and properly lit (that unfortunately sheds no light on my face when I am video chatting with friends) the guest house accommodation is quite cosy. The canteen attached to it is so inexpensive that you tend to tell the owner of it that he should charge a bit more for food. Mr.Nagayya had personally introduced me to Mr.Augustine who runs the canteen. The food is good and the humble price of it make you think about all kinds of food that you have eaten from different restaurants at different places and times.

Cholamandalam is frozen view in the history. Started in 1960s by the illustrious painter, theoretician and the former principal of the Madras College of Arts, K.C.S.Panicker, Cholamandalam was started off as an artists’ co-operative at Injambakkam, a sea shore village thirty kilometres away from the historical site of Mahabalipuram. The artists and the disciples of K.C.S live here. K.C.S’ son and noted sculptor, Nandagopal is the head of the institution who manages the running of the K.C.S Museum here. The campus has a huge old banyan tree and around which there strewn are the sculptures of noted artists from India and elsewhere. It was one of the most happening places in Indian art some point but by end of 1980s, the charm of this place started waning. Today also people come here to visit the museum and live here and work for a while. But somehow the ghetto attitude of the artists who live here has pushed it out of the mainstream art activities of India. Or is it because of the apathy of the mainstream art historical discourse of India? One needs to probe.

(Maitreya under the grand old Banyan tree at cholamandal)

In the evening, I walk towards the beach with my family. My children are excited at the prospectus of playing in water, a rare experience in Delhi. But we are disappointed. The beach, half a kilometre away from our guest house and the Cholamandalam estate is a desolated area though resorts have come up along the sea shore. The private resorts have colonized the sea shore. In the competition, the Cholamandalam sea shore is seem to be lost out. In Chennai, while we were coming towards Cholamandalam I had seen such losing out villages to suburban activities. New townships are in the making. The horizon line once there was only the vast expanse of space and heat, today has defined architectural structures coming up as in any other satellite cities in the world. For a moment I felt like I was travelling from Kolkata airport to Kolkata city. There too a new Kolkata is in the making. May be it is already made. It is one year since I visited Kolkata last.

(JohnyML)

When I write this, my son sits with me with his head leaning over my right shoulder. He keeps reading the words that I type out as if he were a word prompter. When a word is refused to be accepted by the Microsoft word he asks me why it happens so. You may wonder why I am writing about him. I don’t find writing this particular aspect about my son a bit show off why because it is what most of the artists do when they paint the portraits of their sons. It must be out of sheer joy of painting it. I find the same joy when I write about it. Interestingly, one hour before he too was writing about his arrival in Chennai in his note book. Perhaps, it is a part of his class assignment: what have you done during your vacation? He writes both in Hindi and English. Who knows one day he too would write something like this and his son would lean his head on his right shoulder and read what he writes. Wouldn’t it be like a reflection in the parallel mirrors, never ending and immense?






Saturday, December 29, 2012

A Nameless and Faceless Martyr: Legend of a Rape Victim

(Young women protesting against rape at Rashtrapati Bhavan)


I don’t know her name. I have not seen her face. But her death leaves a deep hollow in my heart. A shiver passes through my spine when I think about the horror that had faced since the fateful night of 16th December. She fought bravely to survive. If she had survived she would have fought the system and the perpetrators of rape bravely. But death brought an abrupt end to that young life. Sitting here at the desk, like most of the intellectuals in the country, I too think that we are over-concerned about the death of this girl because the molestation happened in Delhi and Delhi is the seat of power, and we don’t care about the innumerable rape cases which are much more horrible than this one. But that is not the case. She was the inevitable martyr of the savage crime called rape and through her death she has alerted the conscience of this country. As Rajdeep Sardesai rightly pointed out, it is the time for the political leaders of this country to think differently. It is high time that they come back to the people and face them. They are supposed to leave high security covering provided to them and meet people in the street when they are agitated. We need a Gandhiji today to sit with the agitating younger lot of this country, to sit with them, share with them and give them positive directions.

Moving symbolisms are always a must for social movements. As Edward Alby said, someone has to become a scapegoat when none takes responsibility to become one. In 1970s and 80s when the Indian youth were not going anywhere and were caught in the dead and stale dream of nation building through licence quota raj, we had a symbol in the guise of the angry young man portrayed by Amitabh Bacchan. When he was shooting for Manmohan Desai’s Coolie in a Bombay studio, in 1982 he was fatally injured by accident. He was admitted to the Breach Candy Hospital in Mumbai. The whole of India stood up in prayers and the ordeal went on for months for the actor. Finally he survived. It was for the first time after Mahatma Gandhi the whole nation stood up for one man; a huge symbol of hope and direction. Amitabh Bacchan survived his injuries. And today at the age 70 he is healthy enough to play another innings in Bollywood. 

(Amitach Bacchan in Coolie)

If Amitabh Bacchan intestinal injuries moved a nation in early 80s, today a girl’s intestinal injuries move a nation which has evolved itself into a modern nation through the process of globalization. But how can we call ourselves modern when we cherish the age old ideals of a male dominated society. While Aamir Khan in his famous series ‘Satyameva Jayate’ while debating the issues pertaining to love marriages questions the Khap Panchayat members on their insistence on traditional values of the Indian society. Khan rightly asks them whether they become only alerted and vengeful when the females take a decision on their lives and become the authorities of their own bodies and minds. He prods them by asking why the same kind of vengeance does not occur amongst the Khap leaders when children are abused and young girls are raped.

To my shock I found out that many of the young people (of course they are outnumbered by the ones who had congregated at the India Gate to protest against Rape during the last few days) cherish and nourish the same values as strong and vindictive as those of the Khap Panchayats. These young people say that the girls should be wearing proper clothes then things will be good for them. This view comes from absolute blindness and ignorance. Both these entities are fuelled by the ideology of male chauvinism. Dresses are a part of one’s personality and the way one wants to present oneself to the world. It is a part of confidence building and it contains a great amount of symbolism. Of course during our aesthetic intercourse with the mainstream movies we willingly suspend our political correctness and enjoy the scantly clad heroines and item girls. There is an osmotic exchange between the popular culture as exemplified by movie and fashion industries and the way the young people dress in any country. They mutually reflect desires, aspirations and attitudes. As we are in a male dominated situation whatever the man wears becomes cool and whatever the woman wears becomes a source that beckons rapists. It is absolutely a misplaced argument. None has the right to dictate what one should wear in their daily lives.

(punks in a street)

Social customs and practices are the results of codifications that took many years to evolve. Such customs are made mainly to protect the interests of the clans and avoid assumed social embarrassments. It was applicable for a frozen society that was held within a particular time and ethos. We have forgotten that we are a changed society today. And social mobility and visibility have become more or less equal for the males and females. And the social pace is such that we are no longer able to cling to certain customs and practices for not more than a season. In that case what could be the perennial value that would rule a society for a long time? No dress code is a permanent dress code anymore. No attitude is a cool attitude forever. In that flux situation what are the kind of ideals that we are insisting that our social members whether are males or females or queer gender should follow?

In an evolving society there cannot be hard and fast rules. And if at all there could be hard and fast rules it should be on the aspects of humanism and humanitarianism. One could cherish develop values which would make one a better human being. One would be able to accept the freedom of the other person, freedom of other communities, genders, religions and ethics in such a changed scenario. It was not that we did not have such values. There was an egalitarian time but somehow in the process of our evolution we have moved farther away from there. The more we think that we are a developed country the more we succumb to the primitive thinking that woman is a material to be consumed and object to be possessed and exchanged. This should change and the change should happen in our own lives, right now.

(Gandhiji- If he was alive...)

The girl who died interestingly is a soldier in a larger battle for human rights and justice. She does not have a face (definitely she had one but we do not want to face it due to various reasons imposed by state and conscience), she does not even have a name. And the nameless martyrs are more powerful than the martyrs with names. Named martyrs will not haunt us like spirits. They haunt us only as images and ideologies. The nameless martyrs will haunt us like ghosts that are never at rest. They will be rested only when justice is brought to them as well as to the cause they have died for. In each nook and corner of our daily lives we would face their invisible presence. In the face of each woman in the street, in the face of our daughters, sisters, wives and mothers, in the faces of the destitute women, sick, working, toiling women we will see the spirit of this nameless martyr. She will remain alive till we stand up for equal rights and justice. We have got to get it for her. No RIP messages will rest her in ultimate peace. 



Friday, December 28, 2012

Today I Decide to call Myself a Non-Malayali

(Santiago Siarre's work at the Kochi Muziris Biennale- A perfect irony of Capitalism)


I wonder whether I am any more a Malayali. I had all this pride to be a Malayali though I did not marry a Malayali woman. My formative years were spent in Kerala and my thinking process is more or less shaped by the typical Kerala milieu. My black humor, cynicism and the perennial irreverence for the normative come from the tradition of Kunchan Nambiar, Sanjayan, E.V.Krishna Pillai, Kunjunni, O.V.Vijayan and V.K.N. To criticize without fear was a lesson learnt from the columns written by critics and theoreticians like M.Govindan, M.N.Vijayan, Sukumar Azhikode and M.Krishnan Nair. My defiance for political understanding was shaped by reading E.M.S, P.Govinda Pillai, B.Rajeevan, Sakharia, K.Venu and Ajitha. My poetics is shaped out of reading Ezhuthacchan, Kunchan Nambiar, Cherussery, Kumaran Asan, Ulloor, Vallathol, Ayyappa Panicker, Satchidanandan, Balachandran  Chullikkadu, Kureeppuzha Sreekumar and the young ones like Anvar Ali and Pavithra Theekkuni. My feminism comes from Lalithambika Antharjanam, Madhavikkutty, Sugathakumari and J.Devika. My cinematic understanding comes from I.V.Sasi, Adoor Gopalakrishnan, Aravindan, John Abraham, Priyadarshan and so on. I love all the mimicry artists in Kerala because they are the people who carry forward the tradition of Kunchan Nambiar. And my artistic understanding comes from Namboothiri, Kanai, Shibu Natesan to all those friends who used to spend endless hours discussing art at the Trivandrum fine arts college and public library.

That does not mean that I had closed my windows to the world. Born and brought up in an egalitarian society I was well informed of all what had been going on all over the world. I literally grew up under the pictures of Gandhiji, Kennedy, Marx and Lenin. I was guided by a pair of sharp eyes of my father who read more Russian literature than Indian literature. My parents were daring enough to give me a name ‘Johny’ even when we had a small temple right in the middle of our courtyard where my grandmother worshipped Shiva, Ganesha, Lord Ayyappa and Krishna. I grew up with Muslim friends who attended all the temple festivals. I feasted with them in most of their religious occasions. Hindu boys worked as volunteers in Muslim sisters’ marriages and vice versa. Party politics did not deter anybody from having strong social bonding. When it was dark, those college girls alighted at the local railway station were accompanied to their doorsteps by young men who did not every try to molest them. I was a proud Malayali.

 (My picture featured in Atul Dodiya's work at the Kochi Muziris Biennale)

I have been living away from Kerala for the last two decades. Not even a single day passed in my life without singing a Malayalam song or reciting a Malayalam poem in my mind all these days. For years on I used to be very nostalgic; a kind of feeling that was not finding enough avenues to express. Delhi has always had a strong Malayali population. At times I made friends with a few of them and most of the time I kept myself aloof. But I was not away from the Malayali ethos that defined me. I imbibed North Indian ways of living and negotiated with my body and mind to be an Indian rather than a Malayali. But my practice has always been egalitarian though the critical Malayali’s essence working throughout as a guiding spirit. People used to criticize me for not transforming myself into a complete North Indian with an accented Malayalam and more English. I am a very proud person with a strong command over Malayalam as well as English as useful languages. This had even given me opportunity to translate international literature into Malayalam by the major publishing house, D.C.Books.

But today I am ashamed of calling myself a Malayali. I am ashamed because the government in my state Kerala has lost all its sense of direction, democracy and justice. It was just a month back that a special enquiry committee deputed by the Finance Department of the Government of Kerala, after its meticulous investigations found that there had been discrepancies in allocation and expenditure of the five crore rupees funding to the Kochi Muziris Biennale trust. The committee also suggested that the organization should be black listed and a vigilance enquiry should be ordered. Following this the cabinet took a decision to order a vigilance enquiry on the Kochi Muziris Biennale Trust. If found guilty, it was even proposed that the organizers should pay the money back to the government coffers.

(May I help you- Young volunteers at KMB- Can you really help?)

On 12th December 2012 the Kochi Muziris Biennale was inaugurated. Ironically the Chief Minister and the cultural minister who had declared a vigilance enquiry on the organizers attended the inaugural function. In no other state you would find the state heads attending a function which is under scam and suspicion. Ever since the KMB Trust was complaining that they did not have enough money to finish the works and the Biennale was attracting a lot of visitors and it was a grand opportunity for the financial development of Kerala. Film star John Abraham visited the Biennale and offered Rs.10,00,000/- Media celebrated it. Auto major BMW also is reportedly pumped in some money to the Biennale Trust. Several other dignitaries visited the Biennale and some of them demanded that the government should support the organizers. Super Star Mammootty also visited the Biennale but he raised the issue of accountability and transparency. But nobody highlighted his comments. Today, both the ruling and opposition MLAs from Kochi region ask for further financial assistance to the Trust, which in fact the government had categorically denied when the enquiry report became public.

You may ask why I am opposing or people like me opposing further financial assistance to the KMB Trust. Yes, we have been opposing the lack of transparency and funding modes pertaining to the KMB. None of us ever said that we would stop Biennale. Anything wonderful happening for any reason in any aspect of social life is welcomed by us though it has been misinterpreted by many. I am disappointed because a government that has found anomalies in an organization is now planning to give more financial support to the KMB Trust. That is against all democratic values and it denies justice to people who demand transparency in funding matters.

 (Subodh Gupta's work at KMB)

One can understand why the MLAs and the business communities in Kerala want the KMB Trust to be supported. They want their business ventures to flourish if biennale brings more business opportunities in terms of tourism. And it does happen. There is no denial to it. But let’s approach the issue from a different angle. The initial support or Rupees five crore was given to start the biennale activities. The agreement was that the rest of the money would be raised by the Trust from the private sector. But the Trust failed miserably in getting private sponsorship. So they, in the name of art and culture demand more money from the government. Even after the vigilance enquiry hanging on their heads if they are asking for more funding from the government and the government contemplating on releasing more funds, then we should understand that there is something deeper cooking or something decaying terribly. What is decaying is nothing but democracy and justice. The government and business lobbies could flout the democratic demands of the opposing people and silence the voices of opposition. This is brutal. The egalitarian Kerala has succumbed to the rule of money and power.

I don’t want to belong to that society and claim that we, Malayalis are very politically informed people and we do not allow any kind of injustice in our state. Kerala has ultimately proved that art and culture could be another avenue of business expansion than critical thinking. I am not against Biennale. I will go to see it but not as a Malayali but as a dispassionate art lover. I hang my head in shame on behalf of all those friends who still give it a fight.




Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Strip Me of my Manhood because I am a Rapist



Bobbitization, hanging, life imprisonment or chemical castration to the Delhi gang rapists, asks the newspapers to its readers. If I could pass my judgement on those people who have raped a young woman in a moving bus in Delhi on a cold December night (16th December 2012), I ask them to be chemically castrated first, torture them with all the possible tortures that they could get in a life time, cut their organs and hang them with immediate effect. They don’t deserve a dignified trial even. I am not asking us to reverse the clock of civilization and go to a brutal era where instant punishment could be handed out to the culprits in full view of the public. But it is the voice of a helpless man who has a daughter, wife, mother, sister, girl students and female friends. I am utterly helpless and if something happens to any of these people so brutal like what happened to that girl on that night, I would bray for their blood and nothing would stop me. I will leave all my secular credential behind, I would keep all my Gandhian thoughts aside and I will forget all my scepticism on capital punishment in a civilized country and would ask for immediate justice, though the decimation of four culprits will not bring eventual justice to all the women in the world because like these rapists who are caught now, many are walking scot free here and many intend to do this heinous crime when their reason betrays them with momentary pleasures of hunting and forced intercourse.

If my sentences could carry the legal vehemence of justice, I sentence these rapists to death. If my words were gallows I would have hung them from each word till their ugly necks snap in the noose of my agitation. If my words were razor blades, they would have cut their male organs. If my life could raise strong walls of darkness and loneliness I would have pushed them into the dungeons that I have created for them. If my words were chemicals I would have castrated them by now. I am outraged not because I have a daughter, wife, mother, sister and female friends but because I see myself as my gender as brutal one capable of committing any kind of atrocities on females. I am ashamed of calling myself a man who could fall back to savagery with an excuse of being drunk or intoxicated or I could feel like a hunter when I am there with a few friends whose presence would provide me all the courage on earth to hunt down a hapless woman and molest her like a beast. I do not want to exist in this world like a savage if my gender is not giving me any indication of civilization. My place is in the jungle.

Have you ever had sex with a woman, my male friend? If you are civilized man, your woman could stop you with one single word, ‘no’ if she does not want to have a union with you. One single piece of cloth or a single look of defiance, reluctance or non-approval or even a single pressing of thighs together could dissuade you from forcing yourself on her. And you try to do it without her approval either she will offer your body as if she were a corpse or she will have it with you in utter state of dejection. Again you try it without her consent, it will be the most brutal act that you could ever commit in the world even if she is your legally wedded wife. Then what do you actually do when you attempt a rape? You become a beast that kill for pleasure, you forget reason and wipe out all kinds of humanity from your heart and brain and you become a mass of muscles fitted with limbs that could be used as pincers, chains and gagging equipments. You hurt your partner beyond any measures when you force yourself upon her.

I see so many young and old men in the street who all look harmless even when some of them look so arrogant and capable of doing anything bestial. But all of them do not rape. The idea of rape comes from the momentary lack of reason and refuting of human nature, its sophistication that took eons to develop and manifest. The courage to do an act of rape comes from the notion of power that the man feels is naturally invested in him. The force of it comes from the primitive ideas of hunting. Such people do not deserve to live. You look at history; history is a narrative of rapes that are not explicit but are summarized in one or two lines. All the wars resulted into rapes because the weapon wielding soldiers found women as the potential objects to shame the opponent. Woman’s body was a location to play the politics of men who are at war with each other. Nations captured women and sent to the warfronts as service women who were destined to satisfy the sexual hunger of soldiers in war. They were brutally raped not by ten men but by hundreds of them in one day.

Our two major epics, Mahabharata and Ramayana revolve around the conquest of women’s body. Had it not been Sita’s abduction by Ravana there would not have been any Ramayana. Soorpanakha was disfigured because she was sexually potent and was desiring a handsome Rama. We never asked why a woman was punished like that only because she desired a man of her choice. Has she not got any power over her own heart and body? Had it not been Panchali’s humiliation in the Kaurava court, there wouldn’t have been any Mahabharata. When Pandavas were playing dice with their half-brothers none asked Draupadi whether she was ready to stand in as a guarantee. Today, a woman even in the company of a man is not safe because she does not have the right to go out with him, watch a movie and go back home happily. Her body is violated because she is denied any kind of social standing as an individual. Rapists whether they are influenced by liquor or not, are obviously drunken by power of being a man.

Shame on you my gender. I am ashamed of calling myself a man because under the influence of alcohol I could turn into a brute. I could forget all those years of civilization and refinement for that momentary act of exercising power over a body which looks different from my own body. I see the beast in me and if I need to continue living I should kill that beast now, right now. Otherwise my place is in the jungle. I should be like Ashwathama, who has this unhealed wound on his forehead. I should have my wound between the legs, a blood dripping token of my brutality; a reminder of my unworthiness being a man in the refined world. Now, dear third gender friends, you should not let me in your tribe only because I am castrated because I don’t even deserve your painful existence because I am a man, a rapist.

(apologies to all those men who are not rapists)  

Tuesday, December 18, 2012

About Small Little Prayers

(Picture for representational purpose only)



In Ahmedabad it is not cold yet. Blame it on global warming. Years ago when I was here in this state of Gujarat, as a student I used to take a lot of pleasure in wearing jackets and sweaters because it was so exotic to be seen oneself in such clothes that were quite alien to your dressing pattern when you were living in a tropical place. Hot and humid days condition your body and a little bit of cold would pleasure you like a good foot massage. And you look good in sweaters and jackets. You prefer to keep them on even when you are feeling hot from inside. Today the climate has changed much. If at all people wear winter clothes here it is only because of some nostalgia or by habit; just the way you panic your train chugs into the platform or your flight is announced. You know very well that you have a confirmed ticket and your seat is assured. Still you panic. It is habit.

I go for walking wherever I am. It used to be jogging in the beginning. Slow and steady running, lungs refusing to cope up, silent visuals passing by you in a steady pace, unknown people crossing you or overtaking you, then the harmonious rhythm happening between your breath and the movement of legs. You become one and the same with your jogging. You can run kilometres without realizing the fatigue. You feel good when the breeze touches your ears and your shins feel the hardness of earth. Then one day your knees rebel and you shift to brisk walking.

So I go out of my hotel room. Though winter has become an old memory here, silk like darkness carries a whiff of cold in its invisible pores. I don’t find a park in the vicinity. So I choose to walk in a side road. I walk, dogs stare, milk mans cycles by, old people come out of darkness, graves of unsung Muslim saints spring up from nowhere, birds chirp, women was dirty vessels, devotees frantically beat their gongs, motor cars smile in their sleep, trees stretch their branches and a baby cries in a cradle. I feel someone is walking with me. I look around and see none. The feeling is so intense that I start talking to that person. I tell that presence about all those people walking at the same time in roads, parks, walkways, treadmills and in dreams in different parts of the world. I tell the presence about the amount of calories being burnt and mention about the fat and calories waiting on their dining tables to be consumed by them. I smile into a grey morning that has just pushed its limbs out of the blanket of darkness.

A dog looks at me keenly as it sees me talking to myself. But suddenly it remembers something and goes back to its puppies. She knows that these days people talk to others over invisible phones as if they were somnambulists making tele-conferencing. The road narrows down and I reach shanty and from there I reach a clearing where there is a temple and a few people who have just swarm out of their deep blue sleeps. They look wet by dreams and beaten by currents. Unseen words drip from their hairs. They speak to each other in hushed up tones.

I walk back as I feel that I am not welcomed in that area. I look a perfect stranger. I walk fast and the presence is no longer with me. I try to talk with the presence again in vain. I emerge to the main road as if I were coming out of a forest. The roads are already busy. Motor cars ply, shops open their eye lids and look out and with the pupils drawn up they look like blind people staring at the morning with some unknown purpose. My stomach rumbles and I feel like having a cup of tea. I walk along the main road looking for a chai laari. One is opened but the stove has not yet been lit. I walk past. I see an old woman sleeping on the pavement with her belongings kept within a thermocol packing tray. It must have been protecting a television set or a fridge. Now it is her home. Four walls made up of thermocol. Her sleep is sound as if she were a queen living inside a fortress protected by huge walls and armed eunuchs.

One chai laari is opened. The stove is lit. A pot on it steams. I ask the young man whether tea is ready. He picks up a milk pouch, cuts it open and pours it in the vessel which is already steaming. He gives me a smile and says yes. I stand there waiting for the first tea made by the young man. He has a young wife and two small kids. She smashes ginger pieces in a small steel vessel. Children eat some obscure biscuit. They seem extra obedient. The family looks very content on that pavement. A cot where the children sit and a few bundles summarise the worldly belongings of the family. The young man picks up an iron chair and places it for me on the pavement. I sit on it like the king of streets with no kingdom and no courtiers. And I feel a lot of happiness.

The young tea maker works like a magician. He throws a few spoonful of sugar in the boiling milk. Then he places a cloth over a steel vessel. He pours the thick solution which would be filtered in as tea over it. Then he pulls the four corners of the cloth to the centre to make it a sort of bundle and lifts it to the air. It looks like a pouch full of wet and hot secrets. The he takes out an iron pincer and squeezes the pouch. Tea that looks like muddy water hisses into the steel vessel. I think he would pour a glass of tea for me from it. He does not do it. He takes out two spoonfuls of it and pours it on the floor. It flows into the dirt below the lari. The he takes two small steel cups. He pours a glass of tea in it. Then he pours a glass of milk in the other cup. He walks across the road. And pours both on the concrete road divider in the middle of the road. Then he looks up to the rising sun and makes a gesture of supplication.

Immediately, all temples become irrelevant to me. All kinds of places of worship look nothing before that road divider. It looks like a majestic old tree or a totem pole lay horizontally. Road is his temple. Sun is the one that shines it. And at the pavement he lives with his family and tea is what brings him his humble subsistence. And what better offering could be offered by him to the gods of road where tired people come for a cup of tea? Which god he needs to worship? I feel overwhelmed. Soon a thought comes to my mind. Why did he waste those two cups of tea and milk? He could have given them to some poor needy people. But I rubbish my thought. It could be a very humanitarian act. But what about this idea of worshipping the unknown forces that rule his life, that keep him and his family safe?

He pours a cup of tea for me. I take it in my hands as if I were receiving a ritual offering taken from the feet of a deity. I drink it as if I was worshipping something that I don’t know yet or perhaps would never come to know. How is the tea sir, he asks me. I try to discern the taste? How does it taste? I don’t know. But I say, it is good. I pay him and walk back to my hotel room. Under my jogging shoes, all religions and the organized places of worship crumble like those nameless biscuits that those kids eat. 

Monday, December 17, 2012

Looking back at 2012

(JML)


Sit alone. Open the window blinds. Look down at the street. Motor cars ply. Cyclists peddle away their fatigue. People hurry along the pavements. Celebrities smile alluringly from hoardings. Sounds of various kinds fill in the ears. Then slowly sights and sounds fade. A blur overcomes the vision. An illuminated white space appears. Darkness surrounds. Something starts whirring behind. Columns of light pass over horizontally over the head. It is the theatre of life where one sees his or her life projected. It is a retrospective of the year that was. Twelve long months together named as 2012. Look at the watch. Time has just flown away like the migratory birds. They were there. But now the sky is clear. Days passed, weeks counted, months flapped, sorrows appeared like haunting ghostly shadows, joy threw colours as in the celebration of Holi and throughout all these despite the presences you realize that you have been all alone. What you see right in front of you is your life seen like a movie, produced, scripted, choreographed, filmed, edited and directed by you. But soon you recognize that it was not you, but someone was there with you. Otherwise who is there behind you operating that projection system? You call it God or your soul. It makes you introspect. Sit erect. Be vigilant. Get ready to critique yourself. That is the review of your life; life in 2012.

(Durbar Hall, Kochi where a part of KMB is happening)

Scene 1

Cold January in Chattarpur, New Delhi. Inside a crowded metro coach I see myself standing alone holding a bag full of books. One book is in my hand and I am reading. People talk, read and listen to music. I get down at Qutub Metro station. I carry the bag load of books and walk to my studio where I spend time reading and writing. I am happy the shelves in the studio are getting full with books. I look at them like a proud father looking at his children. Ram Kinkar Baij Retrospective curated by K.S.Radhakrishnan at the NGMA, New Delhi is one major event where I play a small part as an assistant curator.

I write blogs. I write articles on art. One of the blogs creates a controversy. In that I speak of the lack of transparency in using the government funds by a private agency which would conduct a Biennale in Kochi in the month of December 2012. People act and react. Friends turn foes and strangers become friends. Facebook becomes an active site of debate. I use all of my energy to defend my arguments. People accuse me of sour grape. Some accuse me of womanising. Some people go around and ask the influential people to shun me. One day I get a court notice that slaps me with Rs.250 Crores compensation case for defaming well known artists who are behind the Biennale. For the first time in my life I realize that I could be rich and pay that whopping amount of Rs.250 Crore to someone. My advocate sends a reply. It is very cold. I cover myself with a shawl. I feel alone. I keep smiling at myself.

February and March. The fight against corruption is on. I feel tired of the abuses that people hurl at me. I try to abuse them back. Anonymous people threaten me with dire consequences. Life goes on in facebook and elsewhere. Many artist friends move away from me. I recognize my true friends. They could be counted by finger. I see turn coats from both the genders. I see powerful people playing double game. Each time I feel helplessness I tell myself that I am not the only one and I am not alone.


Scene 2


(JML at Chandigarh Lalit Kala Akademy)

Life goes on in Chattarpur studio. I am happy there despite the pinching cold. By April things look really sunny. Someone had met me in January at the National Gallery of Modern Art. He had introduced himself as the initiator of an art fair called United Art Fair. In fact I had forgotten about that incident. I edit Art and Deal magazine. I could feel the momentum of its revival. The change in design and the new writers’ vigour; people start liking the magazine again. My days go by in reading and writing. I stop meeting people for the simple reason that I don’t want to listen negative stories about me. By this time I pull myself back from the Biennale debate.

One day I get a call. Some wants to meet me for some reason. I meet that person at the Cafe Coffee Day in New Friends Colony, New Delhi. He asks me to become the project director of the United Art Fair. I tell him that I am not interested. He insists and I tell him about my trip to Chandigarh to present at paper titled ‘Landscape After Battle’ at the Lalit Kala Akademy. Diwan Manna, the Chairperson of Chandigarh Lalit Kala Akademy has invited me. I go there. I am struck by the huge hoarding with my picture. They treat me like a hero. I feel good. I present paper. Make friends and come back. My phone rings again. United Art Fair person wants to meet me. He comes to the studio. He insists. I seek advice from my mentor, KSR. He gives a positive nod. I take the plunge.


Scene 3

May- September: I join the United Art Fair as the Project Director in May. Insist that we should travel and meet artists. I, with a team travel in fourteen different cities. Artists say they are helpless and they cannot pay money. The UAF changes strategy in June. It declares a free United Art Fair. Artists come in like flood.

June- July- August- The days of preparation. I do not sleep much. What make me tick are the thoughts about UAF. I stop reading and writing. I stop going to Chattarpur studio. I attend the UAF office religiously. A major facebook campaign starts for UAF. It becomes a huge hit.

 (From United Art Fair 2012)

September: United Art Fair takes place. Apparently it looks successful. Thanks to organizational faults, a few artists are not exhibited properly. Despite a few complaints the UAF becomes successful as a brand. It is an artists-driven art fair.


Scene 4

(JML)

October- One of the most stressful months. Post UAF soul searching. Self criticism and lonely days. Very few people are seen around.

November- I go back to Chattarpur Studio. My bags are full with books. I start reading and writing again. I feel I have mellowed down.

December- I take the decision to be free. I am no longer with the United Art Fair.





Scene 5

Credits roll: Ram Kinkar Baij Retrospective, Kulwant Roy Retrospective, Rabindranath Tagore Retrospective, Works of Chandan Gomes, Vicky Roy, Samudra Kajal Saikia, Neha Lavangia, Dhanur Goyal, Waswo X Waswo, Manisha Gera Baswani, United Art Fair, India Art Festival, Kochi Muziris Biennale (despite its shortcomings).

People: K.S.Radhakrishnan, Diwan Manna, Subodh Kerkar, Vandana Shukla, Somu Desai, Chintan Upadhyay, Rajendra Patil, Ajith Kumar G, my family and a whole lot of facebook friends.

Happening: God and Goddess manifestations in me.