(Hans Ulrich Obrist)
(Anil Ambani at Marathon Running)
The notable increase in curatorial educational projects has also strangely articulated the moment of educative learning as an authored curated space of knowledge production. this is really problematic for me and an example is the 24 hours interview marathon project of the curator Hans Ulrich Obrist. Obrist is a curator I admire greatly, but how the project is mediated suggests a kind of spectacularisation of the discourse as a public medium and an ownership of the frames of discursive productioin which I dont agree with. That is enormously different from say Free Copenhagen University, Paraeducation, 16 Beaver, Unitednationsplaza, Manifest 6 exhibition as school, Proto academy and so forth, projects that all emerged out of the initiator's immediate context and functioned as saemi-contained counter -public spaces.
--Paul O'Neill, Bristol based Researcher and Curator. Source oncurating.org
From a dossier circulated at one of the FICA Reading Room Projects.
Saturday, January 22, 2011
Friday, January 21, 2011
India Art Summit3: Aaam Aadmi’s Day In
India Art Summit Edition 3, 2011 (IAS). Welcome to the mother of all art fairs in India. Today, as far as the art scene in India is concerned all roads lead to Pragati Maidan, the permanent venue for all the national and international industrial exhibitions in Delhi. Art has not got industrial status yet. There are moves towards it. So wait for that. But there would be a problem. If you go by the old Marxian theories (ahem…we don’t want critics from the age of Dinosaurs), in any industry, there would be machines and alienated workers. Guess who would be the alienated workers in such a scenario.
Eighty four galleries and five hundred works of art. If you are healthy enough you can see all in one day. Even if someone would see all those exhibits in one go, I am sure he/she would come back on the next day not to absorb aesthetics but to absorb the ambience. You may be critical about the kind of art here, but you will be really proud of your ‘Delhi’, according to Girish Shahane, a place that ‘sucks’ all other metros dry. Hello Girish…good to see you here.
Winter and art. Delhi looks like any European city. To make it completely European, the government should disperse the population as in the ironical expression of Gigi Scaria in his work titled ‘Keep Delhi Clean’. Don’t look for it. It is not here in the IAS. Instead, a giant wheel constructed out of urban architectural motifs would welcome you right after the gate. Kudos to Gigi Scaria. This time luckily you don’t have too many imitators.
Young policemen behave extremely well. Only the private security personals will question you. The IAS makes every one very special. Each person inside and outside the Hall Number 18 at Pragati Maidan looks as if he/she is very important and is expected to play a very significant role in the art scene. Thank you IAS for making us feel responsible and good.
Last year Subodh Gupta’s masked figures welcomed you at the Sculpture park along with Iranna’s Dead Donkey, K.S.Radhakrishnan’s Selkit, Vibha’s Heaving Architecture and Jeff Gupta’s Ved Koon avatar..err sorry Ved Gupta’s Jeff Koon avatar. Hi Ved, you look smart in your retro hair do. But please remove those goggles once in a while to show your eyes to the public. At the Threshold Stall your painting sucks extremely. But your sculptures raise interest.
This year Subodh Gupta is predictable with his vessels filled rickshaw, though Nature Morte has a special solo booth for him. Mansoor Ali’s Dance of Democracy is special only because it is big. Akshay Rathode, have you seen Rimzon’s Far Away from Hundred and Eight Feet installation? If not please see it. Anjum Singh, why do you do forced installations? Adip Dutta, your cage made out of industrial steel wool does not surprise me. Graffiti filled Nano. Anybody heard about Ratan Tata and Narendra Modi? No inter-textual and intra-textual and sub-textual readings please…you sucking critic.
At Gallery 320, New Delhi’s stall I saw this sculpture. A suitcase with a Take on Art’s paper bag on it. I looked for the artist’s name. But soon I realized that it was kept there by some visitor. In IAS you will feel like looking for art in anything and everything.
I saw this Husain hidden behind a cabin under a layer of Souza’s drawings. SAHMAT people, don’t worry, Husain is ‘adequately’ represented this year.
Thank you Geetika Goel of the Delhi Art Gallery and Kanika of the Gallery Espace for giving me passes to ferry in the pass-less art students from Kerala. I had approached the IAS authorities to spare a few passes for those students. At the help desk none was there to help me. Finally one girl came who said she was ‘helpless’ as the pass distributing authority was someone else. Initially I thought of flashing my personal card to prove that I was some one in the art field. Then the years behind me (42 in total) prompted me to ask myself this question: Who are you, after all, an art critic?
The best that I noticed for the day: Gigi Scaria, Vivek Vilasini, Hans Op de Beeck, Sudarshan Shetty, Manjunath Kamath, Prajakta Potnis, Pors and Rao, Tukral and Tagra, G.R.Iranna (he strikes back with his paintings, Karl Antao and.. I will tell you tomorrow.
(The observations are purely personal. Poor quality photographs are by me)
Saturday, January 15, 2011
All Art is Contemporary Art- Really?
All Art is Contemporary- an invitation that I got from the Loft, Mumbai says. My initial response was this ‘Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi’. For those people who do not understand Hindi and what Ekta Kapoor does in Television, I will translate: Once upon a time Mother-in-law was also a daughter-in-Law.
Now connect these two statements. The Loft people say, All Art is Contemporary. And Ekta Kapoor says, Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi. For argument’s sake we should accept the truth value of these statements.
But then the issue is Saas cannot be always a bahu. She gets old, take stronger positions in family matters, from the door-mat status she gets elevated to the respectable ‘daadi-maa’ (grand mother), if not she becomes a weeping willow like Nirupa Roy. To put in normal words, Saas is saas because she is saas. She cannot be always bahu because time brings all changes.
Seen in the same way, all art cannot be contemporary. Like a Saas we have to see it in pre-modern, modern, post-modern and contemporary terms. Modern is modern because there is something called contemporary. Or, contemporary is contemporary because there is something called modern.
Contemporary is a word that shows the temporality of a scene. The immediacy of time that you share with your milieu is what makes your productions contemporary. You can paint like Raja Ravi Varma but then you will be called a pre-modern artist. Or you can paint like Souza, then you will be called a modern artist. If you instill certain contemporary elements into the Ravi Varma language, you will be called a contemporary artist.
Contemporary is a term of flux. Movements are in flux. Once they become settled, they are called schools. So we have contemporary pop movement or contemporary cutting edge movement but Baroda ‘school’ of art.
Modernism, in that case any thing that is qualified with classificatory terminology of (art) history, is an aesthetical and historical necessity for analysis. If you force all the –isms into one, you show two symptoms: one, you don’t know anything about history and historiography. Two, you know everything, but to sell your wares, you take this attitude, ‘I would stoop to any extent.’
Market makes right thinking people to behave funnily. They will even argue that Marxism is actually all about Economic imperialism, Arundhati Roy promotes militancy and M.F.Husain is a terrorist and so on. They can even argue that dog has four legs like a table. So Table is Dog and Dog is table. That’s vulgar logic.
All art is not contemporary. Contemporary art is supposed to be political in all sense and it contains all –isms; right from feminism to environmentalism.
You cannot force Benod Behari Mukherjee and Ravi Agarwal into one compartment and call them contemporaries only because both have loved looking at nature.
Then I saw this phrase in the same invitation- ‘Iconic Image’. Art is all about iconoclasm. A functional object becomes an art object when it is converted into icons. Each successive period attempts at breaking these icons. Henec an artist is an iconoclast. Modernism has a history of a series of iconoclasms. Post-modernism is all about the breaking of grand narratives into micro narratives. Hope you all heard of post-structuralist linguistics. This provided tools to the artists to deconstruct the grand narratives of all types.
How do you harness Tagore and Riyas to one yoke? Only by calling them all contemporary, would they become contemporary? If I use the same logic, shouldn’t I call Jamini Roy and Riyas by the same name- modernists or pre-modernists?
What’s happening here? To sell well will you kill all your Will to truth?
After reading this the Loft People must be quoting Deepika Padukone in Om Santi Om by Farah Khan:
‘Ek Chutki sindoor ki kimat tu kya jano Ramesh’
Translation: ‘JohnyML, what do you know about the pangs of a gallerist?’
Friday, January 14, 2011
Mild Terrors of Altered Objects
(Psychopathic Killer Fan)
Today evening my friend asked me about the shows that I am going to catch up in the coming days. Then he enquired about the venues. I told him, ‘get out of your home, get into your car and ask your driver to take to any direction. You will reach to a place/gallery where some art show is opening.’ I am not joking. In Delhi, in winter you have a spring; that is the spring of art. Consider Delhi as a tree and galleries as its branches, then you find each of them filled with flowers, I mean, works of art. The forthcoming third edition of the India Art Summit has made all the gallerists so alert that they all want to put up their best shows. And there is a lot of struggle in it.
(Newly Wedded Bucket)
So one day you start hopping between galleries. And you find a lot of interesting as well as boring works of art. It is just human tendency that during the bad times you think about the good times, the same way you think about King Fisher when you stand in the check in counter of the Indian Airlines. Hence, I think of an artist who is neither in the mainstream nor in the alternative stream. Someone recently asked me, ‘is there any alternative art?’ Yes, I told him immediately and added that alternative is the childhood of mainstream. Once alternative get matured or as the artist Alex Mathew once said about cats, when it grows facial hairs, it becomes mainstream. What about the art which does not have the hormonal support for growing facial hairs? I leave that to your imagination.
(Golden Broom)
Seriously speaking, I am thinking of my friend and artist C.K.Rajan. I don’t know whether Rajan accepts me as a friend because during the boom time relationships had gone for a toss everywhere. Recently C.K.Rajan had a solo show at the Galerie Mirchandani+ Steinruecke, Mumbai. Titled ‘Mad Furniture and Psychic Objects Part I’, this show was real treat to my eyes. And I am sure you also would find these works interesting, thought provoking without much laboring on the visual jargons.
(Ageing Question Mark)
C.K.Rajan studied painting at the painting department of the Faculty of Fine Arts, Baroda and later went to the Hyderabad University to do his post graduation. Ever since, he has been operating from Hyderabad. Born in 1960, Rajan lives a very different life. He is not the party hopping type and he is that kind of artist you tend to speak to in Hindi. Oh, yes it is like that. When you look at a person who does not have any airs on his educational background and does not pin up his laurels around his sleeves, you tend to speak to him in Hindi because you assume that he is a desi type. What a hypocrisy!
(Unemployed Axe)
If you look at the bio-data of C.K.Rajan you would see, he does not have too many shows to flaunt. He was a member of the Indian Radical Painters and Sculptors Association, popularly known as the Radical Group. Of late there are efforts from various intellectual quarters to call it ‘Kerala Radicals’. What a shame and this shame is supported by establishments run on the fuel of the University Grant Commission. Anyway, that is not our issue here. Rajan hit the scene with his ‘Mild Terrors’ in 1998, a time when the established and the struggling artists looked alike. So when Rajan came to exhibit at the Siddharth Hall of the Max Mueller Bhavan, New Delhi, nobody thought about his looks or complexion.
(The Silent Assassin)
‘Mild Terrors’ was an exceptional show because the whole show was made out of collages. They were not like the collages made out of grand imageries. They were simple and unassuming imageries collected from the discarded newspapers and magazines. And Rajan simply cut them and pasted them together and in the act he created a scene of terror both cultural and political before the viewers. Those collages told the viewer that as in a language, when certain syntactical rearrangement is done the meaning changes drastically and the shift in meaning reveals a terrible truth before us. And Rajan’s mild terrors were all about the terrible truths hidden like codes in the daily pictures. Rajan put them together as if they were the pieces of a jigsaw puzzle. And the show was noticed, of course not by the galleries, but the friends like us. Then it was dark age for Rajan…for a long time.
(The Corporate Pick Axe)
With the boom, Rajan was brought back. I say, Rajan was brought back because Rajan was always away and working. He did not care about what people thought about him or about his art. He did not even think what his friend thought about him. He was/is rustic in a very philosophical way. Those people don’t know Rajan personally would take him for an arrogant artist. But he is like that. He speaks truth with a smile and the truths that he spells out are very disturbing. Only solace is that Rajan uses tremendous amount of irony and pun in his works so that the truths hits you like music. It goes deeper into you but it does not hurt.
(The Absent Minded Cup)
Theories on Museumization of objects say that when a functional object is taken out of its functional context and defunctionalized and exhibited for philosophical contemplation, it achieves the quality of a work of art. In this sense, a work of art is a de-functionalized object incapable of performing anything of its own. The artist makes the functional into de-functional. This was what Duchamp did with his Fountain. But Fountain becomes a meaningless object when it is not interpolated with the author’s signature. In that sense, a de-functionalized object is like a patient. A work of art becomes a patient, observes Boris Groys and it needs the ‘curation’ either by the artist himself or by a curator. Rajan is an artist and a curator in this way.
(Seeking Ladle)
In ‘Mad Furniture and Psychic Objects’, Rajan defunctionalizes the functional objects through simple alterations on them. In fact he creates objects that show the possibility of being functional or herald their erstwhile functional status. But it is just an illusion. It is like a linguistic code that in fact does not exist. It gives a suggestion and also underlines the violence acted out on them in order to change the meaning and function. Rajan chooses the functional objects and adopts their basic forms for the alteration, almost the way a linguist approach a language. Then the form is re-articulated in a different fashion, almost evoking a feeling of fun and terror at the same time.
(Obsessive Compulsive Disordered Garden Cutter)
The titles of these works suggest the ironic and deliberate twist imposed on the language by the artist. In ‘Psychopathic Killer Fan’ one sees a fan in the middle of a room with long leafs filling in the room, thereby rendering both the room and the fan de-functional. But instead of being functional it becomes an object that could hurt, obstruct and divide human beings and objects. It is like a psychopath, whose linguistics of logic is altered in a different way. In ‘Newly Wedded Bucket’ you see a bucket looking like a mangalya sutra, wedding pendant. In ‘Ageing Question Mark’, Rajan plays between the political and social connotations of a sickle which has now become bent by age.
(Introvert Spade)
Each work has its pun, both visual and interpretational. When I exhibited Rajan’s work titled the ‘Silent Assassin’, a wrist watch with an unusually long strap, in a show curated by me titled, ‘Fly High My Beloved Birds’ in New Delhi in 2006, people asked me what was the relevance of that watch in the show. I told them to look at the watch and try to see what purpose did it served. They were offended and some even tried to pull the watch down from its display. I had felt a sense of elation as I could see people still getting offended by art, which did not have any political connotations. But the offended parties were just ordinary people who came to see the show only because they knew me as a friend. The gallerists in Delhi were not offended by Rajan’s work because they did not come to see the show.
(Enfant Terrible)
Time changes things. Rajan has not changed but his works have. So are the gallerists’ and curators’ approach to him. He does his work for his pleasure and purpose. That’s why Rajan could say in a work, ‘Time is Running Out’.
(Time Running Out)
Today evening my friend asked me about the shows that I am going to catch up in the coming days. Then he enquired about the venues. I told him, ‘get out of your home, get into your car and ask your driver to take to any direction. You will reach to a place/gallery where some art show is opening.’ I am not joking. In Delhi, in winter you have a spring; that is the spring of art. Consider Delhi as a tree and galleries as its branches, then you find each of them filled with flowers, I mean, works of art. The forthcoming third edition of the India Art Summit has made all the gallerists so alert that they all want to put up their best shows. And there is a lot of struggle in it.
(Newly Wedded Bucket)
So one day you start hopping between galleries. And you find a lot of interesting as well as boring works of art. It is just human tendency that during the bad times you think about the good times, the same way you think about King Fisher when you stand in the check in counter of the Indian Airlines. Hence, I think of an artist who is neither in the mainstream nor in the alternative stream. Someone recently asked me, ‘is there any alternative art?’ Yes, I told him immediately and added that alternative is the childhood of mainstream. Once alternative get matured or as the artist Alex Mathew once said about cats, when it grows facial hairs, it becomes mainstream. What about the art which does not have the hormonal support for growing facial hairs? I leave that to your imagination.
(Golden Broom)
Seriously speaking, I am thinking of my friend and artist C.K.Rajan. I don’t know whether Rajan accepts me as a friend because during the boom time relationships had gone for a toss everywhere. Recently C.K.Rajan had a solo show at the Galerie Mirchandani+ Steinruecke, Mumbai. Titled ‘Mad Furniture and Psychic Objects Part I’, this show was real treat to my eyes. And I am sure you also would find these works interesting, thought provoking without much laboring on the visual jargons.
(Ageing Question Mark)
C.K.Rajan studied painting at the painting department of the Faculty of Fine Arts, Baroda and later went to the Hyderabad University to do his post graduation. Ever since, he has been operating from Hyderabad. Born in 1960, Rajan lives a very different life. He is not the party hopping type and he is that kind of artist you tend to speak to in Hindi. Oh, yes it is like that. When you look at a person who does not have any airs on his educational background and does not pin up his laurels around his sleeves, you tend to speak to him in Hindi because you assume that he is a desi type. What a hypocrisy!
(Unemployed Axe)
If you look at the bio-data of C.K.Rajan you would see, he does not have too many shows to flaunt. He was a member of the Indian Radical Painters and Sculptors Association, popularly known as the Radical Group. Of late there are efforts from various intellectual quarters to call it ‘Kerala Radicals’. What a shame and this shame is supported by establishments run on the fuel of the University Grant Commission. Anyway, that is not our issue here. Rajan hit the scene with his ‘Mild Terrors’ in 1998, a time when the established and the struggling artists looked alike. So when Rajan came to exhibit at the Siddharth Hall of the Max Mueller Bhavan, New Delhi, nobody thought about his looks or complexion.
(The Silent Assassin)
‘Mild Terrors’ was an exceptional show because the whole show was made out of collages. They were not like the collages made out of grand imageries. They were simple and unassuming imageries collected from the discarded newspapers and magazines. And Rajan simply cut them and pasted them together and in the act he created a scene of terror both cultural and political before the viewers. Those collages told the viewer that as in a language, when certain syntactical rearrangement is done the meaning changes drastically and the shift in meaning reveals a terrible truth before us. And Rajan’s mild terrors were all about the terrible truths hidden like codes in the daily pictures. Rajan put them together as if they were the pieces of a jigsaw puzzle. And the show was noticed, of course not by the galleries, but the friends like us. Then it was dark age for Rajan…for a long time.
(The Corporate Pick Axe)
With the boom, Rajan was brought back. I say, Rajan was brought back because Rajan was always away and working. He did not care about what people thought about him or about his art. He did not even think what his friend thought about him. He was/is rustic in a very philosophical way. Those people don’t know Rajan personally would take him for an arrogant artist. But he is like that. He speaks truth with a smile and the truths that he spells out are very disturbing. Only solace is that Rajan uses tremendous amount of irony and pun in his works so that the truths hits you like music. It goes deeper into you but it does not hurt.
(The Absent Minded Cup)
Theories on Museumization of objects say that when a functional object is taken out of its functional context and defunctionalized and exhibited for philosophical contemplation, it achieves the quality of a work of art. In this sense, a work of art is a de-functionalized object incapable of performing anything of its own. The artist makes the functional into de-functional. This was what Duchamp did with his Fountain. But Fountain becomes a meaningless object when it is not interpolated with the author’s signature. In that sense, a de-functionalized object is like a patient. A work of art becomes a patient, observes Boris Groys and it needs the ‘curation’ either by the artist himself or by a curator. Rajan is an artist and a curator in this way.
(Seeking Ladle)
In ‘Mad Furniture and Psychic Objects’, Rajan defunctionalizes the functional objects through simple alterations on them. In fact he creates objects that show the possibility of being functional or herald their erstwhile functional status. But it is just an illusion. It is like a linguistic code that in fact does not exist. It gives a suggestion and also underlines the violence acted out on them in order to change the meaning and function. Rajan chooses the functional objects and adopts their basic forms for the alteration, almost the way a linguist approach a language. Then the form is re-articulated in a different fashion, almost evoking a feeling of fun and terror at the same time.
(Obsessive Compulsive Disordered Garden Cutter)
The titles of these works suggest the ironic and deliberate twist imposed on the language by the artist. In ‘Psychopathic Killer Fan’ one sees a fan in the middle of a room with long leafs filling in the room, thereby rendering both the room and the fan de-functional. But instead of being functional it becomes an object that could hurt, obstruct and divide human beings and objects. It is like a psychopath, whose linguistics of logic is altered in a different way. In ‘Newly Wedded Bucket’ you see a bucket looking like a mangalya sutra, wedding pendant. In ‘Ageing Question Mark’, Rajan plays between the political and social connotations of a sickle which has now become bent by age.
(Introvert Spade)
Each work has its pun, both visual and interpretational. When I exhibited Rajan’s work titled the ‘Silent Assassin’, a wrist watch with an unusually long strap, in a show curated by me titled, ‘Fly High My Beloved Birds’ in New Delhi in 2006, people asked me what was the relevance of that watch in the show. I told them to look at the watch and try to see what purpose did it served. They were offended and some even tried to pull the watch down from its display. I had felt a sense of elation as I could see people still getting offended by art, which did not have any political connotations. But the offended parties were just ordinary people who came to see the show only because they knew me as a friend. The gallerists in Delhi were not offended by Rajan’s work because they did not come to see the show.
(Enfant Terrible)
Time changes things. Rajan has not changed but his works have. So are the gallerists’ and curators’ approach to him. He does his work for his pleasure and purpose. That’s why Rajan could say in a work, ‘Time is Running Out’.
(Time Running Out)
Thursday, January 13, 2011
Malini Chib and Khushwant Singh: You Changed Me
I am a changed man in 2011. I am a changed man not because of the New Year resolutions that I had taken on the New Year eve. Yes, of course, I believe in the saying that one needs a resolution to make a revolution. But then, one needs to do a revolution unto oneself to make a resolution too. So neither did I make any resolutions nor did I attempt a revolution on that particular night. However, I am a changed man today; you may ask why? That is what exactly I am going to tell you now.
The two books that I picked up on two different occasions from the Mumbai and Delhi airport respectively caused all those changes in me. If you are a good reader with an eclectic taste for anything written/printed, airport bookshops are the best places from where you could pick up the books that you really enjoy reading. Hence, while returning from prolonged vacation in Goa, I picked up this book titled ‘Absolute Khushwant’ from Mumbai airport. After a few days, while I was on my way to Kerala, I picked up ‘One Little Finger’ written by Malini Chib.
My life changed considerably after reading those books. Though I am not going to delve deep into the writings of Khushwant Singh, the grand old Indian writer in English, I was deeply moved by a few statements made by him in the book. When a ninety four year old man speaks, he is all transparent. At that ripe age he does not have much to hide, nor does he have too many things to defend. All what he could do is to just look at his own shrinking body and the soul that ever expands like the vision of sky; infinite, limitless and deep.
Khushwant Singh does the same. He says, ‘Work is the cure of all ills’. When a man who writes for around eight hours a day without a fail even today, one could do nothing but believe. When he faces a huge set back, he tells himself, ‘It doesn’t matter.. I don’t give a damn!’ Yes, why should one give any damn to the adversities at all! So long as you enjoy what you do, why care? He quotes Nathaniel Cotton (1707-1788):
“If solid happiness we prize,
Within our breast this jewel lies,
And they are fools who roam.
The world has nothing to bestow;
From our own selves our joys must flow,
And that dear hut, our home.”
I am deeply touched by the line ‘they are fools who roam’. When the jewel is right here, why hunt for it in the yonder lands?
Khushawant Singh tells us about his life and relationships. He does not hide his political stance. He had supported the political emergency. But in a decade’s time he became a big critic of Indira Gandhi for supporting Bhindran Wala. Then he criticized the Congress for carrying out Operation Blue Star at the Golden Temple. Khushwant Singh adores only two people in his life and they are Mahatma Gandhi and Mother Teresa. He has written a touching note on Mother Teresa in this book. And Singh is highly critical of Nehru.
This is an autobiography compressed into two hundred odd pages. He says, ‘Don’t waste time. You don’t have time’. You are reminded of Vaikom Muhammad Bashir one of the best Modernist writers in Malayalam. Bashir said, ‘It is only in the treasury of God, there resides all time in the universe’. Then as in a great coincidence one of my artist friends sent me a link with the adieu of Gabriel Garcia Marquez, who is now in a French retreat, nursing his own loneliness and illnesses. As a parting note from the public life Marquez said, “If I take birth once again, I would do things better than the way I have done them in this life.”
I don’t approach books as self-help books though there are several of them in the racks. I believe any good literature is way and tool to happiness and self realization. Almost a decade back when I was down in the dumps, I happened to read ‘Who Moved My Cheese’ by Dr.Spencer Johnson. I was moved. I felt confidence. But when I read his next book, ‘The Gift’, I did not consider it any more a piece of motivational literature. Instead I approached it the same way I approached St.Excupery’s ‘Little Prince’.
Books talk of real people in their imaginary situations as well as imaginary people in their real situations. And if you are reading a gifted writer, you feel the imaginary world as real and the real world as imaginary. But when real people write about their real lives, you should be careful; you need a different approach. They are not here for literary flourish. They write these books because they want to tell the world about their lives. Writing is a performance; performance of life. When they perform in this way, they touch their own souls and they touch the souls of many others. They find friends in the virtual world of writing and reading. They motivate people in a different way. They give courage to people who feel frightened by life. If you call an autobiography the best form of motivational literature, I would say, yes, it is.
I like the lives of the ordinary people who are extra ordinary in their own ways. Malini Chib could have been another ordinary person. But she was/is different by birth. During the child birth, the umbilical cord got stuck her around her neck preventing the supply of oxygen to the infant’s brain. This incident later proved detrimental to her normal growth and she became a victim of a health condition called cerebral palsy. Those people affected by cerebral palsy have slowed down motor movements of the body if not complete disability in coordinating bodily functions.
Malini Chib could have been one of those people who are affected by cerebral palsy. But now she heads the event department of the Oxford Book House, Mumbai. At the age of forty four, Malini Chib is the head of the organization called ‘ADAPT’ (Able, Disable and All People Together), which she herself founded. She holds three international post graduations in Women Studies, Library Science and Information Management. She is wheelchair bound and writes with one little finger.
I bought this book only because I saw the picture of a wheel chair bound girl in the cover. When I flipped through the pages, I found her born in 1966. It is the same decade I too was born and I felt that she also would have grown up in the same India and experienced the same in India. I wanted to know how she felt like to be a disabled wheel chair bound woman in India in the pre and post-liberalized era.
What I liked about Malini Chib is her firm belief in the saying that nobody is totally independent or fully able-d. A wheel chair bound person might need an assistant to do the daily chores. But the so called able bodied people also need other people to carry out daily things. If a flush breaks down, you don’t repair it yourself. You call a plumber. When you carry a heavy bag, you call a porter. So who said we are all ‘independent’? Malini believed in this and she waged a strong war with life and she still wages it but now she is a different woman; many times able than the real able bodied ones like us.
Malini was lucky to have born in a rich family. Once she was diagnosed of cerebral palsy, her parents took her to London where she had a very protected schooling. But all the lucky people are not determined like Malini. Once back in Mumbai, she found herself in a different place with no disable friendly atmosphere. But she got her graduation in literature from St.Xavier’s in Mumbai. Her family stood with her so were her friends. Her mother established the first spastic society in India and soon many chapters were opened in all the metropolitan cities in India.
This book tells you about how cruel and apathetic we are when it comes to the people with different abilities. Most of the public buildings don’t have ramps so that the wheelchair bound people could ‘walk’ through. Everything is meant for the so called able bodied people. Malini recounts several incidents in which a person like her is treated like a ‘non-existing’ thing or a child. People speak of her condition in her presence without heeding her sentiments. In parties they just leave the disabled person alone. The public toilets are not friendly. The public transport system is not friendly.
Malini fights for these facilities even today. What touched me most was the recounting of a few incidents. Her brother took her for a vacation in Goa and after a couple of beers she wanted to ease herself. The brother and sister had to walk to a different place to find a disable friendly toilet, where the brother helped the sister in the toilet. Malini speaks of her need for love and caring from the opposite sex. She speaks out the sexual urges that a disabled person also feels. She speaks of her failed love affair. And above all she speaks of her continuous efforts to be independent. Today she give lectures all over the world, besides heading the event department of the Oxford book house in Mumbai. Also Malini heads the activities of the ADAPT.
‘Nothing about us without us’ is the slogan of the different abled people all over the world. Everything including the urban planning should be done taking the different abilities of the affected people into consideration. Malini works for it. Malini works for the women who are double incapacitated by physical deformity and gender. One cannot read this book without the feeling of the growing sense of love, respect and affection for the author as every page is turned.
I just remembered, when I finished the last word in the book with tears in my eyes, an incident happened in 2002. I had a few friends (still have) who are differently abled. I was living in London at that time pursuing a Masters Degree at Goldsmiths College. Wherever I went I saw disable friendly conditions. Even the smallest of the galleries had a ramp and a toilet with additional fitting for the disabled people. Inspired by these sights and also agitated by the sad plight of the Indian galleries at that time, I made an email campaign (there were no social networking sites then) demanding disable friendly conditions in each gallery in India. I cited that even the public establishments like the Lalit Kala Akademy, the NGMA and the National Museum did not have such facilities.
Many gallerists in India blocked me in their mailing list. Some people asked me never to write to them at all. Only one person in Indian artist responded positively to me then. It was a woman artist. Arpana Caur. She replied my mail with a lot of pride: “Look Johny, I have made ramp in my gallery at Siri Fort Institutional Area.”
I salute Malini Chib.
Tuesday, December 21, 2010
Growing Up with a Friend- To My Children 8
I don’t remember having too many close friends in my village. We all knew each other, we played together and shared a lot of things amongst us. But we were not close as there were certain restrictions I had in moving around with them all the time. They came to my home to play with me. I hardly went to play with them where they played very tough games. Most of them were tough kids and this toughness was the result of the general economy of the village. I was lucky to have the parents who were educated and employed in the government sector. It gave us a sort of insularity from the hardships that the children of my same age faced in their lives.
Vakkom was a backward village with no significant industries or job opportunities. People belonged to different castes lived in harmony as meager existence was common to all the households. Anchuthengu Fort (Anjengo in British documents) was across the backwaters and it was the place where the British settled during the colonial times and they used the fort as an administrative center as well as a business center. Attingal was under the Travancore kingdom and Maharani was the ruler of Attingal. And there are several reasons to believe that Vakkom was one place where all the socio-economically backward class and castes were pushed to reside.
E.M.Sankaran Namboothirippad (the ideologue of Indian Communist Party Marxist, CPM and the first Communist Chief Minister) in his book titled ‘Kerlam, the Motherland of Malayalis’ observes that the etymology of the name ‘Vaikom’ lies in its geographical position as a land retrieved from the water. One could apply the same logic in the case of Vakkom also. Vakkom should have been under water ages ago and thanks to the receding of sea a land portion might have come up. If you walk a kilometer from the main junction of Vakkom, you reach Anchuthengu Kayal (Anjengo Backwater) and if you cross it by ferry, you reach the Arabian seashore. If you go by the observations of EMS, one could easily find out that the early settlers in this area belonged to the fishing community and as coconut trees were abundant, the people who subsisted on the produces from these trees also might have settled here. Then came the other people as the communities developed around the sea and backwater needed other products for survival. The other people must have been living at the fringes of the Travancore kingdom as well as the sub-kingdoms like Attingal and so on. They found Vakkom and the places around it less prejudiced in terms of class and caste. This observation also justifies the presence of so many Muslims in this area and also the near absence of the Nair community that preferred to live near the seats of power as the Nairs formed the king’s armies.
Production of coir was the basic industry that we had in Vakkom during my childhood. Illustrious painter Raja Ravi Varma had chosen the Anchuthengu region to start a coir factory as he wanted to invest his wealth into an industry. I grew up in the vicinity of a coir factory, which was located a few paces away from my home. This factory was owned by a man named Anandan, a pious stocky man with a smear of sandal paste always n his forehead. He always wore white dhoti and white shirt, and most of the time he spent with the workers. Though the workers and the people in general addressed him as, ‘Anandan Muthalali’, which meant ‘Anandan, the Richman or the Business Man’, he was just like any other person in the village. His factory did not produce any coir product instead it produced coir mats, which were exported to different parts of the world. Besides the coir mats, this factory also produced coir bundles, which were later used for making many other coir products.
Though this coir factory was the hub of people’s life in my village, there seemed to be a limitation for Anandan Muthalali to branch out or expand his industrial operations. He basically remained as the producer of raw materials for coir products throughout his life. His business was connected to the main coir business center of Kerala, Aleppy (Alappuzha district) and from Aleppy two trucks came every weekend and collected the coir mats and bundles and drove away. We knew that the trucks were going to come as the workers spread huge coir mats along the road to give them a finishing touch and then roll them up into huge stacks. Right in front of the coir factory there was a long building and all the rooms in this building was used for making the coir bundles, which were called ‘mannu’. A few people well versed in making these bundles out of single coir threads. These rooms were mostly dark and at time we could see men sitting on the floor and arranging the single threads on the floor and at other times we could see them standing and rolling these single stacks with their legs while they held the tying pieces of coir like a leash in their hands. The rooms were always damp and there used to be a sharp smell; a mixture of damp coir and sweat. This was an art form in itself and now I don’t think too many people know this art of making coir bundles.
Our mornings and evenings were marked by the music of the coir factory machines and the heaving sounds of the people who worked in it. Coir making was a very long process and my occasional outings with some friends to these places where coir was made helped me to learn the process from the very beginning. These outings used to be hidden programs. My father did not like me hanging out with the workers’ kids not because he disliked them but because he thought that they would take me to certain places where the kids from ‘good families’ were not supposed to go. These places were ponds, paddy fields, backwaters, coir making fields and so on. The more we were restricted to go to these places the more we were interested to haunt such places. I had some partners in this conspiracy and they took me to these places directly from the school especially when the last period was free.
Coir making was/in interesting affair and the process was quite long. They separated certain shallow areas of the backwater with bunds and these demarked waters were called ‘Vattoms’ (Circles). The vattoms were meant for decaying the coconut husks collected from all over the village. There were middlemen to collect coconut husks from different houses. They paid a small amount for these husks and in the village economy everything was bartered for things or money. Husks were also collected from those people who made oil out of coconuts. There were ‘kopra kalangal’ (the coconut drying fields) and in these fields they peeled coconuts and each part was sold to different agents. The husks collected thus were brought into the vattoms where some people immersed them in the water around a stick. You could imagine it as an inverted hay/husk stack. It went a few feet deep into the water and was left to decay for a few months.
The people in the industry knew when the husk was ready to be taken out as some kind of smell emanated from these vattoms. And the vattoms are handled by certain people and they took the husks out carefully from the stack without it getting collapsed into the water. These decayed husks were taken to the ‘pakkalangal’ (literally means the fields where mats are made). These pakkalangal are the places where women worked. A certain number of decayed husks were given to each woman worker and they sat on the floor along the fringes of the field and using a wooden hammer called ‘kottuvadi’ (tapping stick) they made fine fibers called ‘chakiri’ out it. The outer peel of the husk was thick and once it was dried it was sold as a sort of firewood. A thick powdery stuff came out of these husks and it was called ‘chakirichhoru’ (rice of the fiber). This chakirichhoru was used as fuel when it was in the dried form or as manure or as a bund making material. The fiber thus made was then sent in bundles to a mill where it was cleaned in some crude machines. This refined chakiri was brought back to the pakkalangal where another set of women made small little bundles out of these and made coir.
The actual process of making the single coir thread started when these women made small bundles out of refined chakiri. At the one end of the pakkalangal there would be a series of ‘raattukal’ (spinning wheels) and at the other end there were a series of ‘kada vandikal’ (Churning Wheels). While raattukal were static, the kada vandis were movable. To make around twenty or twenty five meters of a single thread, three women were needed. While one woman (mostly a young working girl from the family) turned the handle of rattu, two women at the either end of the raatu fixed their chakiri bundle and walked backwards and as they walked the thread was formed along. These separate threads made by two women walking backwards were supported by some structures made in between on their reverse path. Once they reached the other end of the paakkalam, they together fixed the ends of their thread to a common peg in the kada vandi. Then one of the women took over the charge of the kada vandi and started spinning it while the other woman fixed a long triangular wooden tool with grooves on either sides (it is called Acchu) between the threads and walked forward towards ratttu. The woman at the kanda vandi rotated the shaft in clock wise and the girl at the rattu rotated her handle in anti-clock wise direction. In this way, once the woman with the acchu reached the rattu, a single coir thread of twenty or twenty five meters was created. Once she reached the rattu end, she made a shrill noise called ‘kookku’ (a sort of whistling) so both the women at the wheels reversed the rotation to give the coir an ample amount of strength and suppleness. After the kookku, the woman at the kada vandi pulled it back to its original position while the other woman took the thread off from the peg of the rattu and folded it in equal length according to the length of her hands across her chest and this measurement was called ‘maaru’ (literally means breast) and hung the coir at one stick. Then they repeated the process again. Each movement was so coordinated and in harmony with the movement of the others that not single moment was wasted in the process. This efficiency in working was developed as they were paid as per the number of maarus they had made in a day.
I used to go and sit at the paakkalangal. I watched these women working. They all knew me as ‘Lakshmanan sir’s son’ and they had a sort of love towards me which was tinged with a pinch of respect. I knew all the young girls who beat the husks along the fringes of the pakkalams. They used to give me an opportunity to beat the husks. While doing it I realized how difficult it was to lift a heavy wooden hammer like that and beat the husk continuously and rhythmically so that the fibers with the correct temper and fineness were made. These girls were very thin and they used to roll of their skirts till their thigh ends and their legs were mostly hidden by the chakirichhoru. At times you could not make out the difference between the color of the chakirichhoru and the complexion of their thighs. I liked to watch the women moving backwards and making coir. You could spend any number of hours there watching them at work. The older people who were not so agile used to take over when the maarus of coir are made. Their job was to dry them along the edavazhis. They did it with a lot of care and attention and if any boys rode their cycles or cycle tyres over them, these old people showered them with abusive words. A part of such coir threads was sent to the factory to make the mats.
The loom in which the coir mats were made was called ‘Thari’. There were two tharis of two different sizes in the factory. The smaller one made mats of four feet width while the bigger made the mats of eight feet width. To make a coir mat, they needed to prepare the coir as warp and weft. This coir for the warp and weft was prepared as spools that fed into the main spool of the thari. Making these spools was done in two different processes. The first one was called ‘Vandi Kettuka’ (means tying to a vehicle) and the second one is called ‘Unda Chuttuka’ (making balls). In the former process they made long coir threads out of the maarus and spun them around a wooden spool. Crude machines with rotating appendages and shafts were used for this. There was a special technique called ‘pirichu kuthuka’ (twist and tie) in order to join two coir pieces without making a knot. The two threads of one coir piece were forcefully separated and it was twisted with the similar loose end of the other piece. It demanded some kind of expertise otherwise it developed bumps, which killed the smoothness of the mats.
Unda Chuttuka was all about making small nest like coir bundles to fit into the ‘odam’ which was a sort of bobbin that the workers threw between the two layers of warps. Once these things were loaded in the tharis, the workers climbed on the thari platform. They all wear loin clothes and I was afraid that the shafts they alternatively pushed down with left and the right legs would somehow injure them at their groins. But the shafts were made in perfect lengths that they never hurt anyone. When the odam was threw from one and to the other it made a hissing sound and to complement it the worker at the other end who received the odam made another sound. Then they pushed the shaft down and with the hand they pulled a long horizontal wire mesh, which fixed the warp and weft permanently and strongly. A mat took weeks to months to finish. Once it was finished, they with a lot of festivities took the mat out of the spools and brought to the road. There used to be a demand for colored mats and during those sessions, they prepared red and green colors in huge vessels. They boiled the color and dipped the maarus in it before they were sent for vandi kettu and unda kettu. When the trucks came, the same workers helped the truck people to load the huge mats and bungles into the trucks. While hauling and heaving, they made sounds like ‘Abesh…aaria…aabesh …aaria’. And for children like us it was a spectacle and we stood near the factory to see them loading the truck.
You may wonder how I know all these things in their finer details. I owe all these knowledge to my childhood friend Sunil Lal, the one who took me to all these places, where, thanks to the poor economic condition of his family he worked at very tender age itself. Sunil Lal not only conducted me through things but also taught me to do whatever he did. He was the smarted of kids in the block. He was one year senior to me but we studied together till the tenth standard. He had one elder brother and one younger sister and they all lived with their parents in a small room across the road. These three kids almost grew up with me and my sister. When we were growing up my aunts and other relatives had shifted to other places and my paternal grandmother was left alone in the old house where I used to chase the golden eggs. So Sunil Lal and his brother and sister came to my grandmother’s house to spend the night. Actually they were giving company to the old woman. In return, they were given food.
Sunil Lal was not interested in studies. He was always looking for opportunities to do something. But my mother made him to sit with us and study. We had not even heard of mixers or grinders at that time. So we made the batter for idlis and dosas all by ourselves in a device made up of granite. Wet rice and wet uradu dal were put it in a cavity and a granite pestle called ‘kuzhavi’ was used to grind it. Once adequate amount of water was added the batter came up slowly. It took almost two hours to make one kilogram of batter. So once in a week it was we, the children came together around the granite grinder and worked on making the batter. We took turns to do it and Sunil Lal was an expert in making the batter. Next morning we all were given equal number of idlis or dosas. There was no discrimination between children.
In our village there was only one cinema theatre and it was called Sree Narayana Talkies. Black and White movies of the seventies came there after almost three or four months of their actual release in the city centers. We desperately wanted to catch up with these movies and we were not allowed to go on our own to watch movies. But when we were in the fourth standard, we got this opportunity to go and watch movies in this theatre once in a while. There were two shows every day and on Saturdays and Sundays there were three shows. And only on holidays we could go for the movie. The matinee started at 3 in the afternoon and got over by six in the evening and we got back home by 6.30. Sunil Lal and I were the team that always went to watch these movies.
Finding money for the ticket was a big issue for us. My father was not that lenient in giving us pocket money. And mother had to take permission from father to send us for movies. But my father was a Gandhian in certain sense. We needed fifty paise per person to buy tickets. With the fifty paise we could buy a ticket for the front rows where we seated on benches without backrest. So my father advised us to generate our own money by doing some works. So Sunil Lal and I used to create some ‘jobs’ for us. We cleaned the plot, plucked the weeds, cleaned the cycles, bathed our dog, Kuttan, took old newspaper to the market and sold them and cleaned the attic. And once these works were finished, my mother gave us lunch and father gave us fifty paise each and we rushed to the Sree Narayana Talkies.
I was afraid of the fights in the movies whereas Sunil Lal took all interest in fights. Even if there was a huge crowd, he somehow got the tickets once the counter opened. He elbowed his way through the crowd and interestingly we were hardly nine years old then. Sunil Lal had this habit of tying his knickers with a piece of coir around his waist. And he would tie it tight before he got into the crowd. Once inside the hall he untied the coir around his waist. As we sat on the first row we saw everything in ‘upclose and personal’. And we never wondered why all the images were distorted beyond a point. We thought that whoever sat behind us were fools and we caught the images before they could see it. Just behind the bench rows, there were a few rows of folding chairs, which was called second class and just behind those rows there were a series of cane chairs and that section was called ‘First Class’ or ‘Reserved Class’. I sat in the reserved class only when I went to watch a movie with my mother and whenever mother took us to a movie, without any doubt it was a religious movie. My father never came to watch movies with us. Instead, he came to pick us up from the theatre as mother was there and got us back home if it was dark. He went to the movies alone and he was a fan of Jayabharati, a very sexy actress of that time.
It was Sunil Lal who took me to the coir making fields and taught me the techniques of its making. His mother worked as a coir maker and his sister occasionally went to beat fiber out of the husks. His father worked in the coir factory as a mat maker. We called him uncle. Sunil Lal also worked in the factory as a Vandi Kettu and Unda Chuttal expert. He was just ten years then. And to make some extra money he lifted the coir bundles from the storage places to the main road where the trucks came to collect it. It was a very hard life for him but he never showed that he was suffering. He was always jovial and during the school years he was almost like my protector and body guard. My mother used to send our lunch boxes in his hand. She used to pack three lunch boxes equally; one each for me, my sister and Sunil Lal. We sat together and ate our lunch. Only difference was that we used steel tiffin carriers and his was made of aluminum. I wonder why my mother could not by one more steel tiffin for him!
In the coir factory, whenever I could squeeze permission from home, I learned the techniques of twirling the machines to make coir spools and undas. Sunil Lal conducted me around to tell me techniques of making the mats. His father also explained at things. Once in a while I visited these coir making fields with Sunil Lal. He took me to ponds and plucked lotus flowers for me. He could make garlands out of the tender stems of the lotus. He taught me to catch fish using a fishing rod, which he made himself. Also we collected small fishes from the streams using a piece of cloth and put them in glass beakers and watched them moving inside. We did several experiments together. On Fridays, there used to be a change in the movie at the Sree Narayana Talkies. After the school hours we waited before the projection room of this theatre to collect the clipped films.
These films were used for making our own film theatre. We made a projection system out of some discarded cardboard boxes. For a lens, we carefully removed the filament holder from fused electric bulb. Sunil Lal was an expert in crushing the innards of a bulb without breaking it. Anything dangerous attracted him. We filled water in the bulb and hung it inside the box. And in front of the bulb we placed the films one after another and using a broken piece of mirror we reflected sunlight into this box. The light passing through the bulb enlarged the film into four feet size on the wall and we took a great pleasure by doing it. We dug caves, we built make shift houses, we cooked rice in small pots all sourced from different houses and we were almost inseparable entities till we reached the school final.
By the time we entered the high school Sunil Lal had started washing cars in the market junction. While he washed the cars, he learned driving on his own. When we all passed and he failed in the tenth standard, he came up with this news that he was going to get married. At that time, he was working in a provision store in the market. This girl was a senior student in our school and she used to come to this shop to buy things. Slowly they fell in love and decided to get married. Hence, before any of us could think about a girl, Sunil Lal was married. Then I saw his different phases. He became a village terror as he joined a group of young thugs to terrorize the rich. Most of them were my classmates and they treated me with love and respect as I could go to college and study further. Even when they were active in the gang, I used to hang out with them. I never accepted him as a thug, I always treated him as a friend. I had seen him fighting in the street with a sharp sword in his hand. When I saw him, the fight had just got over the opponents had run away. He was high on drinks and anger. The moment he saw me, he walked up to me and asked me to go home as there were all the chances of police coming and picking them up. Then he went to gulf countries. There he did bootlegging, was incarcerated and deported. Once he came back, he joined the head load workers union in the market junction.
Today Sunil Lal’s children are grown up people and his son is now working in some gulf country. Whenever I visit my village, I go to meet him in a provision store where he works as a helper. And whenever trucks come to the market, he works as a head load worker. When I go to meet him, he takes permission from the shop owner and comes with me to have tea and chat up. If I have a few days in my village, he comes to meet me every night before he goes home. We stand near the gate in the darkness and try to remember those good old days. And in those moments we become those boys, Johny and Suni who used to explore the world together.
Monday, December 20, 2010
Archeology of Memories: A Mural Project by Ajayakumar
‘Archeology of Memories’ is a mural done by Ajayakumar. Former Kerala Lalit Kala Akademy Secretary and currently the Principal of Trivandrum Fine Arts College, Ajayakumar has been interested in combining personal mythologies and history in his painterly works. A strongly committed Marxist ideologue and pedagogue, Ajayakumar looks at history as a contestation between different social forces that results into the production of new materialistic and spiritual contexts. Ajayakumar interprets material contexts as the backdrop against which human beings construct their lives and spiritual context as the system of values that the human beings create in and around his products and actions. Hence, in his works one could perceive these contesting forces coming into play, often vivifying their struggle for supremacy and hegemony. And for him, portraying this struggle itself becomes a registration as well as a critique through painterly methods.
When Ajayakumar was invited by his young architect friend, Syriac to do a mural in his newly created village resort near Poovar, a few kilometers away from the city centre of Trivandrum, Ajayakumar thought of creating a series of images, which could represent and debate the violent interfaces between the local history and the history of colonial incursions in this region. Being a seashore village, Poovar had been close to the trading centers created by the colonial forces. The history of Kerala after the 13th Century AD is intricately connected with arrival of the Western forces along the sea coast of the state. Though it does not hold any visible remnants of erstwhile colonial presence, while watching the sea from the hill top where the resort is located one cannot help but wonder at the history of forced juxtaposition of cultures that has produced both good and bad results.
Micro histories constitute the macro history. But ironically, in the larger picture of macro histories, the small incidents get submerged and forgotten. The big picture does not allow the small pictures to emerge and tell the world how these small confrontations made all the difference. However, when an artist with a very inquisitive mind approaches the history with a purpose of analysis, he diligently digs up the micro histories of the location/place and region and highlights it against the larger narratives. When Ajayakumar came to Poovar in 2006 and saw the single unimposing structure that his friend had created as a central module of a future resort, he could connect immediately with the location and the small narratives that constituted the location as in the present. The liminality of the space, which is virgin and unarticulated, attracted Ajayakumar and today his mural, which took almost four months to finish tell us how the artist approached the places which had not been addressed earlier and how he could transform those areas into condensed narratives of materialistic and spiritual struggle of a people against the hegemonic forces.
The first image that hits the viewer/visitor/tourist is a combined image of three different civilizations; a combination of the perfect ratio as imagined by Da Vinci in the human form, the Egyptian civilization as represented in the Pharaoh-ic figure and the Asian civilization in the image of a standing Buddha that reminds one of the Bamian Buddhas. This unified figure does not need too much of clinical analysis as it tells the tale of civilizations that had been in confrontation with each other for ages. But here Ajayakumar does not become overtly critical about the hegemonic powers. Instead, he concentrates on the harmony of the three images and it is a way of telling the viewer that the contestations between the civilizations in fact create ‘culture’. But as an artist he is aware of the brutalities involved in this creation/production of culture. And these brutalities are symbolized in a series of seals with hieroglyphic inscriptions around the central figure. As the viewer proceeds towards his left, he could see war images. War often came by sea and then by land. Ajayakumar represents both these locations and also in different tiers he gives the suggestions of modern warfare. By bringing the modern and ancient war scenes in the upper and lower tiers of the building respectively, and also by suggesting the collapse of Iraq through the presence of a historical architecture, Ajayakumar forwards a critique on the imperialist forces that are still on rampage.
A closer look would reveal that all these wars are happening against religious structures. There is a subtle connotation that all the imperialist wars have got a religious justification as well as a religious backdrop. The inexplicable brutalities of the hegemonic wars are represented by a heap of human bodies in writhing positions. Above this heap one could see the disc thrower from the classical Greek sculptural tradition with a changed body posture aiming at something and he is set against the silhouette of a nuclear missile. Here Ajayakumar becomes clearly critical about the modern western civilization as an incursive force that aims at destroying the varieties of civilizations elsewhere and producing a steamrolled and unified culture.
Without making overt judgments on the so called pacifist nature of the Eastern civilizations, Ajayakumar compels the viewer to see an Egyptian scholar of the ancient times standing before two pyramids and revealing his findings to the world. He is positioned as a giver not as an aggressor. The artistic self could be seen in this surrogate image as this portion is clearly marked away from the war scenes.
In the upper tier of the front wall, the artist has rendered a narrative from a mythological story. This is the story of a serpent who wanted to swallow the celestial bodies like moon and sun. But in the process he was cut into two by the Gods. Ajayakumar uses this narrative in order to reinterpret it as a refined story of hegemonic aggression. The serpents were the low class people who wished to attain the higher positions through the ‘intake’ of the celestial knowledge as represented in sun and moon. But fearing their future positions, the scheming upper class, the Gods, cut them into pieces. Through the recounting of this story in his own visual format, Ajayakumar brings the class struggle also in the picture but without overtly pronouncing his political lineages.
On the other side of the building that faces the sea in a distance, Ajayakumar paints secular stories as if he were talking to a set of students about the beauty of the place. It is a soothing section with the images of mermaids, Apsaras, sea creatures, fishes, turtles, butterflies, peacocks and many small creatures. These images also constitute the archeology of memory, Ajayakumar feels. The nature around you, the creatures that crawl on the earth, the birds that sing, the mermaids that sing to allure, the butterflies that come to flit around your face and every other simple thing in our life are important. And in the final count these micro narratives stand against the macro narratives. And the pain of the people turns into mythologies and once you re-read those mythologies they tell you the stories that had never been written. In this sense, Ajayakumar’s ‘Archaeology of Memories’ is an enquiry into the liminal, the unwritten.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


































